On 12 June 1977, around 140 girls arrived at Camp Scott, a Girl Scout camp on 410 acres of wooded land in Mayes County, Oklahoma, near Locust Grove, for a week-long summer session. It was the camp’s 49th year, run by the Tulsa-based Magic Empire Girl Scout Council. For three of those girls, it was their first night at camp. By the morning of 13 June, all three were dead.
Lori Lee Farmer was eight years old. Michele Heather Guse was nine. Doris Denise Milner was ten. All three were from the Tulsa area, and all three had been assigned to the Kiowa unit’s tent eight — a tent set further from the counsellors’ area than the others, and partly screened by nearby camp buildings. Their bodies were found later that day in a wooded area near the camp, left in their sleeping bags along a trail leading towards the shower facilities.
Investigators concluded the girls had been killed by strangulation and blunt-force injuries, and that they had been sexually assaulted. The details of what was done to them will not be repeated here. What matters is who they were: three children, on their first night away at camp, whose families had trusted that they would be safe.
The camp, and the warning
Camp Scott had been a fixture of Girl Scouting in eastern Oklahoma since 1928. The camp sat in dense woodland, and the Kiowa unit was one of its more isolated sections. In the years since, much attention has been paid to the camp’s layout and to security that night — to how far tent eight stood from adult supervision, and to reports that a note warning of danger had been found at the camp before the killings and dismissed.
The families of the victims later brought a civil case against the Magic Empire Council, arguing that the camp had failed to keep the girls safe. In 1985, a jury ruled in favour of the Council. The verdict settled the legal question of the camp’s liability, but it did not answer the question that mattered most to the families: who had entered that tent in the night.
Camp Scott was evacuated after the murders and never reopened.
Gene Leroy Hart
Attention quickly turned to Gene Leroy Hart, a 33-year-old Cherokee man from the local area. Hart had a history of serious violent and sexual offences, and he had escaped from the Mayes County Jail in 1973. He had been at large for four years, living in the woods and hills around Locust Grove, an area he knew well. He was familiar with Camp Scott and its surroundings.
Hart was arrested within a year of the murders and charged with killing the three girls. His trial began in March 1979. The prosecution’s case rested heavily on circumstantial evidence: Hart’s presence in the area, his history, and items said to link him to the crime. The defence argued that the evidence did not prove Hart had been in the camp that night, and that investigators had fixed on him too quickly.
The jury returned a unanimous verdict of not guilty. Hart was returned to prison to serve the remainder of his earlier sentences. On 4 June 1979, just two months after his acquittal, he collapsed and died of a heart attack while running in the prison yard. He was 35.
The acquittal left the case in a strange position. The only man ever charged had been found not guilty by a jury. No one else was ever charged. Legally, the murders of Lori, Michele, and Doris remain unsolved.
The DNA evidence
The case did not end with Hart’s death. In 1989, the Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation carried out DNA testing on samples recovered from the scene. The results were inconclusive: three of five probes matched Hart’s DNA, but the profile was shared by about one in every 7,700 Native Americans. As Hart was a member of the Cherokee Nation, he could not be ruled out — but neither could thousands of other people. The testing could not close the case.
Decades later, advances in DNA testing allowed a fresh analysis. Testing carried out in 2017, and made public in 2022 at the request of the victims’ families, strongly suggested Hart’s involvement, according to statements attributed to local authorities. The Mayes County Sheriff’s Office has said it considers the DNA results consistent with Hart having been the contributor of DNA found at the scene, and some reports describe the sheriff’s office as considering the case solved.
That is not the same as a legal resolution. There was no trial of the new evidence, no conviction, and no court finding. Hart died in 1979, and he can never be tried again. Wikipedia and other reference sources continue to list the case as officially unsolved, and that is the status used here: the DNA evidence points strongly towards Hart, but the case has never been resolved in court, and the families never saw a conviction.
Why the case still matters
The Oklahoma Girl Scout murders changed how American summer camps think about security. Camps across the country reviewed the placement of tents, the distance between children’s sleeping areas and adult supervision, and the way warnings and unfamiliar visitors were handled. The case became a reference point in debates about how institutions protect children in their care — and about what happens when the systems meant to keep children safe fail.
For the families, the decades since 1977 have brought partial answers and no closure. They know how their daughters died, and they have been told that modern science points to the man who was tried and acquitted. What they do not have, and can never now have, is a verdict. The three girls — Lori, eight; Michele, nine; and Doris, ten — remain at the centre of a case that the law calls unsolved, nearly fifty years after their first night at camp.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Three Girl Scouts — Lori Lee Farmer, 8, Michele Heather Guse, 9, and Doris Denise Milner, 10 — were killed at Camp Scott, Mayes County, Oklahoma, on the morning of 13 June 1977, on their first night at camp. Gene Leroy Hart was charged, tried in March 1979, and acquitted by a unanimous jury. Hart died of a heart attack on 4 June 1979. DNA testing in 1989 was inconclusive. Camp Scott closed after the murders and never reopened. A civil case against the camp’s council was decided in the Council’s favour in 1985.
Unverified or unproven: That Hart was the killer — later DNA testing, reported in 2022, strongly suggests his involvement according to local authorities, but there has been no conviction and the case remains officially unsolved. Claims that a warning note found at the camp was ignored before the killings — reported in some accounts, but the note’s significance has never been established by a court. Any suggestion that another person was involved — no other suspect has been charged, and no evidence publicly supports a second perpetrator.