Martha Elizabeth Moxley was 15 years old and a high-school student in Greenwich, Connecticut. She lived with her family in Belle Haven, an affluent neighbourhood of large houses and quiet streets. On the evening of 30 October 1975, the night before Halloween, she went out with friends in the neighbourhood. She did not come home. On the morning of 31 October, Halloween morning, her body was found in the yard of her family home, beneath a pine tree. She had been killed the previous night. A golf club was identified as the weapon used in the attack. She was 15, and her death became one of the most widely publicised murder cases in American history, not only because of the crime itself, but because of who was eventually charged with it.
The investigation began immediately, but it produced no arrest for nearly a quarter of a century. Greenwich police interviewed neighbours, friends and family members, and examined the scene, but the physical evidence was, in the words the Connecticut Supreme Court would later use, sparse. No DNA or fingerprints tied any named individual directly to the attack, according to later reporting on the court record. The case remained open and unsolved through the 1970s, 1980s and 1990s, while Martha’s family waited for an answer that did not come.
The neighbour who became the defendant
Among the people interviewed in the early investigation were members of the Skakel family, who lived nearby in Belle Haven. Michael Skakel, then 15, was a neighbour of Martha Moxley’s and a cousin of Robert F. Kennedy Jr., through his aunt Ethel Kennedy, the widow of Senator Robert Kennedy. That family connection would later dominate coverage of the case, and it is important to separate it from the evidence itself: a family connection is not evidence of guilt, and the courts that dealt with the case treated it as background, not as proof.
The 2002 trial and conviction
In January 2000, almost 25 years after Martha’s death, Michael Skakel was arrested and charged with her murder. Skakel’s trial took place in 2002 in the Stamford–Norwalk Judicial District. The prosecution’s case relied heavily on witness accounts and on alleged statements by Skakel, rather than on forensic evidence. Witnesses testified that Skakel had spoken about the killing at various times over the years, including during a stay at a treatment centre for troubled teenagers in Maine in the late 1970s. The defence argued that those statements were unreliable, that Skakel had an alibi for the night of the murder, and that the prosecution’s witnesses were not credible. Skakel maintained his innocence throughout.
On 7 June 2002, after three days of deliberations, a jury of 12 found Skakel guilty of murder. On 29 August 2002, he was sentenced to 20 years to life in prison. He was 41 years old at the time of his conviction. For Martha Moxley’s family, the verdict brought a measure of closure after 27 years. For Skakel and his family, it was the beginning of a long series of appeals. The case had been tried in the glare of national publicity, and both sides would later argue about whether that publicity, and the conduct of the trial itself, had affected the outcome.
Appeals, reinstatement and vacatur
The appeals took more than a decade. In 2013, a Connecticut judge granted Skakel a new trial, finding that his trial lawyer, Mickey Sherman, had provided ineffective assistance of counsel. The judge found in particular that Sherman had failed to present a potentially significant alibi witness. Skakel was released from prison in 2013 on $1.2 million bail, having served 11 years. He has remained free since.
The state appealed, and the case moved to the Connecticut Supreme Court. On 30 December 2016, the court ruled 4–3 to reinstate Skakel’s conviction, reversing the order for a new trial. That decision did not end the matter. The court reconsidered the case, and on 4 May 2018 it reversed itself, vacating Skakel’s conviction and ordering a new trial, again on the ground of ineffective assistance of counsel. The 2018 decision meant that the 2002 conviction no longer stood, and that Skakel was, in law, no longer a convicted murderer, although he had not been acquitted. A vacated conviction is not a finding of innocence; it is a finding that the trial was flawed in a way that requires a new trial.
That new trial never took place. On 30 October 2020, the 45th anniversary of Martha Moxley’s murder, the state of Connecticut announced that it would not retry Skakel for her murder. The Chief State’s Attorney, Richard Colangelo Jr., said prosecutors had decided not to seek a second trial, citing the age of the case and the difficulty of obtaining reliable testimony so many years later. The case was dismissed, and Martha Moxley’s killing remains officially unsolved.
What the record shows
Documented: Martha Elizabeth Moxley (16 August 1960 – 30 October 1975), aged 15, was killed in the yard of her family home in Belle Haven, Greenwich, Connecticut, on 30 October 1975, and found on the morning of 31 October 1975. Michael Skakel, also 15 at the time and a neighbour, was arrested in January 2000 and charged with her murder. On 7 June 2002, a jury convicted him of murder, and on 29 August 2002 he was sentenced to 20 years to life in prison. In 2013, a Connecticut judge granted him a new trial on the ground of ineffective assistance of counsel, and he was released on $1.2 million bail. On 30 December 2016, the Connecticut Supreme Court ruled 4–3 to reinstate the conviction. On 4 May 2018, the same court reversed itself, vacated the conviction and ordered a new trial. On 30 October 2020, the state announced it would not retry Skakel. Martha Moxley’s killing remains officially unsolved.
Disputed or unverified: Whether Skakel killed Martha Moxley has not been finally determined by a court, because the 2002 conviction was vacated and no retrial took place. A vacated conviction is not a finding of innocence, and the 2002 verdict is not a standing finding of guilt. The prosecution’s case relied largely on witness accounts and alleged statements, and the Connecticut Supreme Court described the physical evidence as sparse, with no DNA or fingerprints tying Skakel or any other named individual directly to the attack. Claims in books and in later reporting about who was responsible should be treated as allegations and interpretations, not as court findings. This article takes no position on Skakel’s guilt or innocence.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Martha_Moxley
- https://www.cnn.com/us/michael-skakel-fast-facts?cid=external-feeds_iluminar_meta
- http://www.history.com/this-day-in-history/june-7/michael-skakel-convicted-of-1975-murder-in-greenwich
- https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Greenwich_Town_Hall_(Connecticut)_(53922089390).jpg