Doc Holliday: The Dentist, the Gambler, and the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral

Reading Time: 6 minutes ·

John Henry Holliday was born to be a dentist. Trained and qualified before twenty-two, the son of a Georgia doctor, he died at thirty-six in a Colorado hotel room, a professional gambler with tuberculosis, famous for thirty seconds of gunfire in a Tombstone back lot. The record is more interesting than the legend: a sick young man who expected to die, who made his living at cards because his coughing drove dental patients away, and who became a gunman because, in the towns where he gambled, a reputation for violence was a form of job security.

A Georgia dentist with months to live

Holliday was born on 14 August 1851 in Griffin, Georgia, to Henry Burroughs Holliday, a doctor and Civil War veteran, and Alice Jane McKey Holliday. His mother died of tuberculosis on 16 September 1866, when he was fifteen; he had nursed her through her illness, and historians believe he contracted the disease while tending to her.

In 1870 he left Georgia for the Pennsylvania College of Dental Surgery in Philadelphia, receiving his Doctor of Dental Surgery degree on 1 March 1872 at twenty. He returned to Georgia and opened his own practice in Griffin, but shortly after beginning practice in 1873 he was diagnosed with tuberculosis — the disease that had killed his mother. He was given only a few months to live. That diagnosis set the course of the rest of his life.

West: cards, guns and a failing practice

In September 1873 Holliday left for Dallas, Texas, to partner with Dr. John A. Seegar. But coughing fits steadily drove his patients away. Holliday discovered skill at gambling, and it soon became his principal source of income. It also put him in rooms full of armed men with money on the table: he was indicted for illegal gambling in Dallas in May 1874, and arrested after trading gunfire with a saloon keeper in January 1875. No one was hurt, and he was acquitted.

Over the next few years he drifted through the West, dealing faro in Denver, Cheyenne, Deadwood and Breckenridge. In July 1877 in Breckenridge, gambler Henry Kahn shot the unarmed Holliday and seriously wounded him. At Fort Griffin, Texas, while dealing cards at John Shanssey’s saloon, he met Mary Katharine Horony, known as “Big Nose Kate” — as far as the record shows, his only known relationship.

The friendship with Wyatt Earp

In October 1877 Wyatt Earp, then a deputy U.S. marshal, came to Fort Griffin hunting outlaws led by “Dirty” Dave Rudabaugh, who had robbed a railroad camp in Kansas. Shanssey suggested Earp ask Holliday, who had played cards with Rudabaugh; Holliday said he thought Rudabaugh was headed back to Kansas.

The most famous story of that friendship comes from Dodge City in the summer of 1878. According to later accounts, Earp walked into the Long Branch Saloon to confront armed cowboys who had shot up the town, and found himself facing a room full of guns. Holliday, playing cards in the back, was said to have put his pistol to one cowboy’s head, forcing the men to disarm. Earp credited Holliday with saving his life that day. No contemporary newspaper account exists, and the details differ between versions — but Earp believed Holliday had saved him.

Tombstone and the road to Fremont Street

In October 1879 Wyatt Earp arrived in Las Vegas, New Mexico, bound for the silver boom in Tombstone. Holliday and Horony travelled with the Earp party to Prescott, arriving in November; Holliday stayed there, the gambling better, while the Earps went on to Tombstone.

Holliday joined the Earps in Tombstone in September 1880, a town split by a bitter feud between the Earps — Virgil, the city police chief, with his brothers Wyatt and Morgan — and the Cochise County Cowboys, led in effect by Ike Clanton, who had the support of County Sheriff Johnny Behan.

In March 1881 a stagecoach carrying silver bullion was held up between Tombstone and Benson, and the driver, Eli “Budd” Philpot, and a passenger, Peter Roerig, were killed. After a drunken argument in which Holliday threw Horony out, Behan and saloon owner Milt Joyce persuaded her to sign an affidavit implicating Holliday. But the Earps found witnesses who could place Holliday elsewhere, and a sober Horony admitted she had been pressured into signing. The district attorney dismissed the charges, calling them “ridiculous”. On 25 October 1881 Holliday clashed with Ike Clanton in a Tombstone saloon, and by the next afternoon armed Cowboys were gathered in town in violation of a city ordinance.

The gunfight at the O.K. Corral

On the afternoon of 26 October 1881, Virgil Earp, city police chief and deputy U.S. marshal, deputized Holliday and called on his brothers Wyatt and Morgan. Their orders were to disarm the Cowboys. On Fremont Street they met Sheriff Behan, who told them — or implied — that he had already disarmed the men. Virgil handed Holliday a short coach gun to conceal under his long coat.

The lawmen found the Cowboys in a narrow lot on Fremont Street, between Fly’s boarding house and the Harwood house — not inside the O.K. Corral itself. What followed lasted about thirty seconds. Accounts of who fired first differ between witnesses and have been argued over ever since. The outcome is established: three Cowboys were killed — Tom McLaury, Frank McLaury and Billy Clanton — and Virgil and Morgan Earp and Holliday were wounded. Holliday shot Tom McLaury with the concealed coach gun, and was himself grazed by a bullet. Ike Clanton and Billy Claiborne fled unharmed. A thirty-day hearing found the lawmen had acted within their duties.

The Vendetta Ride

In December 1881 Virgil Earp was ambushed and permanently maimed. In March 1882 Morgan Earp was ambushed and killed while playing billiards. Wyatt Earp, newly appointed a deputy U.S. marshal, deputized Holliday, his brother Warren, Sherman McMaster and “Turkey Creek” Jack Johnson as a federal posse. While escorting the wounded Virgil to a train for California, the posse found Frank Stilwell, a suspect in Morgan’s murder, lying in wait in Tucson. Stilwell was killed — Wyatt said later in life that he had shot him. A Tucson justice issued arrest warrants for five of the posse, including Holliday. The posse rode on, killing Florentino “Indian Charlie” Cruz on 22 March 1882, and Curly Bill Brocius at Iron Springs two days later. Within weeks the posse had left Arizona for New Mexico and then Colorado. Wyatt and Holliday, fast friends for five years, quarrelled and parted ways in Albuquerque in April 1882.

Colorado and the end

On 15 May 1882 Holliday was arrested in Denver on the Tucson warrant for the murder of Frank Stilwell. Wyatt Earp, fearing his friend would not receive a fair trial in Arizona, asked Bat Masterson, then Trinidad’s chief of police, to intervene. Masterson had fraud charges drawn up against Holliday in Colorado. On 30 May, Governor Frederick Walker Pitkin, persuaded that the Arizona papers were faulty, refused the extradition. Holliday was released on bond in Pueblo two weeks later.

His remaining years in Colorado were a slow decline, his tuberculosis worsening as he increasingly depended on alcohol and laudanum to ease its symptoms. His last known confrontation came in Leadville in August 1884, when he shot bartender William J. “Billy” Allen over a $5 loan. Allen survived, and Holliday was acquitted in 1885 on a claim of self-defence.

In 1887, badly ailing, Holliday made his way to the Hotel Glenwood in Glenwood Springs, hoping the hot springs would help. He died in his bed on 8 November 1887 of tuberculosis, and was buried that afternoon in Linwood Cemetery, though the exact site of his grave is uncertain. His nurses reported his last words as “This is funny” — he had always expected to die with his boots on — though whether he actually said it cannot be proved. In 1896, Earp summed him up: “He was a dentist whom necessity had made a gambler; a gentleman whom disease had made a vagabond.”

The legend and the man

Holliday’s reputation was already larger than the facts in his own lifetime: he was said to have killed more than a dozen men. Modern researchers, working from court records and coroners’ reports, have concluded he killed between one and three. The O.K. Corral gunfight accounts for most of that count, and even there, who fired the fatal shots is disputed. Holliday was not a mass killer, and he was not, for most of his life, an outlaw at all. He was a trained professional whose body failed him. The tuberculosis that was supposed to kill him in months took fourteen years to do it.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: John Henry Holliday was born on 14 August 1851 in Griffin, Georgia, and received a Doctor of Dental Surgery degree on 1 March 1872; diagnosed with tuberculosis shortly after beginning his dental practice in 1873; indicted for illegal gambling in Dallas in 1874; met Wyatt Earp in 1877; Earp credited him with saving his life in Dodge City in 1878; on 26 October 1881 in Tombstone, Arizona, Holliday, deputized by Virgil Earp, took part in the gunfight near the O.K. Corral in which Tom McLaury, Frank McLaury and Billy Clanton were killed and Holliday was wounded; a thirty-day hearing found the lawmen had acted within their duties; he rode with Wyatt Earp’s federal posse in the Vendetta Ride of March 1882; arrested in Denver in May 1882 and extradition was refused by Governor Pitkin; shot Billy Allen in Leadville in 1884 and was acquitted in 1885; died of tuberculosis at the Hotel Glenwood, Glenwood Springs, on 8 November 1887, and was buried in Linwood Cemetery, where the exact site of his grave is uncertain.

Unverified or unproven: That Holliday killed more than a dozen men — modern researchers conclude he killed between one and three; that he saved Wyatt Earp’s life in the Long Branch Saloon in Dodge City in 1878 — no contemporary newspaper account exists; that he killed Johnny Ringo in July 1882 — the inquest ruled Ringo’s death a suicide, and records place Holliday in Colorado at the time; that his last words were “This is funny” — this rests on the nurses’ account alone; that the man in the famous Tombstone portrait attributed to C. S. Fly is Holliday — his identity is disputed; that Holliday fired the shot that killed Frank Stilwell — accounts conflict, and Wyatt Earp said in later life that he himself shot Stilwell.

Sources

Leave a Comment