The Kidnapping of John Paul Getty III

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

John Paul Getty III was 16 years old and living a bohemian life in Rome in the summer of 1973 when he was taken from a public square in the middle of the night. He was the grandson of J. Paul Getty, the oil tycoon then regarded as the richest man in the world, and the eldest son of John Paul Getty Jr. The kidnappers wanted 17 million dollars. His grandfather’s first answer was no — and that refusal, and what followed, made the case one of the most famous kidnappings of the twentieth century.

Paul, as he was known, had been born in 1956 and raised between Britain and Italy. By 1973 he was living in Rome, largely on his own, after being expelled from a private school. That visibility made him an easy target. The men who took him belonged to the ‘Ndrangheta, the organised crime group based in Calabria in southern Italy, although that connection was not fully understood at the time.

Taken in the Piazza Farnese

At about 3 a.m. on 10 July 1973, Paul was walking in the Piazza Farnese in Rome when a car stopped beside him. Men got out, seized him, and forced him into the car. He was blindfolded, driven south for hours, and held in the mountains of Calabria. He later described being chained and kept in a cave or remote hiding place, moved from one location to another while his captors waited for the ransom.

Two days after the kidnapping, his mother, Gail Harris, received a ransom letter demanding 17 million dollars for his safe return. The letter was made from words cut from magazines. The police and even some members of the family were initially sceptical. Paul had a reputation as a rebellious teenager, and there was a suspicion — shared, at first, by the Italian police — that the whole thing might be a hoax, a trick by Paul to extract money from his grandfather. That suspicion wasted valuable time. His mother took the threat seriously from the start, but she was divorced and no longer wealthy, and she did not have the money herself.

J. Paul Getty Sr. refused to pay. He said that he had 14 other grandchildren, and that if he paid a penny now, he would have 14 kidnapped grandchildren. The remark has become the most quoted line of the case.

The Ear

After three months, the kidnappers acted to prove they were serious. In November 1973, an envelope was delivered to a daily newspaper in Rome. It contained a lock of Paul’s hair and a human ear, together with a note. The note read: “This is Paul’s ear. If we don’t get some money within 10 days, then the other ear will arrive. In other words, he will arrive in little bits.” The second ransom demand in the envelope was for about 3.2 million dollars, a sharp reduction from the original 17 million.

The delivery of the ear changed everything. It was now beyond doubt that Paul was in real danger, and the negotiations began in earnest. An American government role and a former FBI agent were involved in the talks, and the price was negotiated down further, to about 3 million dollars. Getty Sr. finally agreed to contribute 2.2 million dollars — the maximum amount, his advisers said, that would be tax deductible. He lent the remainder, about 700,000 to 800,000 dollars depending on the account, to his son, John Paul Getty Jr., at 4 percent interest. The son would have to repay his own father for the money that freed his own son.

The ransom was paid in Italian lira and delivered by Getty Sr.’s security specialist, former CIA operative James Fletcher Chace. Shortly afterwards, on 15 December 1973, Paul was found alive at a petrol station in Lauria, in the province of Potenza in southern Italy. He had been held for five months. He was malnourished, bruised and missing an ear, and he was found in the rain. He telephoned his grandfather to thank him for paying the ransom. Getty Sr. refused to come to the phone.

The Trial

Nine men were arrested for the kidnapping, including a carpenter, a hospital orderly, a former convict and an olive-oil dealer from Calabria, as well as high-ranking members of the ‘Ndrangheta, including Girolamo Piromalli and Saverio Mammoliti. Only two of the nine were convicted and sent to prison. The others, including the ‘Ndrangheta bosses, were acquitted for lack of evidence. Most of the ransom money was never recovered; only a small fraction, reported as about 85,000 dollars, was found.

The case was later retold in John Pearson’s book Painfully Rich, in the film All the Money in the World (2017) and in the television series Trust (2018).

The Cost That Came Later

Paul’s life never recovered. In 1977 he had surgery to rebuild the ear his kidnappers had cut off. He became dependent on drugs and alcohol, and in 1981 he suffered a stroke brought on by a cocktail of drugs and alcohol. The stroke left him speechless, nearly blind and partly paralysed for the rest of his life. He had to sue his own father to raise money for his medical care. He died in 2011, at the age of 54, having lived for three decades with the consequences of five months in captivity and of the years that followed.

It is easy to treat this case as a story about a rich man’s stinginess, and that is how it is often told. It is also a story about a 16-year-old boy who was left for months in the hands of violent men while adults argued about money, tax and principle.

What Is Established, and What Is Not

Documented facts: John Paul Getty III, aged 16, was kidnapped in the Piazza Farnese, Rome, at about 3 a.m. on 10 July 1973; the kidnappers demanded 17 million dollars; his grandfather, J. Paul Getty, initially refused to pay; in November 1973 an envelope containing a lock of hair and Paul’s ear was sent to a newspaper with a reduced demand of about 3.2 million dollars and the threat quoted above; a ransom of about 2.9 million dollars was eventually paid, of which Getty Sr. paid 2.2 million dollars and lent the remainder to his son at 4 percent interest; Paul was found alive on 15 December 1973 at a petrol station in Lauria; nine men were arrested and two were convicted; most of the ransom was never recovered; Paul had surgery to rebuild his ear in 1977 and suffered a disabling stroke in 1981.

Unverified or disputed: The exact total of the final ransom is reported as about 2.8 million to about 2.9 million dollars in different sources, and the loaned balance as 700,000 to about 1 million dollars; this article gives the figures most consistently reported. The precise locations where Paul was held in Calabria are not fully documented in the public record. Details of the negotiations, and the exact words Getty Sr. used when refusing to pay, come from contemporary reporting and later books and should be treated as reported rather than verbatim court evidence.

Sources

Leave a Comment