Dean O’Banion was the most unlikely of Chicago’s gang bosses: a choirboy turned safecracker who ran the North Side Gang from a flower shop, arranged the flowers for the funerals of the men he had killed, and was murdered in that same shop on a November morning in 1924. His death opened the bloodiest gang war in Chicago’s history, a five-year conflict between the North Side Gang and the organisation of Johnny Torrio and Al Capone that ended in the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre. O’Banion himself had been dead for more than four years by then, but the war was his legacy.
Charles Dean O’Banion was born on 8 July 1892 in Maroa, Illinois, the son of an Irish immigrant house painter. His mother died of tuberculosis in 1901, and his father moved the family to Chicago, to the tough North Side neighbourhood known as Little Hell. As a boy O’Banion sang in the choir at Holy Name Cathedral and served as an altar boy, and the cathedral remained the centre of his life: his flower shop would stand directly across the street from it. He fell in with the Little Hell Gang, a youth gang that graduated into the Market Street Gang, and there he met the three men who would become his lifelong associates — Earl “Hymie” Weiss, Vincent “the Schemer” Drucci and George “Bugs” Moran.
The Flower Shop
O’Banion’s criminal career began with safecracking and robbery, but Prohibition made him rich. He built the North Side Gang into the dominant bootlegging organisation on the North Side of Chicago, running breweries, speakeasies and distribution routes, and he did it from an unlikely headquarters. In 1921 he married Viola Kaniff and bought a half share in William Schofield’s flower shop at 738 North State Street. O’Banion, who had a genuine passion for flower arranging, worked long hours in the shop and often brought a bouquet home to his wife. Schofield’s became the florist of choice for mob funerals across the city — a fact O’Banion is said to have appreciated — and the rooms above the shop served as the gang’s headquarters.
The flower shop was also the source of his downfall. In May 1924 O’Banion sold Johnny Torrio his share of the Sieben Brewery, knowing that the police were about to raid it. Torrio was arrested in the raid and later convicted of bootlegging. O’Banion had set a trap for the most powerful man in Chicago, and he knew it. He also quarrelled with the Genna brothers, the Sicilian bootleggers who controlled the Little Italy territory, over the price of alcohol. By the autumn of 1924 the men around Torrio had decided that O’Banion had to go.
The Morning of 10 November 1924
On the morning of 10 November 1924 O’Banion was clipping chrysanthemums in the back room of Schofield’s when three men entered the shop. One of them was Frankie Yale, a New York gangster who had come to Chicago ostensibly to discuss floral arrangements for the funeral of the gang leader Mike Merlo. With him were the gunmen John Scalise and Albert Anselmi. O’Banion greeted them warmly — “Hello, boys,” he is reported to have said. “You from Mike Merlo’s?” Yale shook his hand and gripped it tight, so that O’Banion could not move. At the same moment Scalise and Anselmi opened fire, hitting him in the chest, the cheeks and the throat. O’Banion died instantly. He was thirty-two years old. His bodyguard, Louis Alterie, had failed to turn up that morning, and O’Banion was alone in the shop.
The murder was never punished. No one was ever convicted of killing O’Banion, though Yale, Scalise and Anselmi were widely named as the killers. His funeral, on 14 November, was one of the biggest gangland funerals Chicago had ever seen, with flowers piled so high that they filled the funeral chapel. Holy Name Cathedral, the church where he had sung as a boy and which stood across the street from his shop, refused him a church service, and he was buried at Mount Carmel Cemetery in Hillside, Illinois.
The War That Followed
O’Banion’s death set off a war that lasted five years. His successor, Hymie Weiss, took the killing as a personal vendetta and pursued Torrio and Capone with a ferocity that shocked even Chicago. Torrio himself was shot and nearly killed in January 1925 and left the city. Weiss was murdered in 1926, Drucci the following year, and the North Side Gang was steadily worn down. The war ended on 14 February 1929, when seven men of the North Side Gang were lined up against a wall in a Clark Street garage and shot dead in the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre. By then the gang O’Banion had built was finished, and Capone’s organisation ruled Chicago.
O’Banion’s afterlife has been as colourful as his life. James Cagney’s character in the 1931 film The Public Enemy was partly based on O’Banion and his lieutenant Weiss, and the image of the gangster-florist has become one of the enduring figures of Prohibition Chicago. The reality was simpler and grimmer: a man who loved flowers and ran a murderous bootlegging gang, who set a trap for the most powerful criminal in Chicago and paid for it in his own shop, among the chrysanthemums, on a November morning.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Charles Dean O’Banion was born on 8 July 1892 in Maroa, Illinois; his mother died of tuberculosis in 1901 and his father moved the family to Chicago. He sang in the choir at Holy Name Cathedral as a boy. He became the leader of the North Side Gang during Prohibition. In 1921 he married Viola Kaniff and bought a half share in William Schofield’s flower shop at 738 North State Street, Chicago; the rooms above the shop served as the gang’s headquarters. In May 1924 he sold Johnny Torrio his share of the Sieben Brewery shortly before a police raid in which Torrio was arrested. On the morning of 10 November 1924 O’Banion was shot dead in the back room of Schofield’s by Frankie Yale, John Scalise and Albert Anselmi, according to the standard account. No one was ever convicted of the murder. He was buried at Mount Carmel Cemetery, Hillside, Illinois. His death was followed by a five-year gang war that ended with the St. Valentine’s Day Massacre on 14 February 1929.
Not documented / unverified: Sources disagree on O’Banion’s birthplace, with some giving Aurora, Illinois, rather than Maroa. The exact words spoken in the flower shop on the morning of the murder are reported, not recorded, and vary between accounts. Some accounts name different men among the killers, including members of the Genna family. The claim that Holy Name Cathedral refused O’Banion a church funeral service is reported in several accounts but is not documented in the cathedral’s own records.
Sources
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dean_O%27Banion
https://nationalcrimesyndicate.com/who-was-dean-obanion-how-did-he-get-killed/?amp=1
https://Myalcaponemuseum.com/id158.htm
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hymie_Weiss