On the afternoon of Saturday 19 August 1978, 13-year-old Genette Tate set out on her bicycle to deliver newspapers around the village of Aylesbeare, in Devon. It was a paper round she had covered for about a year, a 45-minute circuit of quiet country lanes between Aylesbeare and the surrounding farms. She knew the roads well enough to ride them without thinking. At about 3:30 p.m., she stopped to chat with two friends on Withen Lane. Minutes later, her bicycle was found lying in the road, the newspapers scattered across the tarmac. Genette was gone.
Her father, John Tate, reported her missing at 5 p.m. that evening. Devon and Cornwall Police launched one of the largest searches in the county’s history. They found nothing: no footprint, no sign of a struggle, no witness who had seen anything after the moment her friends had passed her. A small wooden cross was placed at the spot where her bicycle had been found. Genette’s body has never been found, and her case remains one of Britain’s longest-running missing person inquiries — and one of its most haunting.
A summer afternoon in Devon
Genette Louise Tate was 13 years old, living with her parents in Aylesbeare, a small village in east Devon, not far from Exeter. She was a reliable, sensible girl, and her paper round was a regular Saturday job. The route took her along Withen Lane and the surrounding country roads, past farms and cottages, in an area where everyone knew everyone else and a child on a bicycle was an ordinary sight.
The afternoon of 19 August 1978 was warm and ordinary. Genette set off on her round as usual, and at about 3:30 p.m. she paused to talk to two friends on Withen Lane. They were the last people to see her. A few minutes later, another pair of girls came along the lane and found Genette’s bicycle lying in the road, its wheels still spinning, the newspapers strewn around it. There was no sign of Genette, and no sign of anyone else.
The details of that moment have been retold so often that they have become part of the case’s legend: the spinning wheels, the scattered papers, the empty lane. What they meant, in plain terms, was that something had happened suddenly, and that Genette had not had time to react — or had not been given the chance.
The search
Devon and Cornwall Police launched a search on a scale the county had never seen. Hundreds of officers, volunteers, and search dogs combed the fields, woods, and lanes around Aylesbeare. Helicopters searched from the air. The investigation accumulated thousands of witness statements and interviewed hundreds of people. It produced nothing: no body, no clothing, no trace of a vehicle, no credible sighting.
For eleven years, the case produced no viable suspect and no body. Because there was no body, there was no confirmed cause of death, and without a cause of death there was no crime to prosecute. In the precise language of the law, the case remained a missing-persons inquiry rather than a murder investigation, even though everyone involved believed that Genette had been taken and killed. The absence of a body did something specific to the case: it removed the clock. There was no deadline, no trial date, no resolution — only a file that stayed open, year after year.
Robert Black
The first real suspect emerged more than a decade after Genette vanished, and he emerged from another case entirely. Robert Black was born in Falkirk, Scotland, in 1947, and raised in local authority care after his mother gave him up in infancy. He had convictions for sexual offences against children from an early age, and he worked as a delivery driver, driving a van all over Britain.
On 14 July 1990, in the Scottish Borders village of Stow, a member of the public watched Black bundle a six-year-old girl, Laura Turner, into his Transit van. He was arrested, and the investigation that followed linked him to the abduction and murder of three young girls: Susan Maxwell, Caroline Hogg, and Sarah Harper. At Newcastle Crown Court in 1994, Black was convicted of all three murders and received ten life sentences. In 2011, he was convicted of a fourth murder, that of Jennifer Cardy in 1981.
Genette’s case had been flagged as a probable Black crime almost from his arrest. The pattern fitted: a young girl taken from a quiet road, a delivery driver who travelled the country, a man who had been making deliveries in the south-west of England in 1978. In 1996, an eyewitness claimed to have seen a vehicle of the model Black was known to have driven in 1978 at Exeter Airport on the morning Genette disappeared. But police inquiries were unable to establish that Black had been in Aylesbeare on the day, and in August 2008 the Crown Prosecution Service decided that there was insufficient evidence to charge him with Genette’s murder.
The case that almost was
Devon and Cornwall Police did not give up. In June 2014, they reviewed the case again, in the hope of finding enough evidence to prosecute Black. The review was thorough: a 500-page file was compiled, and the force prepared to submit it to the Crown Prosecution Service with a recommendation to charge. There were reports that Black had once told a prison guard that he had visited Aylesbeare, even correcting the officer when he misheard the name — a detail the police took seriously, though it was never tested in court.
At the time of Black’s death, on 12 January 2016, the police were five weeks away from submitting the file. The file was submitted in April 2016, but the Crown Prosecution Service said that, because Black was dead, there would be no posthumous decision to charge him. The service’s policy is that it does not charge dead suspects, and so the case against Black — the only designated suspect Devon and Cornwall Police have ever named — was never put to a jury.
John Tate, Genette’s father, has said publicly that he is not even sure Black did it. In August 2018, on the eve of the 40th anniversary of his daughter’s disappearance, he made a further appeal for information, saying: “I am not even 100% sure Black did it. I need proof that Black killed her.” It was a remarkable statement from a father who had waited forty years: not a demand for vengeance, but a demand for certainty.
What remains
Genette Tate’s disappearance remains one of Britain’s best-known unresolved cases. Devon and Cornwall Police describe it as a murder investigation, and they have been clear that Black was their only designated suspect. But without a body, without a charge, and without a trial, the case has no ending. The wooden cross still stands at the spot on Withen Lane where her bicycle was found, and her father has kept the appeal alive for nearly half a century.
The case is also a reminder of how much has changed since 1978. There were no mobile phones, no CCTV on country lanes, no DNA database. A child could be taken from a Devon lane in the middle of a Saturday afternoon and leave almost nothing behind. Modern policing would have more to work with. In 1978, the police had a bicycle, some scattered newspapers, and two girls who had spoken to Genette minutes before she vanished. It was not enough then, and it has never been enough since.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Genette Louise Tate, aged 13, disappeared on 19 August 1978 while delivering newspapers in Aylesbeare, Devon. She was last seen at about 3:30 p.m., after speaking to two friends on Withen Lane; her bicycle was found shortly afterwards in the lane with newspapers scattered around it. Her father reported her missing at 5 p.m. Devon and Cornwall Police launched one of the largest searches in the county’s history and found no trace of her. Her body has never been found. Robert Black, a delivery driver convicted in 1994 of the kidnap, rape, and murder of Susan Maxwell, Caroline Hogg, and Sarah Harper, and in 2011 of the murder of Jennifer Cardy, was questioned in connection with the Tate case. In August 2008 the Crown Prosecution Service decided there was insufficient evidence to charge him. Devon and Cornwall Police reviewed the case in June 2014 and prepared a file seeking a decision to charge; Black died on 12 January 2016, and the Crown Prosecution Service said there would be no posthumous charging decision. The case remains open and is described by police as a murder investigation.
Unverified or unproven: That Robert Black killed Genette Tate is the police’s belief, not a finding of any court. No evidence has ever placed Black in Aylesbeare on 19 August 1978, and the reported sighting of his vehicle at Exeter Airport that morning has never been confirmed. The reported remark by Black to a prison guard about visiting Aylesbeare is second-hand and was never tested in evidence. Any claim that Genette’s body was found, or that DNA evidence linked Black to her, is false — her body has never been found, and no DNA match has ever been reported. Genette’s father himself has said he is not certain Black was responsible.