The Trial of Oscar Pistorius

Reading Time: 5 minutes ·

Oscar Pistorius was one of the most famous athletes in the world. A double amputee sprinter from South Africa, he had competed on carbon-fibre blades — the reason for his nickname, the “Blade Runner” — at the 2012 London Olympic and Paralympic Games, becoming the first amputee sprinter to compete at the Olympics. Six months later, in the early hours of Valentine’s Day 2013, he shot and killed his girlfriend, Reeva Steenkamp, in his home in Pretoria. The trial that followed was broadcast live around the world, and its verdict was overturned on appeal — a sequence almost without precedent in a case of this profile.

Reeva Steenkamp was 29 years old, a model and a law graduate, who had been dating Pistorius for a few months. She was, by all accounts, a warm and ambitious young woman with a career in front of her. She is the victim at the centre of this case, and the legal argument that followed was about what Pistorius intended, and what he must have foreseen, in the seconds before he fired. It was never about whether he had fired the shots. He admitted that from the start.

The Night of 14 February 2013

In the early hours of Thursday 14 February 2013, at Pistorius’s home in a gated estate in Pretoria, Steenkamp was shot four times through the locked door of a toilet cubicle inside the bathroom. Pistorius fired the shots from a licensed 9mm pistol. Steenkamp died from her wounds. Pistorius later said he had broken down the bathroom door with a cricket bat and found her inside.

The prosecution, led by Gerrie Nel, argued a very different version. It said the couple had argued, that Steenkamp had taken refuge in the toilet cubicle, and that Pistorius had deliberately fired at her through the door, intending to kill her. The state pointed to neighbours who said they had heard shouting and arguing before the shots, to the sequence of the shots, and to the fact that Pistorius had not checked where Steenkamp was before firing. The defence disputed the neighbours’ evidence and said the sounds they had heard were Pistorius shouting for help after the shooting.

The Trial in Pretoria

The trial, formally the State v. Oscar Pistorius, opened on 3 March 2014 in the Gauteng Division of the High Court in Pretoria, before Judge Thokozile Masipa. It was one of the first South African trials to be substantially broadcast live on television, and it was followed around the world for seven months. Pistorius testified in his own defence, breaking down repeatedly under cross-examination by Nel, who challenged his account in detail and showed the court a video of Pistorius firing a gun at a watermelon to demonstrate the destructive power of the ammunition.

On 11 and 12 September 2014, Judge Masipa delivered her verdict. She acquitted Pistorius of premeditated murder and of murder, finding that the state had not proved that he had intended to kill Steenkamp, or that he had known she was behind the door. She found him guilty instead of culpable homicide — the South African offence closest to manslaughter — in Steenkamp’s death, and guilty of reckless endangerment with a firearm for an earlier incident in which he had fired a pistol under a table in a packed restaurant. She acquitted him of two other firearms charges, including illegally possessing ammunition and firing a pistol through the sunroof of a car.

On 21 October 2014, Masipa sentenced Pistorius to a maximum of five years in prison for culpable homicide, with a concurrent three-year suspended sentence for the restaurant incident. He began serving his sentence the same day. On 19 October 2015, after serving about a year — one-sixth of his sentence, as South African law allowed — he was released to house arrest under correctional supervision.

The Appeal That Changed the Verdict

The state appealed the culpable homicide conviction, arguing that Judge Masipa had made an error of law. The question was a narrow but decisive one: did it matter that Pistorius may not have known Steenkamp was behind the door? The prosecution argued that it did not. Under the South African legal principle of dolus eventualis — sometimes described as murder by foresight — a person is guilty of murder if they foresaw that their actions might kill someone and proceeded anyway, even if they did not know or intend who that person was.

In December 2015, the Supreme Court of Appeal in Bloemfontein agreed. In a unanimous judgment, Justice Eric Leach found that the trial court had erred: Pistorius must have foreseen that whoever was behind the toilet door could be killed when he fired four shots through it with a high-powered pistol, and he had proceeded regardless. The court overturned the culpable homicide conviction and substituted a conviction for murder. Pistorius’s lawyers sought to challenge the ruling in the Constitutional Court, but that avenue required a point of constitutional law, and it did not succeed in reversing the murder conviction.

The case returned to Judge Masipa for resentencing. On 6 July 2016, she sentenced Pistorius to six years in prison for murder — well below the fifteen-year minimum ordinarily prescribed for murder in South Africa, on the grounds of mitigating circumstances. The state appealed again, this time against the leniency of the sentence. In November 2017, the Supreme Court of Appeal increased the sentence to fifteen years, with the time Pistorius had already served reducing the remaining term to thirteen years and five months.

What Is Documented, and What Is Not

Documented facts: In the early hours of 14 February 2013, Oscar Pistorius shot Reeva Steenkamp four times through a locked toilet door at his home in Pretoria, killing her. His trial opened on 3 March 2014 before Judge Thokozile Masipa in Pretoria. On 11–12 September 2014 she acquitted him of murder but found him guilty of culpable homicide and reckless endangerment with a firearm, and on 21 October 2014 sentenced him to five years in prison. He was released to house arrest on 19 October 2015. In December 2015 the Supreme Court of Appeal overturned the culpable homicide conviction and substituted a murder conviction on the basis of dolus eventualis. On 6 July 2016 Masipa sentenced him to six years for murder; in November 2017 the Supreme Court of Appeal increased the sentence to fifteen years, with time served reducing the remaining term to thirteen years and five months. He was granted parole in November 2023 and released in January 2024, with conditions running until his sentence expired in December 2029.

Unverified or unestablished claims: What Pistorius intended, and what he believed, in the moments before he fired remains disputed — his account of mistaking Steenkamp for an intruder was rejected as a basis for acquittal on murder by the appeal court, but no court has established as fact that he knew Steenkamp was behind the door, or that the couple had argued before the shooting. Neighbours’ accounts of shouting and arguing were contested at trial and should not be presented as settled fact. Claims in later commentary that the trial was unfair are legal arguments, not court findings, and remain contested.

Sources

  • https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_of_Oscar_Pistorius
  • https://www.aetv.com/articles/oscar-pistorius-murder
  • https://www.wmot.org/2015-12-03/appeals-court-convicts-oscar-pistorius-of-murder?_amp=true
  • https://www.tntsports.co.uk/athletics/oscar-pistorius-case-how-and-why-verdict-was-overturned_sto5013168/story.shtml

Leave a Comment