Keith Hunter Jesperson was a long-haul truck driver who killed eight women between 1990 and 1995. He was not caught because of a single piece of forensic evidence. He was caught, in the end, because he could not bear to let someone else take the credit for his crimes — and because the letters he wrote to claim that credit gave investigators the proof they needed. His case is also one of the starkest examples in American history of a wrongful conviction: two innocent people spent more than four years in prison for a murder Jesperson committed.
Jesperson was born on 6 April 1955 in Canada, and grew up in the United States. As an adult he worked as a long-distance truck driver, a job that gave him mobility across many states, long stretches of time alone, and a ready explanation for being anywhere on the highway system. The women he killed were often vulnerable — women he met in bars, at truck stops, and on the road — and their cases, spread across several states, were not connected to one another for years.
The First Murder and the Wrong Convictions
His first confirmed victim was Taunja Bennett, a 23-year-old woman whose body was found near Portland, Oregon, in January 1990. The case drew intense media attention in Oregon, and in 1991 a woman named Laverne Pavlinac confessed to killing Bennett with her boyfriend, John Sosnovske. Both were convicted and sent to prison.
The confession was false. Pavlinac later said she had made it up to escape an abusive relationship, believing that the police would discover the truth. They did not, and the case was closed — with the wrong people behind bars.
Jesperson, who had killed Bennett, was furious. He had committed what he considered a perfect crime, and two other people were receiving the attention for it. Within weeks of Bennett’s murder he wrote a confession on the wall of a truck-stop bathroom, signing it with a smiley face. When that produced no response, he began writing letters — to the media and to prosecutors — confessing to his murders and signing each one with a smiley face. In May 1994 he sent a six-page letter to The Oregonian newspaper in Portland, admitting to killing Bennett and several other women. Phil Stanford, the columnist who covered the story, dubbed the anonymous letter-writer the “Happy Face Killer,” and the name stuck.
A forensic handwriting expert later determined that the handwriting in the letter matched the writing in the bathroom-wall confessions. But at the time, investigators were sceptical. They believed they already had the right people in prison, and they were slow to accept that a truck driver writing to newspapers could be telling the truth.
Caught by His Last Murder
Jesperson’s final known victim was Julie Winningham, his own girlfriend. Her body was found on 11 March 1995 beside Highway 14 near Skamania County, Washington. Investigators searching her property found a receipt for the sale of her car, signed by Jesperson as a witness. When they questioned him, he confessed to her murder the following day — and then, piece by piece, to the rest.
The arrest came on 30 March 1995. Before it, Jesperson had written a letter to his older brother Brad, saying: “I am sorry that I turned out this way. I have been a killer for five years and have killed eight people. Assaulted more.” Brad, instead of destroying the letter as Jesperson had asked, turned it over to the police. It became a central piece of evidence.
In custody, Jesperson led investigators to Bennett’s purse, which he had hidden in a place only the killer could have known, and provided details of her killing that had never been made public. The evidence was conclusive. In November 1995 he pleaded guilty or no contest to the murders of Winningham and Bennett, and to the murder of Laurie Ann Pentland in Salem, Oregon. On 27 November 1995 — more than four years after their convictions — Pavlinac and Sosnovske were released from prison.
The Victims
Eight murders have been confirmed. The victims were Taunja Bennett in Oregon; Julie Winningham in Washington; Laurie Ann Pentland in Salem, Oregon; Suzanne Kjellenberg in Florida; Cynthia Lyn Rose in California; Angela Subrize in Wyoming; and Patricia Skiple in California. Skiple, known for years only as “Blue Pacheco” after a tattoo, was identified by DNA analysis and genealogy research in 2022. The eighth victim was a woman killed in Blythe, California, in 1992; Jesperson pleaded guilty to that murder in 2010. He has claimed to have killed as many as 160 people. Only eight murders have been confirmed, and the larger claim has never been supported by evidence.
Jesperson received multiple life sentences and is serving them at the Oregon State Penitentiary in Salem. He was spared the death penalty in exchange for his confessions.
Why the Case Still Matters
The Jesperson case is remembered for its nickname, but it should be remembered for something else: it is a case study in how a wrongful conviction happens and how hard it is to undo. Pavlinac and Sosnovske were convicted on a false confession, and the system resisted the evidence that they were innocent even when the real killer was writing letters to newspapers to say so. It took Jesperson’s arrest, his confession, and his ability to point investigators to evidence only the killer could know before the two were freed. They lost more than four years of their lives.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Keith Hunter Jesperson was born on 6 April 1955. He killed eight women between January 1990 and March 1995, a span confirmed by the record of his crimes. His first victim was Taunja Bennett, found near Portland, Oregon, in January 1990. Laverne Pavlinac and John Sosnovske falsely confessed to Bennett’s murder, were convicted in 1991, and were released on 27 November 1995 after Jesperson’s confession was confirmed. Jesperson wrote a confession on a truck-stop bathroom wall signed with a smiley face, and in May 1994 sent a six-page letter to The Oregonian signed the same way; columnist Phil Stanford dubbed him the “Happy Face Killer.” His final victim was Julie Winningham, whose body was found on 11 March 1995 in Skamania County, Washington. He was arrested on 30 March 1995, after confessing to Winningham’s murder, and a letter to his brother Brad admitting to eight murders was turned over to police. He led investigators to Bennett’s purse, providing details only the killer could have known. He pleaded guilty or no contest to several murders in November 1995 and received multiple life sentences. He is held at the Oregon State Penitentiary. Patricia Skiple, long known only as “Blue Pacheco,” was identified in 2022.
Not documented / unverified: Jesperson’s claim to have killed as many as 160 people is unconfirmed and is not supported by evidence; only eight murders have been confirmed. Sources differ on the precise location of the bathroom-wall confession — some say a bus terminal in Livingston, others a truck stop — and on the exact dates of some events, including whether Winningham’s body was found on 10 or 11 March 1995. The identities of the victims are given consistently across the main sources, but the spelling of some names varies (Kjellenberg, Subrize), and the Blythe, California victim’s name is not consistently reported. The details of Jesperson’s childhood and motives come largely from his own accounts and from a book by the journalist Jack Olsen, and should be read as his version of events, not as independently verified fact.
Sources
- https://www.aetv.com/articles/keith-jesperson-happy-face-killer
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Keith_Hunter_Jesperson?oldid=438540320
- https://allcountygazette.com/is-happy-face-a-true-story-revisiting-the-murders-of-keith-hunter-jesperson/
- https://www.femalefirst.co.uk/features/true-crime-keith-jesperson-happy-face-killer-murders-story-sinister-saturday-1280188.html