The Trial of Mary Surratt: The Lincoln Conspirators and the First Woman Hanged by the Federal Government

Reading Time: 5 minutes ·

At about 1:15 in the afternoon of 7 July 1865, four people were led up thirteen steps to a gallows in the courtyard of the Washington Arsenal. Three were men: Lewis Powell, David Herold and George Atzerodt. The fourth was a forty-two-year-old widow named Mary Surratt, dressed in black, so ill and weak that she had to be supported by soldiers. Minutes later, all four were dead. Surratt had maintained her innocence to the end. She became the first woman ever executed by the United States government, and her case has been argued about ever since.

The Boarding House on H Street

Mary Elizabeth Jenkins was born around 1823 on a tobacco plantation in southern Maryland, near Waterloo. She married John Harrison Surratt, and after his death in 1862 she ran the family’s tavern at Surrattsville, Maryland — now Clinton — and then a boarding house on H Street in Washington, D.C. Her son, John Surratt Jr., was a Confederate courier, and her house became a meeting place for a circle of young men around the actor John Wilkes Booth.

Booth’s plan, in the last weeks of the Civil War, was elaborate: he would kill President Abraham Lincoln at Ford’s Theatre, Powell would kill Secretary of State William Seward at his home, and Atzerodt would kill Vice President Andrew Johnson. The aim was to decapitate the Union government in a single night. On 14 April 1865, five days after Robert E. Lee’s surrender at Appomattox, Booth shot Lincoln at Ford’s Theatre. Powell attacked Seward with a knife and seriously wounded him. Atzerodt lost his nerve and did nothing. Booth fled, and was killed twelve days later in Virginia. The others were hunted down within days.

Mary Surratt was arrested on 17 April, three days after the assassination, when police came to her boarding house. She insisted she knew nothing of any plot. Her son John had fled the country.

A Military Commission

On 1 May 1865, President Andrew Johnson ordered the eight accused conspirators to be tried not in a civilian court, but before a military commission of nine army officers. The decision was controversial from the start. Surratt’s lawyers argued that a military trial was illegal: the war was effectively over, the civil courts were open, and civilians were entitled to a jury. The government replied that the assassination was an act of war, and the commission went ahead.

The trial opened on 9 May 1865 and ran for seven weeks. More than three hundred witnesses testified, producing nearly five thousand pages of transcript. Mary Surratt was so ill during the final days that she was allowed to remain in her cell. The commission could convict on a simple majority and impose death on a two-thirds vote.

The most damaging evidence against her came from John Lloyd, the keeper of the Surrattsville tavern, who testified that Surratt had told him to have “shooting irons” ready for Booth’s men, and that she had given him a package containing Booth’s field glasses on the afternoon of the assassination. Another boarder, Louis Weichmann, testified about the meetings at the house and about a message Surratt had sent. Her defence — led by Frederick Aiken — argued that she was a boarding-house keeper who had rented rooms to the wrong men, and that the government had no direct evidence that she knew of a murder plot.

On 30 June 1865, the commission found all eight defendants guilty. Surratt, Powell, Herold and Atzerodt were sentenced to hang. Samuel Mudd, Michael O’Laughlen and Samuel Arnold received life imprisonment, and Edman Spangler six years. The conviction of Surratt herself was by the narrowest possible margin, and five of the nine commissioners signed a petition asking President Johnson to commute her sentence to life imprisonment, “in consideration of her sex and age”. The petition was attached to the findings sent to the president. Johnson approved the death sentences on 5 July and signed the execution order. He later claimed he had never seen the petition; nobody was ever able to prove whose version was true.

The Scaffold

A last attempt to save her, a writ of habeas corpus, failed when Johnson declared the writ suspended in her case. On 6 July, Surratt was told she would hang the next day. On 7 July, at the Washington Arsenal — now Fort McNair — the four condemned prisoners were led past their own freshly dug graves and up the scaffold steps. General John F. Hartranft read the death warrant. The trapdoor fell shortly after one o’clock. Surratt died maintaining her innocence, and the hangman who dropped the trap is said to have believed her.

Her son John was captured in Egypt in 1866 and brought back for trial in a civilian court in 1867. The jury could not agree, and he was released. He lived until 1916. Less than a year after his mother’s execution, the Supreme Court ruled in Ex parte Milligan that it was unconstitutional to try civilians before military commissions where the civil courts were open — the ruling that would have saved Mary Surratt, had it come in time.

Guilty or Scapegoat?

Historians still argue about Mary Surratt. Her defenders point to the thinness of the evidence — no witness heard her agree to a murder, and the key testimony came from Lloyd, a man with his own reasons to cooperate — and to the unfairness of a military trial with no jury, in a city still in shock. Her critics point to the pattern of meetings at her house, the “shooting irons”, the field glasses, and the message she sent on the day of the assassination, and argue that a woman who ran a boarding house for conspirators knew exactly what she was hosting.

What is not in dispute is the shape of the case: a woman tried by soldiers, convicted by the narrowest margin, recommended for mercy by most of the men who convicted her, and hanged anyway. It is one of the reasons the trial of the Lincoln conspirators remains the most argued-about trial in American history.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: Mary Surratt, a widowed boarding-house keeper in Washington, D.C., was arrested on 17 April 1865, three days after the assassination of Abraham Lincoln. She was tried with seven others before a nine-officer military commission that opened on 9 May 1865 and heard more than three hundred witnesses. On 30 June 1865, all eight were found guilty; Surratt, Lewis Powell, David Herold and George Atzerodt were sentenced to hang. Five of the nine commissioners petitioned President Johnson to commute Surratt’s sentence to life imprisonment. Johnson approved the death sentences on 5 July. Surratt was hanged on 7 July 1865 at the Washington Arsenal, the first woman executed by the United States government. Her son John was tried in a civilian court in 1867; the jury hung and he was released. In 1866 the Supreme Court ruled in Ex parte Milligan that military commissions could not try civilians where civil courts were open.

Not documented / unverified: Whether Mary Surratt knew that Booth planned murder, rather than a kidnapping, has never been settled: the conspirators originally planned to kidnap Lincoln, and the date on which the plan changed to assassination is itself disputed. Whether President Johnson saw the clemency petition before signing the execution order is unresolved — Johnson later said he had not, and the record does not prove otherwise. The exact time of the execution is given variously as 1:15 p.m. and 1:30 p.m. in different accounts.

Sources

Leave a Comment