The Bear Brook Murders: Four Names Found After Forty Years

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On 10 November 1985, a hunter walking near Bear Brook State Park in Allenstown, New Hampshire, came across a metal 55-gallon drum lying in the woods, close to the burned-out shell of a store on Route 28. Inside were the remains of an adult woman and a young girl, wrapped in plastic. Both had died of blunt-force trauma, according to the autopsies. The two were buried in an Allenstown cemetery under a headstone that did not name them, because nobody knew who they were. For fifteen years, that was where the case stood: two unidentified victims, no suspect, and no clear account of what had happened to them.

Then, on 9 May 2000, investigators returned to the area for a fresh look. About ninety metres from the first site, outside the perimeter that had been searched in 1985, they found a second drum. Inside were the remains of two more young girls. They, too, had died of blunt-force trauma. The four victims became known collectively as the Allenstown Four, after the town where they were found, and the case became known as the Bear Brook murders, after the state park across the road. The investigators believed all four had been killed within roughly the same period, but the exact dates of their deaths were never established.

The long wait for science

For years, the investigation was limited by the science of its time. There was no national DNA database for unidentified remains when the first drum was found, and the victims’ fingerprints and dental records matched no missing-person report that investigators could find. Facial reconstructions were released, and the case was publicised, but no family came forward. The victims had vanished so completely that it seemed possible nobody was looking for them at all.

That changed slowly. In 2014, mitochondrial DNA testing established that the adult woman and the oldest and youngest girls were maternally related, and further testing in 2015 confirmed that the woman was the biological mother of two of the three children in the family group. The second-youngest child, the one found in the second drum, was not related to the other three. That finding mattered, because it suggested that the group in the drums was not a single family in the ordinary sense. It also set up the question that would eventually break the case open: who was the man connected to them?

A man of many names

In January 2017, New Hampshire authorities publicly announced that Bob Evans was a suspect in the Bear Brook case, and that DNA had confirmed he was the father of the middle child found in the drums. His legal identity, however, was still unknown. He had used many aliases over the years, including Robert Evans, Gordon Jenson, Curtis Kimball and Larry Vanner. In June 2017, police released a video of a police interview with Evans from 2002, hoping someone would recognise him. At the same time, genetic genealogist Barbara Rae-Venter was using genetic genealogy to narrow down his identity, uploading a DNA profile to a public consumer genealogy database, finding distant cousins who shared segments of it, and building their family trees backwards until the trees intersected.

Two months later, in August 2017, Y-DNA testing confirmed the result: the man was Terry Peder Rasmussen, born in Denver, Colorado, in 1943. A DNA sample contributed by one of his children from what is believed to have been his first marriage had provided the match. The identification was the first major case in the United States in which genetic genealogy was used to identify a crime suspect, a method that would later be used in other high-profile cold cases, including the Golden State Killer case. Rasmussen had already been convicted in 2002, under the alias Curtis Kimball, of murdering his then-wife Eunsoon Jun in California, and he had died in prison in December 2010. He was therefore never charged with, or tried for, the Bear Brook killings, and he was never asked a single question about the four bodies in the drums, because nobody knew to ask him while he was alive.

Giving the victims their names

Knowing the suspect’s name did not give the victims theirs. That work took longer, and it depended on the same genetic genealogy methods, along with the research of a Connecticut librarian, Rebekah Heath, who had been following the case as a private project. On 6 June 2019, New Hampshire investigators publicly identified three of the four victims: Marlyse Elizabeth Honeychurch, born in 1954, and her daughters Marie Elizabeth Vaughn, born in 1971, and Sarah Lynn McWaters, born in 1977. All three had last been seen around Thanksgiving 1978, after Honeychurch had left California with Rasmussen. The fourth victim, previously known only as the middle child, remained unidentified for another six years. In September 2025, New Hampshire police positively identified her as Rea Rasmussen, born in 1976, Terry Rasmussen’s own daughter. A California birth certificate and genetic testing identified her mother as Pepper Reed, who had disappeared from California in the late 1970s and is also suspected to have been a victim of Rasmussen, although that has not been proven in court.

What the record shows

Documented: A hunter found a drum containing an adult woman and a young girl near Bear Brook State Park, Allenstown, New Hampshire, on 10 November 1985; a second drum containing two more young girls was found nearby on 9 May 2000. All four died of blunt-force trauma. Mitochondrial DNA testing in 2014–2015 showed the adult woman was the mother of two of the girls; the middle child was unrelated to the other three. In August 2017, Y-DNA testing confirmed that the man known as Robert Evans was Terry Peder Rasmussen (1943–2010) of Denver, Colorado. Rasmussen had been convicted in 2002, as Curtis Kimball, of murdering Eunsoon Jun in California, and died in prison in December 2010. On 6 June 2019, three victims were identified as Marlyse Elizabeth Honeychurch (born 1954) and her daughters Marie Elizabeth Vaughn (born 1971) and Sarah Lynn McWaters (born 1977), last seen around Thanksgiving 1978. In September 2025, the fourth victim was identified as Rea Rasmussen (born 1976), Rasmussen’s daughter. No one has been charged or convicted specifically for the Bear Brook killings.

Disputed or unverified: The exact dates of the four murders have never been established; investigators place them in the late 1970s or early 1980s, after the Honeychurch family disappeared in November 1978. The claim that Rasmussen was responsible for additional murders beyond the five named above is investigators’ belief, not a court finding. Denise Beaudin disappeared in 1981 and has never been found; her fate has not been established in court. Pepper Reed disappeared in the late 1970s and is suspected to have been a victim, but that has not been proven. The precise distance between the two drums varies between sources, so this article gives it only approximately.

Sources

Leave a Comment