The Disappearance of Hailey Dunn: Thirteen Years, One Arrest, and No Conviction

Reading Time: 6 minutes ·

On the night of 26 December 2010, Hailey Dunn was at home in Colorado City, Texas, playing video games. She was 13 years old, a middle school cheerleader, and she had spent Christmas with her family. Her brother David saw her that evening before he left to spend the night at a friend’s house. Her mother saw her at about 10 p.m. The next day, according to her mother’s boyfriend, Shawn Adkins, Hailey left the house to go to a friend’s. She never arrived. She was reported missing on 28 December 2010.

Her remains were found more than two years later, in March 2013, near a lake in Scurry County. A man was finally arrested for her murder in June 2021 — eleven years after she vanished. And then, in June 2023, the charges were dismissed, and he walked free. No one has ever been convicted of killing Hailey Dunn. Her case, which has been called solved in some accounts, is in fact still open, and it is now in the hands of the Texas Rangers Cold Case Unit.

The last day

Hailey Darlene Dunn was born on 28 August 1997 in Colorado City, a small town in West Texas. She lived with her mother, Billie Jean Dunn, her older brother David, and Billie’s live-in boyfriend, Shawn Adkins. She was involved in sports and school activities, and by most accounts was a happy, ordinary teenager.

Adkins was the last person to see her alive. He told police that on 27 December, Hailey had left the house to walk to a friend’s home, and that he had not seen her since. She never reached the friend’s house. When Billie Jean reported her missing on the afternoon of 28 December, the search began — and it found nothing.

Adkins was a person of interest from the start, but there was no evidence to charge him. On 17 March 2011, police went to the house to speak to him, and Billie Jean was arrested for lying to them about his whereabouts, saying he had not been at the house when he had. She pleaded no contest in June 2011 to making a false report and was given probation. After sentencing, she moved away from Colorado City.

In 2012, human remains were found near the home of Adkins’s mother in Big Spring, at an airfield. After an autopsy, they were determined to be those of a man, and not connected to Hailey’s case.

The remains at Lake J.B. Thomas

On 16 March 2013, a man named Curtis Lloyd was searching for fossils near Lake J.B. Thomas, south-west of Snyder in Scurry County, about twenty miles from Colorado City, when he found human remains: a skull, a tooth, a femur, and a pair of blue sweatpants of the kind Hailey had last been seen wearing. The remains were sent to the University of North Texas Center for Human Identification for DNA analysis, and on 26 April 2013 police announced that they belonged to 13-year-old Hailey Dunn. Her death was classified as a homicide.

Her remains were not released to her mother until 2017, when Hailey was finally laid to rest. In 2018, the investigation was turned over to Scurry County, because that was where her remains had been found. For years after that, there were no updates. Adkins remained a person of interest, and the clear primary suspect in the eyes of investigators, but there was not enough evidence to bring charges that would hold up in court.

The arrest — and the dismissal

The case changed in 2020, when the Texas Rangers reopened it as a cold case. DNA samples were collected from Adkins, and on 14 June 2021 he was arrested in Howard County and charged with first-degree murder and second-degree tampering with evidence. He was held on a 2 million dollar bond. Later that year, a grand jury indicted him, and court documents revealed that investigators believed he had struck Hailey on the head with an unknown blunt object, killing her, and had concealed her body.

It looked, at last, as if the case had been solved. It had not. In June 2023, prosecutors filed a motion to dismiss the charges against Adkins without prejudice — meaning he could still be charged again later — after a series of serious evidentiary problems came to light. Adkins was released from custody. Prosecutors were explicit, even in dismissing the case, that they still considered him their primary suspect, but they acknowledged that the evidence as it stood was not enough to take to a jury.

As of January 2025, Hailey’s case has been formally handed to the Texas Rangers Cold Case Unit for continued investigation. Her father, Clint Dunn, and a private investigator who has worked on the case for years have continued to push publicly for renewed attention, and have expressed frustration that more than a decade after Hailey’s death, no one has ever been convicted.

What remains

Hailey Dunn’s case is a reminder that an arrest is not a solution, and that a charge is not a conviction. For eleven years, the investigation produced no suspect it could charge. Then it produced one, and the case against him fell apart. The evidence that led to the arrest — DNA collected in 2021 — was not enough, on its own, to carry a murder prosecution to trial, and whatever else the investigators had was undermined by the evidentiary problems that forced the dismissal.

The case is also a record of a family divided by loss. Hailey’s mother lied to the police about the man who was the last person to see her daughter alive, and was convicted for it. Her father has spent years demanding that the investigation continue. Her brother, who saw her on her last evening, has lived with the case for most of his life.

The case is also a record of a family divided by loss. Hailey’s mother lied to the police about the man who was the last person to see her daughter alive, and was convicted for it. Her father has spent years demanding that the investigation continue. Her brother, who saw her on her last evening, has lived with the case for most of his life.

For the investigators, the file is still open. The Texas Rangers Cold Case Unit lists the case under number 153, and asks anyone with information to call. The remains found near Lake J.B. Thomas in 2013 are buried. The man investigators have long considered their primary suspect is free, and has never been convicted of any charge directly related to her death. And the question of what happened to Hailey Dunn on 27 December 2010 — who struck her, and why, and how her body came to lie near a lake twenty miles from home — is still unanswered.

The dismissal in 2023 was not a finding of innocence, and it was not the end of the case. Prosecutors chose to dismiss without prejudice — deliberately preserving the right to charge again — because the evidence they had could not support a trial, not because they had concluded that Adkins was innocent. The case now rests with the Texas Rangers, who have taken over the investigation in full. Any new evidence, any new witness, or any new forensic technique could bring it back to court. Until then, Hailey Dunn’s file remains what it has been since the day she vanished: an open investigation, in a small West Texas town, waiting for the one piece of evidence that would finally close it.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Hailey Darlene Dunn, 13, of Colorado City, Texas, was last seen on 27 December 2010 and reported missing on 28 December 2010. Her mother’s boyfriend, Shawn Adkins, was the last person to see her alive. Her mother, Billie Jean Dunn, was arrested on 17 March 2011 for lying to police about Adkins’s whereabouts and pleaded no contest in June 2011, receiving probation. Human remains found on 16 March 2013 near Lake J.B. Thomas in Scurry County were identified on 26 April 2013 as Hailey Dunn’s, and her death was classified as a homicide. Adkins was arrested on 14 June 2021 and charged with first-degree murder and tampering with evidence, and was indicted later that year; investigators believed Hailey had been struck on the head with an unknown blunt object. In June 2023, prosecutors dismissed the charges without prejudice, citing evidentiary problems, while stating that Adkins remained their primary suspect. In January 2025 the case was handed to the Texas Rangers Cold Case Unit. No one has ever been convicted of killing Hailey Dunn.

Unverified or unproven: That Shawn Adkins killed Hailey Dunn has never been proven in court; the charges against him were dismissed before trial, and he has never been convicted of any charge related to her death. The precise sequence of events on 27 December 2010, including who struck Hailey and how her body reached Scurry County, has not been established. Claims made in some accounts that the case was “solved” by the 2021 arrest are incorrect: the charges were dismissed in 2023 and the case remains formally unsolved.

Sources

Leave a Comment