Robert Napper: The Plumstead Ripper and the Rachel Nickell Case

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On 15 July 1992, Rachel Nickell, a 23-year-old mother, was walking with her two-year-old son and their dog on Wimbledon Common in south-west London when she was attacked and stabbed 49 times. Her son, Alex, was left standing beside her body. The murder became one of Britain’s most notorious unsolved crimes — and one of its most damaging miscarriages of justice. Police arrested an innocent man, Colin Stagg, and pursued him for two years while the real killer remained free. That killer was Robert Napper, a man already known to police, who went on to murder a mother and her four-year-old daughter in Plumstead before he was finally caught. DNA evidence linked him to Nickell’s murder in 2004, and in 2008 he pleaded guilty to her manslaughter. He is detained indefinitely at Broadmoor Hospital.

Napper was born Robert Clive Napper on 25 February 1966 in Erith, south-east London, and grew up in nearby Plumstead. He first came to police attention in 1986, and by the late 1980s he was carrying out a string of sexual assaults along the Green Chain Walk in south-east London, which earned him the name the “Green Chain Rapist”. In October 1989, his own mother telephoned the police to tell them that he had admitted raping a woman on Plumstead Common. The information was disregarded. Three years later, he killed Rachel Nickell.

The Murder on Wimbledon Common

Rachel Jane Nickell was 23. On the afternoon of 15 July 1992 she was walking through a secluded part of Wimbledon Common with her son Alex, then aged two, and their dog Molly, when Napper attacked her. She was stabbed 49 times in the neck and torso and sexually assaulted, and she died at the scene. Alex clung to his mother’s body, begging her to wake up. He became one of the youngest witnesses ever questioned by the Metropolitan Police.

The investigation that followed went badly wrong. Detectives focused on Colin Stagg, a local man with no connection to the crime, and built a case around an elaborate undercover operation in which a policewoman befriended him and tried to draw out a confession. Stagg was charged with Nickell’s murder, but the case collapsed: in September 1994 the judge at the Old Bailey ruled the undercover evidence inadmissible, and Stagg was acquitted. He was eventually awarded more than £700,000 in damages, though not until 2008. The detectives handling the case had rejected, with hostility, a suggestion from officers investigating another murder — that of Samantha Bisset and her daughter — that the two crimes had been committed by the same man.

The Bisset Murders and the Arrest

Sixteen months after Nickell’s murder, in November 1993, Napper broke into a flat in Plumstead and killed 27-year-old Samantha Bisset, stabbing her in the neck and chest, and then sexually assaulted and smothered her four-year-old daughter, Jazmine Jemima Bisset. The similarities with the Nickell murder were striking, and this time the police caught him: forensic investigators recovered his fingerprint, and he was arrested and charged.

At the Old Bailey in October 1995, Napper was convicted of the two Bisset murders. He also admitted two rapes and two attempted rapes. From that trial onwards he was held at Broadmoor, the high-security psychiatric hospital in Berkshire, after being diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia. But he was not yet connected to Rachel Nickell’s murder, and for years the case remained officially unsolved.

DNA and the 2008 Conviction

In 2002, detectives launched a cold-case review of the Nickell murder, using forensic techniques that had not been available in 1992. A tiny male DNA sample, which could not previously have been identified, was analysed, and in 2004 it was matched to Napper. Detectives interviewed him at Broadmoor in 2006. On 28 November 2007 he was charged with Nickell’s murder. His trial began at the Old Bailey on 11 November 2008, and on 18 December 2008 he pleaded guilty to Nickell’s manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility. He also admitted to four other attacks on women. The judge, Mr Justice Griffith Williams, ordered that he be detained indefinitely at Broadmoor, telling him: “You are in any view a very dangerous man.”

Napper remains at Broadmoor. The case is remembered for two reasons: the horror of what happened to Rachel Nickell, Samantha Bisset and Jazmine Bisset, and the failure of the original investigation — an innocent man pursued for two years while the evidence pointing to the real killer was dismissed. Colin Stagg’s acquittal, and the compensation that followed fourteen years later, stand as a warning about what happens when investigators decide they already have their man.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: Robert Clive Napper was born on 25 February 1966. Rachel Jane Nickell, 23, was stabbed 49 times and killed on Wimbledon Common on 15 July 1992, in the presence of her two-year-old son. Colin Stagg was wrongly charged with her murder and acquitted in September 1994; he was later awarded more than £700,000 in damages. In November 1993 Napper killed Samantha Bisset, 27, and her four-year-old daughter Jazmine Jemima Bisset in their flat in Plumstead. He was convicted of those two murders at the Old Bailey in October 1995, and also admitted two rapes and two attempted rapes. He has been held at Broadmoor Hospital since that trial, diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia. A cold-case review begun in 2002 used new DNA profiling to link him to Nickell’s murder in 2004. He was charged on 28 November 2007, and on 18 December 2008 he pleaded guilty to Nickell’s manslaughter on the grounds of diminished responsibility and was ordered to be detained indefinitely at Broadmoor. He also admitted four other attacks on women.

Not documented / unverified: Some sources date Napper’s guilty plea to January 2008; the plea was entered on 18 December 2008. The precise date of the Bisset murders in November 1993 is not consistently reported. Napper is believed to have been responsible for a string of rapes along the Green Chain Walk, but the exact number of those attacks has not been established in court. Some accounts also describe him as having Asperger’s syndrome as well as schizophrenia; the diagnosis most consistently reported is paranoid schizophrenia. The number of attacks he admitted to beyond the three killings varies between sources, because he admitted four other attacks at the 2008 hearing in addition to the two rapes and two attempted rapes admitted in 1995.

Sources

Leave a Comment