At 5:17 a.m. on 6 June 2015, a corrections officer doing a bed check at the Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora, New York, found something wrong in two cells on the Honor Block. The beds were occupied — or seemed to be. Under the blankets were dummies, fashioned from sweatshirts. The men who should have been in those beds, Richard Matt and David Sweat, were gone.
It was the first escape from the maximum-security section of Clinton in a hundred years. Clinton, founded in 1845, is one of the oldest and largest maximum-security prisons in New York State, a walled fortress in a small Adirondack town about 40 miles south of the Canadian border. Matt and Sweat had not climbed over its walls. They had gone through them — and under them — in a tunnel they had spent months cutting, with tools smuggled in by a prison employee.
Two murderers and a tailor shop
Richard Matt, 49, was serving 25 years to life for the murder of his former boss, William Rickerson, in 1997. David Sweat, 35, was serving life without parole for the murder of Broome County Sheriff’s Deputy Kevin Tarsia in 2002. Both were housed on Clinton’s Honor Block, a privileged unit whose residents had access to cooking stations, televisions, wall-mounted telephones and card tables. Both worked in the prison’s tailor shop.
The shop was supervised by Joyce Mitchell, a 51-year-old civilian employee who had worked at Clinton since 2008 as an industrial training supervisor in the prison’s clothing manufacturing division. Mitchell grew close to both men, and especially to Sweat. Starting in February 2015, she began smuggling contraband into the prison for them: hacksaw blades, chisels, food, and even lighted glasses to help them work in the dark tunnels beneath the prison. She hid the tools in frozen hamburger meat. In April, she began smuggling in the things they would need once they were on the run, and the plan took shape: she would meet them outside the walls and drive them away.
Over more than three months, Matt and Sweat cut holes in the backs of their cells, gaining access to the maintenance catwalks and utility tunnels behind and above them. They worked at night and returned their tools to the prison’s toolboxes before morning. The tunnels beneath Clinton had not been inspected since the mid-1990s, when the inspections were discontinued to save money. No one was watching the route they were cutting.
Their way out ran through an idle steam pipe, 18 to 24 inches wide, that led beneath the prison’s perimeter wall to a manhole about 400 feet beyond it, in the village of Dannemora. The manhole cover was chained to a ladder with a padlock they had to break. Sweat made a solo trial run the night before the escape and made it outside. On the night of 5 June, both men made their final descent, crawled through the pipe, and emerged through the manhole into the night. They left a note behind in the pipe, taunting their captors: “Have a nice day.”
The manhunt
Mitchell was supposed to meet them at midnight. She did not come. According to a relative, she developed chest pains and was taken to hospital; she later said she had panicked. Whatever the reason, Matt and Sweat were on foot, in the woods of northern New York, with no car, no clothes and no plan B.
The manhunt that followed was one of the largest in New York history. More than a thousand officers from state police, the FBI, the U.S. Marshals and the National Guard searched the Adirondack woods. The cost was later put at about $23 million. Roadblocks went up across Clinton and Franklin counties. Residents were told to lock their doors. For three weeks, the two men stayed ahead of the search, moving at night, breaking into cabins for food and shelter.
The search ended in the last week of June. On 26 June, Matt was shot dead by a U.S. Border Patrol tactical team near Malone, New York, about 35 miles west of the prison, after he was spotted in the woods and refused to drop a shotgun. Two days later, on 28 June, State Trooper Sergeant Jay Cook spotted Sweat walking on a road near Constable, New York, close to the Canadian border. Cook chased him into an open field and shot him as he tried to run. Sweat survived, was taken into custody, and was later transferred to the Midstate Correctional Facility in Marcy, New York, where he remains. He received an additional sentence of three and a half to seven years for the escape.
Three weeks in the woods
The manhunt that followed the escape was one of the largest in New York history. More than a thousand officers from the state police, the FBI, the U.S. Marshals Service and the National Guard searched the Adirondack woods around Dannemora. Roadblocks went up across Clinton and Franklin counties. Bloodhounds worked the trails. Residents were told to lock their doors and stay inside. The cost was later put at about $23 million.
Matt and Sweat stayed ahead of the search for three weeks, moving at night and breaking into cabins for food, clothing and shelter. They split up as the net closed. On 26 June, Matt was spotted in the woods near Malone, about 35 miles west of the prison, and was shot dead by a U.S. Border Patrol tactical team after he was seen carrying a shotgun and refused to drop it. Two days later, Sweat was spotted walking on a road near Constable, close to the Canadian border, by State Trooper Sergeant Jay Cook. Cook chased him into an open field and shot him as he tried to run. Sweat survived, and was taken into custody. Cook was hailed as a hero by the governor.
The escape itself had been, in its way, a masterpiece of patience. Over more than three months, two men had cut through steel and concrete with hand tools, in the dark, in tunnels no one had inspected for twenty years, and had left behind dummies in their beds and a note in the pipe that read “Have a nice day.” What they had not planned for was the simplest thing of all: the person who was supposed to drive them away did not come. The tunnel worked perfectly. The getaway did not.
The reckoning
Joyce Mitchell was arrested on 12 June 2015, while the manhunt was still under way, and charged with providing material assistance to the escapees. She pleaded guilty in September 2015 to promoting prison contraband and criminal facilitation, and was sentenced to two and a third to seven years in prison, fined $6,375, and ordered to pay about $79,841 in restitution for the damage caused by the escape. She served four years and two months and was released on parole from the Bedford Hills Correctional Facility in February 2020. She has denied a romantic or sexual relationship with either man, but admitted she had discussed hiring Matt to kill her husband, and admitted smuggling the tools that made the escape possible.
A corrections officer, Gene Palmer, was also charged with providing tools to the inmates, and pleaded guilty to promoting prison contraband.
The escape exposed serious failures at Clinton. Tunnel inspections had been abandoned for cost reasons. The Honor Block’s privileges had given two convicted murderers the time, the tools and the privacy to cut their way out. And a civilian supervisor had been able to smuggle in hacksaw blades hidden in frozen meat for months without detection. The state ordered a review of security at all of its maximum-security prisons.
The story became a national sensation, and in 2018 it was dramatised in the television series Escape at Dannemora. But the real story is simpler and stranger than any drama: two men, a tailor shop, a steam pipe, and a plan that depended entirely on a woman who, at the last moment, did not show up. The tunnel worked perfectly. The getaway did not.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: On 6 June 2015, Richard Matt and David Sweat were discovered missing at a 5:17 a.m. bed check at the Clinton Correctional Facility in Dannemora, New York. They had cut holes in their cell walls, travelled through utility tunnels and a steam pipe, and exited through a manhole about 400 feet outside the prison wall. Joyce Mitchell, a tailor shop supervisor, pleaded guilty to smuggling them tools and was sentenced to two and a third to seven years in prison; she was released on parole in February 2020. Matt was shot dead on 26 June 2015 near Malone, New York; Sweat was shot and captured on 28 June 2015 near the Canadian border. The manhunt cost about $23 million. Sweat received an additional three and a half to seven years for the escape.
Unverified or unproven: Why Mitchell failed to meet the escapees at midnight — she was hospitalised with chest pains according to a relative, and has said she panicked; no single account has been confirmed. The exact nature of Mitchell’s relationships with Matt and Sweat — she has denied any romantic or sexual involvement, though she admitted discussing a plan to have her husband killed. Whether other prison staff knew about the escape plan beyond the two employees charged.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2015_Clinton_Correctional_Facility_escape
- https://www.adirondack.net/history/clinton-correctional-facility-prison-escape/
- https://www.aetv.com/real-crime/joyce-mitchell-now?source=realcrime&platform=twitter&postid=sf145882349&sf145882349=1
- http://www.oxygen.com/dannemora-prison-break/crime-news/joyce-mitchell-now-david-sweat-richard-matt-what-to-know