On 21 February 1965, Malcolm X was about to speak at the Audubon Ballroom in Harlem, New York, when gunmen opened fire. He was 39 years old, one of the most powerful voices in the civil rights movement, and he had broken with the Nation of Islam the year before — a break that had made him enemies inside the organisation he had helped to build. He died that afternoon. Within days, the police had arrested three men, all members of the Nation of Islam: Talmadge Hayer, Muhammad Aziz, and Khalil Islam. All three were convicted of murder in 1966. And one of them, Hayer, said from the start that the other two were innocent.
Hayer, who was arrested at the scene, admitted that he had been one of the shooters. But he insisted that Aziz and Islam had nothing to do with the killing. Aziz and Islam said the same thing. Both men had alibis: they said they had been at home in the Bronx when Malcolm X was killed. The jury did not believe them. On 11 March 1966, all three men were found guilty of murder and sentenced to life in prison.
The Doubts
The doubts about the convictions began almost immediately and never went away. Hayer repeated his account for decades, naming other men as his accomplices and saying again and again that Aziz and Islam were innocent. Historians who studied the case found that the prosecution had relied on witnesses whose testimony was unreliable, and that evidence supporting the alibis had not been shown to the defence. In 2011, the historian Manning Marable’s biography Malcolm X: A Life of Reinvention argued that the shooters had come from a mosque in New Jersey, not from the circle that included Aziz and Islam.
In February 2020, Netflix broadcast a six-part documentary, Who Killed Malcolm X?, which made the case for the two men’s innocence in detail and named other men as suspects. The series was watched widely, and within days the Manhattan District Attorney, Cyrus Vance Jr., announced that his office would reopen the investigation.
The Reinvestigation
The reinvestigation, conducted over 22 months by the district attorney’s office together with the Innocence Project, examined FBI and police files that had not been available at the trial. What it found was damning. The FBI and the New York Police Department had withheld evidence that pointed to other suspects and supported the alibis of Aziz and Islam. Some of the witnesses against them had been FBI informants, a fact that had been kept from the defence. Testimony from a witness who supported Aziz’s alibi had been withheld. The investigators concluded that if the evidence they had found had been shown to a jury in 1966, Aziz and Islam would probably not have been convicted.
On 18 November 2021, Manhattan Judge Ellen Biben dismissed the convictions of Muhammad Aziz and Khalil Islam and vacated the judgments against them. Aziz, then 83, stood in court with his family and his lawyers for the moment. Islam had died in 2009, still carrying the conviction. Hayer, by then known as Mujahid Abdul Halim, was 80, and when he learned of the exoneration he told a reporter, “God bless you. They’re exonerated.” In October 2022, New York City agreed to pay $26 million to settle lawsuits brought on behalf of the two men, and the State of New York added $10 million — $36 million in total, divided between Aziz and the estate of Islam.
The Questions That Remain
The exoneration answered one question and left others open. The reinvestigation did not name any additional shooters beyond Halim, and it did not determine who ordered the assassination — a question historians have debated for sixty years. The FBI’s surveillance of Malcolm X, the Nation of Islam’s internal conflict, and the role of informants in the case are all part of a larger story that has never been fully told.
Malcolm X’s legacy has grown since his death. His autobiography, written with Alex Haley and published in 1965, is one of the most widely read books in American history. The Audubon Ballroom, where he was killed, is now the Malcolm X and Dr. Betty Shabazz Memorial and Educational Center. And the exoneration of Aziz and Islam has become one of the most significant wrongful-conviction cases in American history — a reminder that a verdict is not the same as the truth, and that the truth can take more than half a century to arrive.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Malcolm X was killed at the Audubon Ballroom in Harlem on 21 February 1965. Talmadge Hayer (later Mujahid Abdul Halim), Muhammad Aziz (then Norman 3X Butler), and Khalil Islam (then Thomas 15X Johnson) were convicted of murder on 11 March 1966 and sentenced to life. Hayer admitted his role and maintained that Aziz and Islam were innocent; both men maintained their innocence and offered alibis. In 2020, Manhattan District Attorney Cyrus Vance Jr. reopened the case. On 18 November 2021, Judge Ellen Biben dismissed the convictions of Aziz and Islam after a 22-month reinvestigation found that the FBI and the NYPD had withheld exculpatory evidence. Islam died in 2009. In October 2022, New York City and New York State agreed to pay a total of $36 million in settlements.
Not documented / unverified: Who ordered the assassination of Malcolm X has never been established by a court or an official investigation, and the reinvestigation did not name additional shooters beyond Halim. The identities of the other gunmen have been suggested by historians and in the 2020 documentary, but those identifications have not been tested in court and should be treated as allegations, not findings. Claims about the FBI’s role in the assassination itself, as opposed to its withholding of evidence, are matters of historical debate, not established fact.