Fall River, Massachusetts, was a mill city that measured a man by what he owned and how little of it he spent. On the morning of Thursday, 4 August 1892, the heat had already settled over Second Street before nine o’clock, and the windows of the narrow frame house at number 92 were shut against it. Inside, the household went about its ordinary business. A maid washed the outside windows. A daughter ate pears in the yard. An old man came home from his morning walk, lay down on the sitting-room sofa to rest, and never got up again.
By noon, two people were dead in that house, killed about ninety minutes apart, and the woman who found the second of them was the daughter of the first. The police who came to the house that day found no broken door, no open window, no stranger seen coming or going, and no blood on the clothing of the woman who had been in the house all morning. Ten months later, a jury of twelve men in New Bedford heard the case against her, deliberated for about an hour, and found her not guilty of both murders. No one else was ever charged, and no one has ever been convicted. The case has been open for more than a century, and it has never come any closer to being closed.
This is the story of what the record shows, what the evidence can and cannot prove, and how a trial that ended in acquittal became the most famous unsolved double murder in American history. The verdict is a matter of law, and it stands. The question of who killed Andrew and Abby Borden is a matter of history, and it has never been answered.
The House on Second Street
Andrew Jackson Borden was seventy years old in the summer of 1892, and he was one of the richest men in Fall River. He had begun working life as a carpenter’s apprentice and had risen, through property dealing, banking, and mill directorships, to a fortune that the city reckoned in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. He was also, by every account of those who knew him, famously unwilling to spend any of it. He lived in a modest two-storey frame house on Second Street, in the crowded centre of the mill city, when his money could have bought him a mansion on the Hill, the neighbourhood where Fall River’s wealthy families lived. He kept the house plain, the food simple, and the household on a tight allowance, and his daughters, who had grown up in comfort but never in luxury, resented it.
His first wife, Sarah, had died in 1863, leaving him with two daughters: Emma, who was forty-one in 1892, and Lizzie, who had been born on 19 July 1860 and was thirty-two. In 1865 he married Abby Durfee Gray, who became the girls’ stepmother. Abby was sixty-four by the summer of 1892. She was, by the accounts of the household, a quiet and devout woman, and she was not loved by her stepdaughters. Lizzie, in particular, called her Mrs Borden rather than mother, and the distance between them was a matter of common knowledge in Fall River. The tension had a practical edge as well as a personal one. The sisters believed their father had been too generous with property toward Abby’s relatives, and money, in a house run as tightly as the Bordens’, was never a small subject.
The household at 92 Second Street consisted of Andrew, Abby, Lizzie, and a live-in maid, Bridget Sullivan, a young Irish immigrant of about twenty-five whom the family called Maggie. Emma was away on the morning of the murders, visiting friends in Fairhaven, about fifteen miles from Fall River. A fifth person had arrived the day before: John Vinnicum Morse, the brother of Andrew’s first wife, who had come to Fall River on business and stayed the night. Morse was a familiar figure in the house, a farmer from out of town, and his presence on that particular night would matter, because it gave the household one more person to account for, and one more alibi to check.
The days before the murders had been uneasy ones. The household had been ill, with stomach complaints that had brought the family doctor, Dr Seabury Bowen, to the house on 3 August. Whether the sickness was bad food or something worse was never settled, and it would become one more thread in a case full of them. On the evening of 3 August, Lizzie visited her friend Alice Russell, who lived next door, and spoke of her worries about her father’s affairs and about a feeling that something bad might happen to the family. Russell would later testify about that conversation, and the prosecution would treat it as a sign that Lizzie expected violence. The defence would treat it as the talk of a nervous daughter in a household that had been unwell and unhappy for days.
The Morning of August 4
The morning of 4 August 1892 can be reconstructed, hour by hour, from the testimony of the people who were there, and the reconstruction is what makes the case so difficult. John Morse left the house at about 8.45, to visit relatives in town. Andrew Borden left after nine for his usual morning round of the banks and his business affairs. Abby went upstairs to make the bed in the second-floor guest room, the room kept for visitors, and Bridget Sullivan went outside to wash the windows. Lizzie was, by her own later accounts, in the barn and then in the yard. The house, for a time, was quiet.
Abby Borden was killed in that upstairs guest room, struck from behind while she worked, and she fell between the bed and the wall. The medical evidence would later fix the time of her death with unusual precision for 1892. When Andrew’s body was found, his blood was still warm and liquid. Abby’s was dark, cold, and thoroughly congealed, and stiffness had begun to set in. The doctors concluded that she had been dead for at least an hour and a half before her husband was attacked. The killer, whoever it was, had not struck twice and left. Whoever it was had killed Abby, and then stayed in or close to that house for ninety minutes, waiting for Andrew to come home.
Andrew returned late in the morning, at about half past ten, and lay down on the sitting-room sofa to rest. At about a quarter past eleven, Lizzie called down to Bridget Sullivan, who was still outside washing windows, and told her that her father was dead. Sullivan came in and found Andrew on the sofa. Lizzie sent her to fetch Dr Bowen, who lived nearby, and Bowen arrived within minutes. The police followed soon after. Abby’s body was found upstairs only after the house had been searched, and by then the shape of the case was already set: two victims, one house, a morning in which almost everyone in it could be placed, and ninety minutes that nobody could fill.
Lizzie’s accounts of her own morning became the central problem of the investigation. At different times she said she had been in the barn looking for fishing sinkers and for irons, and that she had been in the yard eating pears. The accounts did not match each other, and they did not match what others remembered. She also said that Abby had received a note that morning, calling her to visit a sick friend, and that Abby had gone out in response to it. No note was ever found, and no one ever came forward to say they had sent one. The police noted these things, and they noted something else as well: there was no blood on Lizzie’s clothing, and no blood on her hands or face, when the police arrived. In a case built on a close, violent attack, that absence would become one of the most argued facts in the whole record.
The Investigation
The investigation that followed was, by the standards of 1892, thorough, and by the standards of any later time, thin. The police searched the house and the cellar, and in a box of tools in the cellar they found a hatchet head with the handle freshly broken off. Four hatchets and axes were found in the house in all. None of them showed bloodstains that the laboratory methods of the day could confirm, and none of them was ever tied to the killings. No blood was found on Lizzie’s person, and no blood was found on the dress she was wearing when the police arrived. The physical record, in the end, consisted of a broken hatchet head, a house full of blades that every household of the time owned, and two bodies.
Two pieces of evidence that the police regarded as strong were kept out of the trial altogether, and the reasons they were kept out shaped the outcome. The first concerned poison. On 3 August, the day before the murders, a clerk at a Fall River drugstore, Eli Bence, later testified that a woman he identified as Lizzie had tried to buy ten cents’ worth of prussic acid, a deadly poison, saying she needed it to clean a sealskin cape. Bence refused to sell it to her without a prescription, and two other men in the shop supported his account. The testimony was heard at the preliminary hearing, but the trial court excluded it, on the grounds that an attempt to buy poison had nothing to do with murders committed with a blade. The jury never heard it.
The second concerned a dress. On Sunday 7 August, three days after the murders, Alice Russell walked into the Borden kitchen and found Lizzie burning a blue Bedford cord dress in the stove. Lizzie told her it was covered with paint. Russell later testified that she saw no blood on the part of the dress she observed, and Emma said she was the one who had told Lizzie to get rid of it. The prosecution treated the burning as the destruction of evidence. The defence treated it as the disposal of a stained housedress by a woman whose house was full of policemen. The dress was gone, and with it went the one piece of clothing that might have settled the question of whether Lizzie had been wearing it on the morning of the murders.
The inquest was held from 9 to 11 August, and Lizzie testified for three days. She did so without a lawyer present, and while effectively in custody, and her answers were confused and contradictory. She could not give a steady account of where she had been during the morning, and she changed her story about the note, the barn, and the pears. On 11 August, at the end of the inquest, she was arrested and charged with the murders of her father and stepmother, and taken to the jail at Taunton. A preliminary hearing followed, and in December 1892 a grand jury indicted her on three counts: one for the murder of Abby, one for the murder of Andrew, and one joint count covering both. She spent nine months in jail awaiting trial, and by the time the trial opened, the case had become the most talked-about murder trial in America.
The Trial in New Bedford
The trial opened in New Bedford on Monday, 5 June 1893, before three judges of the Massachusetts Superior Court: Chief Justice Albert Mason and Associate Justices Caleb Blodgett and Justin Dewey. The prosecution was led by District Attorney Hosea Knowlton, with William Moody, who would later become a justice of the United States Supreme Court. The defence was led by George Robinson, a former governor of Massachusetts, with Andrew Jennings, a Fall River lawyer who knew the Borden family. The courtroom was crowded every day, the newspapers of the country covered the proceedings in detail, and the trial ran for thirteen days.
The prosecution’s case was built entirely on circumstance. There was no witness to either killing, no weapon tied to the crime, and no blood on the accused. Knowlton argued opportunity, motive, and means: Lizzie had been in the house all morning, she had reason to resent her father and stepmother over money, she had tried to buy poison the day before, and she had burned a dress three days after. But the two rulings that had gone against the prosecution before the trial began had already taken the heart out of that argument. The judges excluded Lizzie’s inquest testimony, on the grounds that she had given it without counsel while effectively in custody and without being warned against self-incrimination. They excluded the prussic acid evidence as too remote from a crime committed with a blade. The jury, which was made up of twelve men, never heard the two pieces of evidence the prosecution considered its strongest.
The trial had its moments of theatre. The skulls of Andrew and Abby Borden, preserved after the autopsies, were produced in court, and Lizzie, by the newspaper accounts of the day, fainted at the sight of them. The defence made much of the absence of blood, arguing that no woman could have committed such an attack and emerged without a mark on her clothing, and that the police had found no blood anywhere on Lizzie or on anything she wore. Robinson’s closing argument asked the jury to consider what the prosecution had actually proved, and his answer was that it had proved a double murder and a daughter in the house, and nothing more. Lizzie herself never took the stand, which was her right, and which the jury was told not to hold against her.
On 20 June, after thirteen days of testimony, the jury retired. It returned after a brief deliberation, generally reported as about an hour to an hour and a half, with some accounts saying the jurors had agreed on a single ballot. The verdict was not guilty on both counts. Lizzie Borden walked out of the New Bedford courthouse a free woman, and the court ordered her discharged. The newspapers that evening carried the news across the country, and Fall River, which had followed the trial day by day, was left with a verdict it could not quite believe and a question it could not answer.
The Theories That Followed
The acquittal did not end the case. It ended the only prosecution the case would ever have, and it left the field open to more than a century of argument. The theories that followed fall into a small number of groups, and each of them has a hole in it, which is why none of them has ever settled the matter.
The first group concerns the other people in the house. John Morse left at about 8.45 in the morning and was seen in town during the hours that followed, and no evidence ever connected him to the killings. Bridget Sullivan was in the house all morning, washing windows outside, and she testified at the trial; no motive was ever found for her, and no evidence ever placed her upstairs with Abby. Emma Borden was fifteen miles away in Fairhaven, visiting friends, and her alibi was never seriously challenged. The household, in other words, was full of people, and every one of them except Lizzie had an account of the morning that could be checked, and every one of them was checked.
The second group concerns a stranger. Some writers have argued that an unknown person entered the house, killed Abby, waited for Andrew, killed him, and left unseen. The difficulty is that no sign of forced entry was ever found, no stranger was seen near the house that morning, and the house was occupied throughout. A stranger would have had to enter a house with three people in it, kill a woman upstairs without being heard by the maid outside or the daughter in the yard, wait for ninety minutes, kill a man on the sofa, and leave without leaving a trace. It is possible, and it is the theory that the defence itself suggested, but it rests on nothing except the absence of proof against anyone else.
The third group concerns the note. Lizzie said that Abby had received a note on the morning of the murders, calling her to visit a sick friend, and that this was why Abby had gone upstairs to make the guest-room bed. The note was never found, no sender ever came forward, and no sick friend was identified. Some writers have treated the note as Lizzie’s invention, a story told to explain why Abby was upstairs. Others have treated it as a real message from someone who never admitted sending it. The record holds neither version. It holds only that Lizzie spoke of a note, and that the note has never been found.
The fourth group concerns later claims about other suspects. A man named William Borden later said that he was Andrew Borden’s illegitimate son, and some writers have suggested that he, or another unknown relative, had a motive rooted in inheritance. No contemporary record supports the claim, and no evidence has ever connected William Borden to the house on the morning of 4 August. Another line of argument concerns the pigeons. According to later accounts, Andrew had killed Lizzie’s pigeons in the barn with a hatchet shortly before the murders, and Lizzie had been distressed by it. The story is not confirmed by the trial record, and it appears in accounts written long after the events, which is why it sits in the disputed column rather than the verified one.
The fifth group concerns motive. The prosecution argued that Lizzie resented her father over money, and that she and Emma stood to inherit a large estate. That was true: the sisters did inherit a substantial sum, and they used it, two months after the acquittal, to buy a large house on the Hill. But motive is not evidence of a crime, and the defence argued, with some force, that a great many daughters resent their fathers over money without killing them. The money explains why Lizzie might have wished her father dead. It does not explain how she could have killed two people in a house full of witnesses and left no trace of herself on either of them.
The Rhyme and the Legend
The case would probably have faded from public memory if it had not been turned into a rhyme. The chant that every American schoolchild once knew says that Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother forty whacks, and that when she saw what she had done, she gave her father forty-one. It is wrong about almost everything it contains. The weapon was a hatchet, not an axe. The number of blows was about twenty-nine in total, eighteen or nineteen to Abby and ten or eleven to Andrew, not eighty-one. Abby was Lizzie’s stepmother, not her mother. And Abby died first, not Andrew. The earliest traced printings of the rhyme date to February 1894, only eight months after the acquittal, and in those early versions the numbers were twenty and twenty-one. The forty and forty-one version is the one that Edmund Pearson put into his book Studies in Murder in 1924, and it is the version that stuck.
The rhyme did more than get the facts wrong. It fixed the case in the public mind as a piece of folklore, and folklore does not need evidence. Once the rhyme existed, Lizzie Borden was no longer a woman who had been tried and acquitted. She was a character in a children’s chant, a figure of horror and of dark comedy, and the distinction between the verdict and the legend was lost. Books, plays, films, and television dramas followed, each of them retelling the story with a different ending, and each of them claiming, in its own way, to know what really happened. Some of them named Lizzie as the killer. Some of them named someone else. None of them could prove it.
The serious literature on the case is large, and it is worth separating from the legend. Edwin Porter, a Fall River newspaperman, published The Fall River Tragedy in 1893, within months of the trial, reprinting testimony from the hearings and the trial at length. Pearson’s Studies in Murder, published in 1924, shaped the popular understanding of the case for a generation. In recent years, Sarah Miller’s The Borden Murders and Cara Robertson’s The Trial of Lizzie Borden have gone back to the original records, and both of them treat the case as what it is: a trial that ended in acquittal, and a murder that was never solved. The Fall River Historical Society holds the trial evidence, the letters, and the photographs, and in recent years it has received new material, including journals kept by Andrew Jennings, a member of Lizzie’s defence team, which offer researchers a fresh view of how the defence was built.
The house at 92 Second Street still stands, and it now operates as a museum and bed-and-breakfast, where visitors can sleep in the rooms where the murders took place. The house is a reminder of how completely the legend has overtaken the record. The people who stay there come for the story they learned as children, not for the trial record, and the trial record is the only part of the story that was ever tested in court.
The Life After
Lizzie Borden lived for another thirty-four years after her acquittal, and the verdict did not free her from the case. She and Emma inherited their father’s estate, and about two months after the trial they bought a large Queen Anne house at 306 French Street, in the Hill neighbourhood where Lizzie had always wanted to live. They named it Maplecroft. Lizzie began to call herself Lizbeth, and she became a patron of the theatre and a supporter of animal welfare, leaving a substantial sum to the Animal Rescue League of Fall River in her will. She lived, by all accounts, as a woman of means in a city that had never stopped watching her.
The sisters’ life together at Maplecroft ended in 1905, when Emma moved out after a falling out whose cause was never publicly settled. Newspapers at the time connected the break to Lizzie’s friendship with the actress Nance O’Neil, whom she had met in 1904, and to the theatrical circle that gathered at Maplecroft. Emma herself refused to discuss the reasons, saying only that conditions had become unbearable. The sisters never spoke again. In 1913, Emma spoke to the press for the first time about the case, and she maintained her sister’s innocence, saying that as for Lizzie being guilty, she said no, and decidedly no. She had supported Lizzie through the investigation and the trial, and she supported her still, even after they had stopped speaking.
Lizzie remained at Maplecroft for the rest of her life. Her health declined in her final years, and she underwent surgery for gallbladder trouble about a year before her death, from which she never fully recovered. She died at home on 1 June 1927, at the age of sixty-six, of pneumonia. She was buried in the family plot in Oak Grove Cemetery in Fall River, alongside Andrew and Abby, under the name Lizbeth. Emma died nine days later, in Newmarket, New Hampshire, at the age of seventy-six, and was buried in the same plot. The two sisters, who had not spoken in twenty-two years, were reunited in death in the same ground as the parents whose murders had defined both of their lives.
The case followed Lizzie to the end, and it has followed her ever since. She was acquitted by a jury, and she was never exonerated in the public mind. The distinction matters, and it is the heart of the case. A verdict of not guilty is a legal finding that the prosecution did not prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt. It is not a finding that the accused did not do it, and it is not a finding that someone else did. Lizzie Borden lived for thirty-four years under a suspicion that no court could remove, and she died under it, and the suspicion has outlived her by nearly a century.
Why the Case Endures
The Borden case endures because it sits at the crossing of two American stories that never quite meet. One is the story of the law, which is a story about proof: what can be shown, what can be excluded, and what a jury of twelve ordinary people can be asked to decide. The other is the story of the public, which is a story about belief: what people think happened, what they are willing to say happened, and what they will go on saying long after the court has closed its doors. In the Borden case, the law and the public reached different conclusions, and neither of them has ever yielded to the other.
It endures, too, because the evidence is so finely balanced that it will support almost any reading, and no reading completely. The case for Lizzie’s guilt rests on opportunity, on her contradictory accounts, on the poison, and on the burned dress. The case against it rests on the absence of blood, the absence of a weapon, the exclusion of the two strongest pieces of evidence, and a jury that needed about an hour to decide. Both cases are built on the same record, and both of them leave the same gap: the ninety minutes between the two killings, in a house full of people, during which nobody saw anything.
It endures, finally, because it is a story about a family, and families are where the hardest cases live. Andrew Borden was a rich man who lived like a poor one. Abby Borden was a stepmother in a house where she was not loved. Emma Borden was a sister who stood by her sibling and then left her. Lizzie Borden was a daughter who was tried for killing her parents and acquitted, and who spent the rest of her life paying for a crime she was never convicted of. The house on Second Street held all of them, and it held the secret of what happened there on the morning of 4 August 1892, and it has never given it up.
Evidence Ladder
Verified
- Andrew and Abby Borden were killed in their home at 92 Second Street, Fall River, Massachusetts, on the morning of 4 August 1892: Abby first, in the upstairs guest room, and Andrew about ninety minutes later on the sitting-room sofa, both struck with a hatchet-like weapon.
- Lizzie Borden was arrested on 11 August 1892, indicted in December 1892, tried in New Bedford from 5 to 20 June 1893 before three judges, and acquitted by a jury of twelve men; no one else was ever charged with the murders.
- The trial court excluded Lizzie’s inquest testimony, given without counsel while she was effectively in custody, and excluded the prussic acid evidence as too remote; the prosecution’s case was entirely circumstantial, no blood was reported on Lizzie or on the dress she wore when police arrived, and no weapon was ever tied to the killings.
Disputed
- Whether Lizzie’s contradictory accounts of her morning, in the barn looking for fishing sinkers and irons, and in the yard eating pears, were lies, confusion under shock, or the product of an inquest conducted without counsel, and how much weight a jury should have given them.
- Whether the blue Bedford cord dress Lizzie burned in the kitchen stove on 7 August 1892 was the dress she wore on the morning of the murders: Alice Russell testified she saw no blood on it, and Emma said she told Lizzie to burn it, yet the prosecution treated the burning as destruction of evidence.
- Whether Andrew Borden killed Lizzie’s pigeons in the barn shortly before the murders, and whether that incident, if it happened, supplies a motive: the story appears in later accounts and is not confirmed by the trial record.
Rumour
- Claims that an unknown intruder entered the house, killed both Bordens, and left unseen rest on no evidence: no sign of forced entry was found, and no stranger was seen near the house that morning.
- Claims that William Borden, a man who later said he was Andrew Borden’s illegitimate son, committed the murders rest on no contemporary record and have never been supported by evidence.
- Claims that Lizzie confessed to the murders in later life, in stories repeated in memoirs and on stage, have no documentary support and are contradicted by the accounts of those who knew her.
Case File
- What happened: Andrew and Abby Borden were killed in their home in Fall River, Massachusetts, on the morning of 4 August 1892; their daughter Lizzie was arrested, tried, and acquitted, and no one else was ever charged.
- When: 4 August 1892; trial 5–20 June 1893.
- Status: Unsolved
If a jury of twelve men could not find enough evidence to convict the only suspect the police ever had, and no one else was ever charged, how does a case stay open for more than a century without ever finding a second suspect?
Keep exploring: The Zodiac Killer: The Letters, the Codes, and the Case That Never Closed; The Black Dahlia: Elizabeth Short and the Biggest Investigation of Its Time; D.B. Cooper: The Man Who Jumped Out of a Plane With $200,000 and Vanished; The Lindbergh Kidnapping: The Crime That Changed American Law