The Murder of William Desmond Taylor

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On the morning of 2 February 1922, William Desmond Taylor’s valet arrived at his employer’s bungalow in the Alvarado Court Apartments in Westlake, Los Angeles, and found him dead on the floor. A man who identified himself as a doctor stepped forward, made a cursory examination, declared that Taylor had died of a stomach haemorrhage — and was never seen again. When investigators rolled the body over, they found the truth: the 49-year-old film director had been shot once in the back.

Taylor’s murder became the first great unsolved crime of Hollywood, and it remains unsolved more than a century later. It was also a case in which the investigation itself became part of the scandal: a trampled crime scene, missing evidence, and a film industry determined to keep its secrets.

The director

William Cunningham Deane-Tanner was born on 26 April 1872 at Carlow, Ireland, into an Anglo-Irish family, and came to America in 1891. After years in theatre and a mysterious disappearance in 1908 — he deserted his wife and daughter in New York and resurfaced years later in California under a new name — he became one of Hollywood’s most respected directors, making fifty-nine silent films between 1914 and 1922 for Famous Players–Lasky. He was also president of the Motion Picture Directors Association. He was, by every account, a man of culture, education, and refinement.

Taylor lived in a bungalow at the Alvarado Court Apartments. On the evening of 1 February 1922, the actress Mabel Normand — the great comedy star of the silent screen, and a close friend — visited him. According to Normand, she left at about 7:45 p.m., carrying a book he had lent her, and the two blew kisses to each other as her limousine drove away. She was the last person known to have seen him alive. The time of his death was later set at 7:50 p.m.

The investigation

In Taylor’s pockets, investigators found a wallet holding $78 in cash, a silver cigarette case, a Waltham pocket watch, a pen knife, and a locket bearing a photograph of Mabel Normand. A two-carat diamond ring was still on his finger. Robbery did not look like the motive — except that a large sum of cash, which Taylor had shown to his accountant the day before, was missing and never accounted for.

The crime scene was compromised almost immediately. Neighbours crowded into the bungalow, and at least one studio troubleshooter was reported to have removed or planted evidence. The murder weapon, a small-calibre pistol, was never found. A detective who worked the case later told the director King Vidor: “We were doing all right and then, before a week was out, we got the word to lay off.” The studios, facing a public backlash against Hollywood, were widely believed to have wanted the case contained.

The suspects

No one was ever charged, but the case produced a cast of suspects that has filled books ever since.

Mabel Normand was interrogated at length by the Los Angeles police, who ruled her out as a suspect. Taylor had been deeply concerned about her cocaine addiction, and according to the writer Robert Giroux, he had met with federal prosecutors shortly before his death and offered to testify against her drug suppliers. Giroux believed the suppliers hired a contract killer. That theory has never been proven, and most subsequent writers have also ruled Normand out.

Charlotte Shelby, the mother of the young actress Mary Miles Minter, was the most persistent suspect. Her statements to police were described as evasive and “obviously filled with lies” about her daughter’s relationship with Taylor. She allegedly owned a rare .38-calibre pistol with unusual bullets very similar to the kind that had killed Taylor; after that became public, she reportedly threw the pistol into a Louisiana bayou. Her other daughter, Margaret Shelby, openly accused her mother of the murder in 1938. At least two Los Angeles County district attorneys publicly declined to prosecute her, and the district attorney Buron Fitts later concluded the evidence was insufficient for an indictment. The remaining case files subsequently disappeared. Shelby died in 1957.

Margaret Gibson — the actress who had worked with Taylor when he first came to Hollywood, later known as Patricia Palmer — reportedly confessed to the murder shortly before her death in 1964. That confession, reported second-hand, has never been verified.

Edward Sands, Taylor’s former valet, had forged Taylor’s signature on checks and stolen money and valuables, including a car, from his home in 1921. He was never charged in the murder.

The aftermath

Taylor’s funeral took place on 7 February 1922 at St. Paul’s Cathedral in Los Angeles, and he was buried in a mausoleum at Hollywood Cemetery, now Hollywood Forever Cemetery. His crypt reads: “In Memory of William C. Deane-Tanner, Beloved Father of Ethel Deane-Tanner. Died 1 February 1922.”

The murder’s cultural impact was enormous. It was, by contemporary accounts, the first American murder in which so many people felt a personal interest, because the names involved were familiar from the screen. Anti-Hollywood feeling peaked in the weeks that followed, with editorials denouncing the film colony as a modern Sodom and Gomorrah. The case also damaged the careers of those caught in its orbit: Normand’s reputation never recovered, and she died of tuberculosis in 1930, at 37.

Copies of a few documents from the police files were made public in 2007. The rest of the physical evidence is gone. Books continue to claim the case is solved — one blames Shelby, another blames Minter, another blames drug suppliers — but no conclusive evidence has ever been produced linking the crime to any particular person.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: William Desmond Taylor (born William Cunningham Deane-Tanner, 26 April 1872, Carlow, Ireland) was shot once in the back and found dead in his bungalow at the Alvarado Court Apartments, Los Angeles, on 2 February 1922; the time of death was set at 7:50 p.m. on 1 February. Mabel Normand was the last person known to have seen him alive, leaving at about 7:45 p.m. His valuables remained on his body, but a large sum of cash shown to his accountant the day before was missing. The murder weapon was never found. No one was ever charged. Taylor was buried at Hollywood Cemetery (now Hollywood Forever). District Attorney Buron Fitts later concluded the evidence against Charlotte Shelby was insufficient for an indictment.

Unverified or unproven: That Charlotte Shelby killed Taylor — she was suspected and her statements were evasive, but no charges were ever brought and the evidence was judged insufficient. That Margaret Gibson confessed to the murder — the confession was reported second-hand, shortly before her death in 1964, and has never been verified. That drug suppliers hired a contract killer because Taylor offered to testify against them — this is Robert Giroux’s theory, not a proven fact. That the studios ordered the investigation curtailed — a detective’s later account, widely repeated, but not documented in the official record. Any claim that a specific person fired the shot is unproven.

Sources

Leave a Comment