Frances Marion Parker was twelve years old, a schoolgirl in Los Angeles, and the daughter of a bank employee named Perry Parker. On 15 December 1927, a stranger walked into her school, told the registrar that her father had been in an accident, and took her away. Two days later, her father paid a ransom of $1,500 in gold — and was handed his daughter’s body. The Los Angeles Times called it “the most horrible crime of the 1920s.” It was, at the time, considered the most horrific crime in the history of California.
Her killer was caught within a week. He was tried, convicted, and hanged. What makes the case endure is not a mystery about who did it, but the cruelty of the crime itself — and the fact that a twelve-year-old girl’s murder changed how America thought about the safety of its children.
The abduction
Marion Parker was born on 11 October 1915 in Los Angeles, to Geraldine and Perry Marion Parker. She had a twin sister, Marjorie. She attended Mount Vernon Junior High School in the Lafayette Square section of Los Angeles.
On 15 December 1927, after Marion was dismissed from her classes, a well-dressed young man presented himself to the school registrar, Mary Holt, as an employee of the bank where Perry Parker worked. He said Perry had suffered an automobile accident and wished to see his daughter. Holt, who later said she “never would have let Marion go but for the apparent sincerity and disarming manner of the man,” released Marion to him. The man, apparently unaware that Marion had a twin sister, took only her. Marion was reported missing later that day.
The ransom
On 16 December, the first of several ransom demands arrived at the Parker home by telegram, demanding $1,500 in $20 gold certificates. The messages were signed with names such as “Fate,” “Death,” and “The Fox” — one signed “George Fox” — and some had words written in Greek. One telegram read: “Do positively nothing till you receive special delivery letter.” Another said: “Marion secure. Use good judgment. Interference with my plans dangerous.”
On the evening of 17 December, the kidnapper telephoned the Parker home and instructed Perry to leave at once with the money. Perry drove alone to the meeting place in central Los Angeles. The abductor, driving a Chrysler coupe, pulled up beside Perry’s car, holding him at gunpoint with a sawn-off shotgun, a bandana covering most of his face. Perry could see Marion seated in the passenger seat, concealed up to her neck by clothing, not visibly moving. When he called out to her, she did not respond, though her eyes were visibly open; he assumed she had been drugged.
As soon as the money was handed over, the abductor drove forward and pushed Marion’s body out of the car before speeding away. She had been killed before the exchange, and her body had been mutilated. Her limbs were found the next day in Elysian Park. The autopsy found she had been dead about twelve hours, and there were no signs of sexual assault.
The manhunt
The killer was identified quickly. Fingerprints taken from the getaway car — a Chrysler later found to have been stolen in San Diego — matched William Edward Hickman, born 1 February 1908, a 19-year-old former co-worker of Perry Parker. Both men had been employed by the First National Bank of Los Angeles, where Perry was an assistant cashier and Hickman an officer. The year before, Hickman had been arrested on a complaint made by Perry about stolen and forged checks totalling $400; he had been convicted and sentenced to probation.
Additional fingerprints lifted from the ransom letters were also identified as Hickman’s. A search of his apartment at the Bellevue Arms, where he had been living under the alias “Donald Evans,” found bloody footprints.
Hickman was tracked through the Pacific Northwest over several days, on sightings in Albany and Portland, Oregon, and Seattle, Washington, where he paid shopkeepers with the gold certificates from the ransom. On 22 December, a gas station proprietor in Portland recognised him from wanted posters. Officers found $1,400 of the ransom gold in the car, and arrested him in Echo, Oregon, the same day. He was extradited to California.
The confession and the trial
On the train back to Los Angeles, Hickman confessed to the district attorney and the chief of police. He admitted he had acted alone. He gave shifting accounts of his motive — at one point saying he wanted the money to go to college and to Bible school, at another saying he had killed Marion because he was afraid she would make a noise. He also claimed that a deity he called “Providence” had told him to commit the crime, and he told a journalist a story about accomplices named Cramer — a story police determined to be impossible, as the Cramers had been in prison for months.
Hickman and his defence claimed he was insane. He was one of the first defendants in California to use a new law allowing defendants to plead not guilty by reason of insanity. In February 1928, a jury rejected the defence, and the judge sentenced him to death by hanging. He appealed, and the California Supreme Court upheld the conviction.
In March 1928, Hickman and an accomplice, Welby Hunt, were also found guilty of first-degree murder in the death of a druggist, Clarence Ivy Toms, and received life sentences. On 19 October 1928, Hickman was hanged at San Quentin State Prison. He was twenty years old.
Marion Parker was survived by her parents, her elder brother, and her twin sister Marjorie. Her murder inspired ballads, including “Little Marian Parker,” recorded in 1928, and it has been retold in books and on screen ever since — most recently, loosely, in the 2020 revival of Perry Mason.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Frances Marion Parker (11 October 1915 – 17 December 1927), aged twelve, was taken from Mount Vernon Junior High School, Los Angeles, on 15 December 1927 by a man posing as an employee of her father Perry’s bank. Ransom telegrams demanded $1,500 in gold, signed “Fate,” “Death,” and “The Fox.” On 17 December, Perry paid the ransom and received his daughter’s body; she had been killed before the exchange. The killer was identified by fingerprints as William Edward Hickman (born 1 February 1908), a 19-year-old former co-worker of Perry Parker, and was arrested in Echo, Oregon, on 22 December 1927, with $1,400 of the ransom gold in his car. Hickman confessed on the train to Los Angeles. A jury rejected his insanity defence in February 1928, and he was sentenced to death; the California Supreme Court upheld the conviction. Hickman was hanged at San Quentin on 19 October 1928.
Unverified or unproven: Hickman’s motive — he gave shifting accounts, including money for college, fear she would make a noise, and a divine command from “Providence”; none was established as the true motive. Whether anyone else was involved — Hickman at one point claimed accomplices, but police established that the men he named had been in prison, and he later admitted he acted alone. The precise time and circumstances of Marion’s death rest on Hickman’s own confession, which was detailed but self-serving in places. The identity of the killer, and his guilt, are not in doubt: he was convicted on fingerprint evidence and his own confession.