Catherine Susan Genovese, known as Kitty, was 28 years old and worked as a bar manager in New York City. She lived in Kew Gardens, a quiet residential neighbourhood in Queens. In the early hours of 13 March 1964, she was returning home from work, driving her red Fiat to the apartment building where she lived. She parked, got out of her car and walked towards her door. She was attacked outside the building by a stranger, Winston Moseley, a 29-year-old man from Manhattan. The attack took place in two stages, separated by about ten minutes: an initial attack on the street, after which Moseley left, and a second, fatal attack in a stairwell inside the building, out of sight of almost everyone outside. Genovese died on her way to hospital. A friend, Sophia Farrar, went down to the stairwell and held her as she died.
The murder itself was solved quickly. Six days later, Moseley was arrested during a house burglary, and while in custody he confessed to killing Genovese. His trial began on 8 June 1964 and ran until 11 June, presided over by Judge J. Irwin Shapiro. Moseley initially pleaded not guilty, but his lawyer later changed the plea to not guilty by reason of insanity. The jury found him guilty of murder, and on 15 June 1964 he was sentenced to death. On 1 June 1967, the New York Court of Appeals reduced the sentence to life imprisonment, finding that Moseley should have been able to argue that he was medically insane at the sentencing hearing. He remained in prison for the rest of his life, was denied parole 18 times, and died in prison on 28 March 2016, at the age of 81, having served 52 years. He was one of New York State’s longest-serving inmates.
That is the documented core of the case: a woman killed by a stranger, a confession, a conviction, and a life sentence served in full. But the case is not remembered for those facts. It is remembered for a newspaper story published two weeks after the murder, and for the claim in that story that has shaped psychology textbooks for sixty years.
The story that made the case famous
On 27 March 1964, The New York Times published an article by Martin Gansberg under the headline “37 Who Saw Murder Didn’t Call the Police”. The article’s own opening line gave a different number: “38 respectable, law-abiding citizens in Queens watched a killer stalk and stab a woman” for more than half an hour, it said, in three separate attacks, and not one of them had called the police during the assault. The 38 figure stuck, even though the headline said 37. The Times’ metropolitan editor, A. M. Rosenthal, expanded the account into a short book, Thirty-Eight Witnesses: The Kitty Genovese Case, published later in 1964.
The story became a national scandal and a founding case for a new field of research. Social psychologists Bibb Latané and John Darley read the Gansberg account and used it as the motivating case for what became known as the bystander effect: the finding, tested in experiments from 1968 onwards, that a witness to someone in trouble is less likely to intervene when other witnesses are around than when alone. In their best-known experiment, participants who believed they alone had heard a stranger having a seizure reported it 85 per cent of the time, against 31 per cent of those who believed four others could hear it too. The Genovese case was the anecdote that opened the door to that research, not itself a piece of experimental evidence. But for decades, introductory psychology courses taught the 38-witness story as if it were established fact.
What later investigation found
The reassessment began with the trial record itself. In 2007, psychologists Rachel Manning, Mark Levine and Alan Collins published an analysis in American Psychologist, “The Kitty Genovese murder and the social psychology of helping: The parable of the 38 witnesses”. Working from trial records, police files and contemporary reporting, they concluded that there was no evidence that 38 people watched the murder, no evidence that those who were aware of it saw the attack itself, and no evidence that witness inaction caused her death. They described the story explicitly as a parable — something taught for its moral clarity rather than for its accuracy — and noted that it had been repeated uncritically in psychology curricula for decades.
The other parts of the original story also failed to hold up. There were two attacks, not three, and the fatal second attack happened inside a stairwell, out of the view of almost everyone. At least one neighbour did call the police after the first attack, and another call was made as well, according to police records examined in later research. The claim that nobody called the police until after Genovese was dead is therefore not supported by the record. At trial, only five residents of the apartments overlooking the street testified, and only three of them had seen Genovese and Moseley together. The assistant district attorney at the trial, Charles Skoller, was later quoted as saying that prosecutors had found “about half a dozen” people who had seen what was going on. No list of 38 witnesses has ever been made available.
What the record shows
Documented: Catherine “Kitty” Genovese, 28, a bar manager, was killed outside her apartment building in Kew Gardens, Queens, in the early hours of 13 March 1964, in two attacks about ten minutes apart; the second, fatal attack took place in a stairwell. Winston Moseley, 29, was arrested six days later during a burglary and confessed in custody. He was tried 8–11 June 1964, found guilty of murder, and sentenced to death on 15 June 1964; the sentence was commuted to life imprisonment on 1 June 1967. Moseley died in prison on 28 March 2016, aged 81, after 52 years, having been denied parole 18 times. The New York Times published Martin Gansberg’s article “37 Who Saw Murder Didn’t Call the Police” on 27 March 1964, its text claiming 38 witnesses. In 2007, Manning, Levine and Collins concluded in American Psychologist that there was no evidence for 38 witnesses, for witnesses observing the murder, or for total witness inaction. In 2016, The New York Times called its own reporting flawed and said it had grossly exaggerated the number of witnesses and what they had perceived.
Disputed or unverified: The claim that 38 people watched the murder and did nothing is disputed and is not supported by the trial record; the figure appears to have come from a police tally of people interviewed, not of eyewitnesses. The exact number of people who saw any part of the attacks is not settled — secondary accounts give figures from two to about a dozen — and this article does not state a single figure as proven. The original article’s claim of three attacks is contradicted by the record, which shows two. The claim that nobody called the police during the assault is contradicted by police records showing that calls were made.