Dick Turpin: The Highwayman Who Became a Legend

Reading Time: 8 minutes ·

Ask most people in Britain to name a highwayman, and they will name Dick Turpin: a masked rider on a black mare, galloping through the night from London to York, a gentleman thief who robbed the rich. It is one of the most durable images in English popular culture. Almost none of it is true.

The real Turpin was a butcher’s son from Essex who joined a gang of housebreakers, then became a highway robber and a killer. He was caught because of a letter he wrote from prison, and hanged for stealing three horses. He was 33. The legend came later — from novelists, not from Turpin himself.

A butcher’s son from Hempstead

Richard Turpin was baptised on 21 September 1705 at Hempstead in Essex, the fifth of six children of John Turpin, a butcher and innkeeper, and his wife Mary Elizabeth Parmenter. He was born at the Blue Bell Inn, the family pub. He followed his father into the butcher’s trade and married Elizabeth Millington in about 1725, although no record of the marriage survives. The couple moved to Buckhurst Hill, where Turpin opened a butcher’s shop. He was about five feet nine inches tall and heavily marked by smallpox — the closest thing we have to a portrait, since no contemporary likeness exists.

The Essex gang

By the early 1730s, Turpin had fallen in with the Essex gang, a group of deer thieves operating in and around Epping Forest. The government offered rewards for information — £10 at first, raised to £50 in 1733. The gang was known as the Gregory gang, after its leading figure, Samuel Gregory, a blacksmith. Its members included Gregory’s brothers Jeremiah and Jasper, Joseph Rose, Thomas Rowden, John Wheeler, and Mary Brazier, the gang’s fence. Turpin, a young butcher who knew how to handle and sell meat, was a natural contact for men stealing deer. By the summer of 1734 he was a close associate of the gang.

There is no evidence that Turpin himself stole deer. But when the gang’s fortunes changed, he changed with them: by the autumn of 1734, several members had been captured or had fled, and the survivors turned from poaching to something far worse — breaking into houses.

The housebreakers

The gang forced its way into houses at night, bound the occupants — often elderly people living alone — and ransacked the place. In the winter of 1734 they raided homes at Woodford and Barking, taking an estimated £300 from Ambrose Skinner, a 73-year-old farmer. The worst raids came in the winter of 1734–35. On 1 February 1735, five men entered the house of the Widow Shelley at Loughton in Essex. The widow refused to say where her money was kept until the gang threatened her son; they took nearly £100 in money and plate. Read’s Weekly Journal reported the raid on 8 February 1735, including the threat to hold the widow over the fire.

Three days later, Turpin, Gregory, Rose, Wheeler and Fielder robbed Joseph Lawrence, a farmer at Earlsbury Farm in Edgware. They burst into the house armed with pistols, bound the two maidservants, and attacked the 70-year-old farmer, beating him and forcing him to sit on the fire. Gregory took one of the maidservants upstairs and raped her. For all of that, the gang escaped with less than £30. These are the crimes that define the real Turpin — and the victims, not the legend, deserve to be at the centre of this story.

The gang falls apart

The Lawrence raid was the gang’s undoing. On 11 February 1735, Fielder, William Saunders and Wheeler were arrested in Bloomsbury after an alehouse keeper recognised their horses. Wheeler, possibly as young as fifteen, turned informer. Most of the gang were hanged or transported within months. By the spring of 1735, only Turpin and Thomas Rowden remained at large.

On the highway

With the gang destroyed, Turpin turned to the crime he would become famous for: highway robbery. He was first identified as a suspect in one on 10 July 1735, described as “Turpin the butcher”, alongside Thomas Rowden, “the pewterer”. In August they robbed coach parties on Barnes Common and between Putney and Kingston Hill, and took six guineas from a Mr Godfrey on Hounslow Heath. In December they separated; Rowden was later convicted of passing counterfeit coin and transported in 1738.

By March 1737 Turpin was working with Matthew King — often wrongly called Tom King — and Stephen Potter, hiding in a cave in Epping Forest. The partnership ended suddenly at Whitechapel, after a horse had been stolen near Waltham Forest. The owner reported it to Richard Bayes, landlord of the Green Man at Leytonstone, who tracked the horse to the Red Lion at Whitechapel, where Matthew King’s brother John was apprehended. In the mêlée that followed, Matthew King was wounded by gunfire and died on 19 May. Accounts differ: Bayes claimed Turpin fired the fatal shot, but the newspapers later retracted that claim and blamed Bayes himself. Who killed Matthew King remains uncertain.

The killing of Thomas Morris

Turpin escaped to his hideaway in Epping Forest, where he was seen by Thomas Morris, a servant of one of the forest keepers. On 4 May 1737, when Morris attempted to capture him, Turpin shot and killed him with a carbine. A reward of £200 was offered for his capture. Morris is the forgotten victim of the Turpin story: a working man, a keeper’s servant, shot dead for trying to arrest a wanted criminal.

John Palmer of Brough

Sometime around June 1737, Turpin crossed the Humber and settled at Brough in the East Riding of Yorkshire, under the alias John Palmer. Posing as a horse trader, he stole horses as he went: in July 1737 he stole one from Pinchbeck in Lincolnshire and three more on the way back to Brough. His downfall came over something trivial: on 2 October 1738 he shot another man’s game cock in the street at Brough, and threatened John Robinson when rebuked. Three East Riding justices tried to bind him over, but Turpin refused to pay the surety and was committed to the House of Correction at Beverley. Enquiries showed “Palmer” was suspected of sheep and horse theft at Long Sutton. Refusing sureties for the York Assizes, he was transferred to York Castle in handcuffs on 16 October 1738. Thomas Creasy, owner of the three stolen horses, had tracked them down; it was for those thefts that Turpin would be tried.

The letter that unmasked him was written from his cell in York Castle. Turpin wrote to his brother-in-law, Pompr Rivernall, asking for help. Rivernall refused to pay the delivery charge when he saw the York postmark, saying he “had no correspondent at York.” The letter was sent on to Saffron Walden, where James Smith — who had taught the young Turpin to write — recognised the handwriting and alerted a justice of the peace, who paid the postage and opened the letter. Smith then travelled to York Castle and on 23 February identified “Palmer” as Turpin. He received the £200 reward.

Trial and execution at York

Horse theft had been a capital offence since 1545. Turpin was tried at York Assizes from 22 March 1739, charged with stealing Creasy’s horses: a mare worth three pounds, a foal worth twenty shillings, and a gelding worth three pounds. The indictments wrongly placed the thefts at Welton in March 1739; they had taken place at Heckington in August 1738. Seven witnesses were called, including Creasy and James Smith. Turpin said he had bought the mare and foal from an innkeeper near Heckington, and asked for the trial to be put off so he could call witnesses. When the judge asked his name before he came to Lincolnshire, he said: “Turpin.” The jury found him guilty of both charges without leaving the courtroom. Asked for any reason against sentence, Turpin replied: “It is very hard upon me, my Lord, because I was not prepar’d for my Defence.” He was sentenced to death.

He bought a new frock coat and hired five mourners to follow his coffin. On 7 April 1739, Turpin and John Stead, another horse thief, were taken by open cart to Knavesmire, the city’s place of execution. Turpin “behav’d himself with amazing assurance” and “bow’d to the spectators as he passed.” York had no permanent hangman; the pardoned prisoner who acted as executioner was fellow highwayman Thomas Hadfield. The Gentleman’s Magazine records that Turpin spoke a few words to the executioner, “then threw himself off, and expir’d in five minutes.” He was buried at St George’s Church, Fishergate, though historians doubt he lies beneath its gravestone.

The making of a legend

The folk-hero transformation began almost immediately, built on fiction. Within weeks of the execution, Richard Bayes — the landlord involved in Matthew King’s death — published The Genuine History of the Life of Richard Turpin, a hurried pamphlet mixing fact with invention. But the legend that made him immortal came almost a hundred years after his death. In 1834, William Harrison Ainsworth published Rookwood, a Gothic romance in which Turpin appears as a dashing highwayman, given the novel’s best scenes — including a desperate overnight ride from London to York on his mare Black Bess, about 200 miles in less than a day, at the end of which the horse dies at the gates of York.

The ride never happened. Its origins lie in Daniel Defoe’s 1727 A Tour Thro’ the Whole Island of Great Britain, in which another highwayman, William Nevison, rode from Kent to York in 1676 to establish an alibi. A similar ride had been attributed to Turpin since 1808, but Ainsworth fixed it to Turpin and Black Bess. As imagined — about 200 miles in less than a day — the feat is impossible. It was repeated in penny dreadfuls, ballads, plays, films and television ever since.

The transformation is remarkable. A pockmarked butcher’s son who terrorised elderly householders, who may or may not have killed his own accomplice, who shot a forest keeper’s servant dead, and who was hanged for stealing three horses, became “a gentleman of the road” and “a protector of the weak” — an eighteenth-century Robin Hood. The gallant highwayman owes far more to other men — Nevison, whose ride Turpin inherited, and Claude Duval, whose manners were borrowed wholesale — than to Turpin himself. That is the real story: not a hero, but a violent criminal whose fame was invented by writers who never met him. The legend should never drown out the people he hurt: the Widow Shelley, Joseph Lawrence and his maidservants, and Thomas Morris.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Richard Turpin was baptised on 21 September 1705 at Hempstead, Essex, the fifth of six children of John Turpin, a butcher and innkeeper, and Mary Elizabeth Parmenter. By the early 1730s he was a close associate of the Essex gang, also called the Gregory gang, led by Samuel Gregory. The gang carried out a series of violent house robberies in the winter of 1734–35, including the raids on the Widow Shelley at Loughton on 1 February 1735 and on Joseph Lawrence at Edgware on 4 February 1735, as reported in contemporary newspapers. After the gang was broken up in early 1735 — Fielder, Rose and Saunders were hanged at Tyburn on 10 March 1735, Samuel Gregory was executed on 4 June — Turpin turned to highway robbery with Thomas Rowden and later with Matthew King and Stephen Potter. Matthew King died of a gunshot wound on 19 May 1737. Turpin shot and killed Thomas Morris, a servant of a keeper of Epping Forest, on 4 May 1737, and a reward of £200 was offered for his capture. He lived in Yorkshire under the alias John Palmer, was committed to York Castle in October 1738, was identified by James Smith after Smith recognised his handwriting on a letter Turpin had written from prison, was tried at York Assizes on 22 March 1739 and found guilty on two charges of horse theft, and was hanged at Knavesmire, York, on 7 April 1739.

Unverified or unproven: Who fired the shot that killed Matthew King — Richard Bayes claimed it was Turpin, but contemporary newspapers retracted that claim and said Bayes had fired the fatal shot; Turpin’s own account also differs from Bayes’s. The exact date of Turpin’s marriage to Elizabeth Millington, and whether the couple had a child, are not supported by surviving records; Bayes’s claim that Turpin married a Miss Palmer is regarded as almost certainly incorrect. The story of Turpin’s body being stolen by body-snatchers and reburied with quicklime comes from accounts appended to Thomas Kyll’s 1739 pamphlet and is treated with caution by historians, as is the authenticity of the gravestone at St George’s, Fishergate. The overnight ride from London to York on Black Bess is fiction: it was invented, in the form in which it is known, by William Harrison Ainsworth in his 1834 novel Rookwood, drawing on an older story about a different highwayman, William Nevison. No contemporary portrait of Turpin exists; the familiar images of him are nineteenth-century illustrations of Ainsworth’s novel, not likenesses of the real man.

Sources

Leave a Comment