The Disappearance of Lauren Spierer: A Night Out in Bloomington

Reading Time: 6 minutes ·

In the early hours of Friday, 3 June 2011, a 20-year-old Indiana University student walked out of a friend’s apartment in Bloomington, Indiana, and turned south down College Avenue toward her own apartment, two blocks away. She was barefoot, had no phone and no purse, and was badly intoxicated. She never made it home.

Her name was Lauren Elizabeth Spierer. Fifteen years later, no trace of her has ever been found — no body, no confirmed sighting after that short walk, no charge against anyone. Her last hours are documented in unusual detail, yet the record stops, abruptly, at a street corner at 4:30 in the morning.

Lauren Spierer

Lauren Elizabeth Spierer was born on 17 January 1991 in Scarsdale, New York, to Charlene and Robert Spierer; her father worked as an accountant. She graduated from Edgemont High School in 2009 and enrolled that autumn at Indiana University in Bloomington, where she was studying textiles merchandising. She was 4 feet 11 inches tall and weighed around 90 to 95 pounds.

She had met her boyfriend, Jesse Wolff, and her friend Jay Rosenbaum years earlier at Camp Towanda, a summer camp in Pennsylvania.

Spierer also lived with a serious medical condition: long QT syndrome, a rare heart condition that can cause sudden, dangerous irregularities in the heartbeat. Nine months earlier, she had been arrested on charges of public intoxication and illegal consumption.

On the night of 2 June 2011, the end of the semester, Spierer went out with friends. Wolff did not go out with the group; he stayed home and exchanged text messages with her before going to bed. According to witnesses, she was drinking heavily through the night.

The night of 2–3 June 2011

Bloomington police later reconstructed the night from surveillance footage and witness statements. The timeline is unusually precise — and it ends with a gap no one has been able to fill.

At about 12:30 a.m. on Friday, 3 June, Spierer left her apartment with a friend, David Rohn, and went to Jay Rosenbaum’s apartment, where she met Corey Rossman, a neighbour of Rosenbaum’s. At 1:46 a.m., cameras recorded her entering Kilroy’s Sports Bar, at 319 North Walnut Street, about a block east of her apartment. She left the bar with Rossman at 2:27 a.m., leaving her mobile phone and her shoes behind — she had taken her shoes off on the bar’s sand-covered patio.

Rossman walked with her to her apartment building, Smallwood Plaza, at 455 North College Avenue. At about 2:30 a.m., she was seen entering the building, where a passer-by asked if she was all right. She did not stay. At 2:48 a.m., she entered an alley between College Avenue and Morton Street; cameras recorded her leaving it at 2:51 a.m. Her keys and purse were later found along that route.

Spierer and Rossman then went to Rossman’s apartment, where his roommate, Michael Beth, was present. Rossman was heavily intoxicated and vomited on the way upstairs. Beth said he helped Rossman to bed, then tried to persuade Spierer to stay the night for her own safety; she said she wanted to return to her own apartment. At about 3:30 a.m., Beth telephoned Rosenbaum and asked him to look after her. At Rosenbaum’s apartment, he noticed a large bruise under her eye, apparently from a fall earlier in the evening.

At 4:30 a.m., according to Rosenbaum, Spierer left his apartment on her own. He said he last saw her at the intersection of 11th Street and College Avenue, heading south toward her apartment — a walk of about two and a half blocks. She was barefoot, wearing black leggings and a white shirt. He was the last known person to see her. She never arrived home. Hours later, Wolff texted her; the reply came from a Kilroy’s employee, who had her phone. He reported her missing.

The search

The search began almost immediately and grew rapidly. On 6 June, hundreds of volunteers joined a ground search of the Bloomington area. The disappearance was featured on America’s Most Wanted on 11 June, and national press coverage followed. Her parents travelled to Bloomington, offered a reward for information, and have kept the case in the public eye ever since.

In August 2011, police conducted a nine-day search of the Sycamore Ridge Landfill in Pimento, south of Terre Haute, where Bloomington’s rubbish is taken. The Bloomington Police Department, the Indiana University Police Department and the FBI all took part, and more than 4,000 tons of refuse were sifted. Nothing was found. Despite the scale of the effort, no confirmed trace of her has ever surfaced.

The investigation

Investigators have pursued several leads over the years, and each has ended without an answer. In April 2015, Bloomington police examined a possible link to the murder of another Indiana University student, Hannah Wilson, who had gone missing on 24 April 2015 after visiting Kilroy’s — the same bar Spierer had visited — and whose body was found the next morning in Brown County. A local man, Daniel Messel, was arrested and later convicted of the murder. In July 2015, police concluded that the two cases were unrelated.

On 28 January 2016, the FBI and other agencies searched a property in Martinsville, about 20 miles north of Bloomington, connected to a man named Justin Wagers. Cadaver dogs indicated potential evidence, and anthropologists dug and sifted soil from a barn where the dogs had reacted. They found nothing, and no connection to Spierer was established.

Messel has never been charged in connection with her case. Police have said the case is still active, and they have never named a suspect. The four men Spierer spent the evening with — Rossman, Rosenbaum, Beth and Wolff — have been described as persons of interest, not suspects, and none has been charged with any offence connected to her disappearance.

The questions that remain

With no body and no crime scene, the case has always turned on theories, and each of them has gaps.

One theory is that Spierer died accidentally — from an overdose, a heart event linked to her long QT syndrome, or a fall — and that someone concealed what happened. Rosenbaum told investigators she had consumed alcohol, cocaine and crushed Klonopin tablets that evening, and police later found a small amount of cocaine in her room. Spierer’s parents have said they believe their daughter is dead, and her father has said the family felt somebody could have slipped something into her drink at Kilroy’s. Police have addressed rumours that she may have overdosed and that those with her hid her body, but no evidence supporting that account has ever been made public.

Police have also not ruled out abduction by a stranger. Spierer’s parents have said they do not believe her disappearance was a random abduction, and have voiced suspicion about the men she was with that evening, noting that they declined police-administered polygraph tests and retained lawyers soon after she vanished. The men say they took private polygraphs, as well as one from the FBI, and retained lawyers because they did not trust the Bloomington police. The parents have made no specific accusations, only that they believe the men know more than they have told police.

In June 2013, Spierer’s parents sued Rossman, Rosenbaum and Beth for negligence, arguing that they supplied Spierer with alcohol after she was already visibly intoxicated and then failed to make sure she returned safely to her apartment. A federal judge, Tanya Walton Pratt, dismissed the suit against Beth in 2013, finding he had no duty of care toward Spierer, and dismissed the suits against the other two men in 2014. The parents appealed, and the dismissal was upheld by a federal appeals court in 2015.

A family that would not stop

Whatever happened in the early hours of 3 June 2011, the case has had a lasting effect beyond Bloomington. Her parents became vocal advocates for missing-persons reform, and in 2013 Indiana passed “Lauren’s Law”, which requires law enforcement to begin an investigation immediately when a person is reported missing and may be in danger, without any mandatory waiting period. Her case has also been cited as an example of missing white woman syndrome — the disproportionate media attention given to some missing-person cases.

Fifteen years on, a 20-year-old student left a friend’s apartment at 4:30 on a June morning, two and a half blocks from home, and was never seen again. The cameras that followed her through the night stop at a street corner. The friends who were with her have been interviewed again and again, and have never been charged. The searches — of streets, a landfill, a property twenty miles away — found nothing. Lauren Spierer’s family does not know what happened to their daughter, and the file at the Bloomington Police Department remains open.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Lauren Elizabeth Spierer, 20, an Indiana University sophomore studying textiles merchandising, disappeared in the early hours of 3 June 2011 in Bloomington, Indiana. Cameras place her entering Kilroy’s Sports Bar at 1:46 a.m. and leaving with Corey Rossman at 2:27 a.m., leaving her phone and shoes at the bar. She was last seen at about 4:30 a.m. at 11th Street and College Avenue, barefoot, in black leggings and a white shirt, walking toward her apartment; she never arrived. She had long QT syndrome, and Rosenbaum told investigators she had consumed alcohol, cocaine and crushed Klonopin tablets that evening. A nine-day landfill search in August 2011 found nothing; 3,060 tips had arrived by May 2013. Police ruled the Hannah Wilson murder unrelated in July 2015, and a 2016 FBI search in Martinsville found nothing. Civil lawsuits against Rossman, Rosenbaum and Beth were dismissed in 2013–2014 and upheld on appeal in 2015. Indiana passed “Lauren’s Law” in 2013. No body has been found and no one has been charged.

Unverified or unproven: That Spierer died of an accidental overdose, a heart event, or a fall — her condition and the substances she took that night are documented, but what happened after 4:30 a.m. is unknown, and no evidence of a fatal accident has been found. That she was drugged at Kilroy’s — her parents have raised this, but it has not been established. That any of the men she was with knows more than they have told police, or was involved — the parents believe this, the men deny it, and none has been named as a suspect or charged. That Daniel Messel or Justin Wagers was connected to her disappearance — neither has been charged in connection with her case.

Sources

Leave a Comment