In 399 BC, the democracy of Athens put one of its own citizens on trial for his life, convicted him by a narrow majority, and sentenced him to drink hemlock. The defendant was Socrates, a 70-year-old philosopher who had spent decades questioning his fellow Athenians in the marketplace. He wrote nothing himself. Everything we know about his trial comes from his students, above all Plato and Xenophon, who wrote their own accounts in the years that followed. The trial has been argued over ever since — not only because of what happened, but because of what it says about a democracy that could condemn a man for asking questions.
Athens after the war
Socrates was a conspicuous figure in Athens, a city still shaken by defeat in the Peloponnesian War and by the brief, brutal rule of the Thirty Tyrants in 404 BC. He was poor, plain in appearance, and famous for stopping people in public places and questioning them about justice, courage, piety and the good life, exposing the limits of what they claimed to know. He had served as a soldier at Potidaea, Delium and Amphipolis, and in 406 BC he had served on the council’s standing committee during the controversial trial of the generals after the battle of Arginusae. He was also associated, in the public mind, with men who had become enemies of the democracy: Alcibiades, the brilliant and untrustworthy general, and Critias, one of the leaders of the Thirty Tyrants, had both been among his companions. Socrates had not joined the Thirty, and Plato’s Apology records that he refused an order from them to arrest a man named Leon of Salamis for execution. But association, in a frightened city, was enough to make him suspect.
The charges
In 399 BC a citizen named Meletus brought the formal charge, with the support of Anytus, a democratic politician, and Lycon, an orator. The indictment, as preserved by Plato, accused Socrates of two offences: asebeia, impiety, and corrupting the youth of the city. More specifically, the accusers said that he did not acknowledge the gods the city acknowledged, that he introduced new deities, and that he corrupted the young.
Athenian procedure required no state prosecutor. Any citizen could bring a public indictment, heard by a jury of citizens chosen by lot — the dikasts. In Socrates’ case the jury numbered 501 men. There was no judge in the modern sense and no appeal. The accuser spoke, the defendant spoke, and the jury voted by ballot.
The charges were ambiguous. Impiety could cover a wide range of conduct, and “corrupting the youth” was never defined with precision. On one reading, Socrates was convicted for what he taught; on another, for who he knew and what his companions had done. Historians continue to argue about how much weight to give each.
The defence
Our principal source is Plato’s Apology — “defence speech” rather than an apology in the modern sense. Plato was present at the trial, but the Apology is his own reconstruction, written years after the event, not a stenographic transcript. Xenophon wrote a shorter Apology of his own. Neither can be treated as a verbatim record.
As Plato presents it, Socrates refused to beg for mercy or to bring his family before the jury, as defendants commonly did. He argued that he had lived as a kind of gadfly to the city, questioning its citizens for their own good, and that he could not abandon that life even to save himself. Cross-examining Meletus, he exposed contradictions in the prosecution’s case, and insisted that his divine voice had only ever warned him against actions, never commanded wrongdoing.
The jury voted to convict. Plato’s Apology suggests that the margin was narrow: if about thirty votes had gone the other way, Socrates would have been acquitted, and less than three-fifths of the jury voted against him. Later reconstructions commonly give the vote as roughly 280 to 221, but the precise figures vary between sources and should be treated as approximate. What is not in doubt is that the conviction was close, and that it was decided by ordinary citizens voting in secret.
The sentence
Athenian law then required a second vote, on the penalty. The prosecution proposed death. The defendant was invited to propose an alternative. Socrates, as Plato presents him, first proposed what he said he deserved: free meals at public expense in the Prytaneum, the honour given to Olympic victors and public benefactors. Only after pressure from his friends did he offer a fine, which they guaranteed. The jury, perhaps provoked by the first proposal, voted for death.
The sentence was death by drinking hemlock, the standard method of civic execution in Athens. Because a religious festival was under way, the execution was delayed for about a month, during which Socrates remained in prison, receiving friends. Plato’s Crito presents him refusing a plan to escape, on the ground that a citizen who had lived under the laws of Athens could not break them to save himself. Plato’s Phaedo describes his final day: calm, still questioning his friends, drinking the poison and lying down as the numbness rose until it reached his heart. Plato says he was himself ill and absent that day.
What the trial means
The trial has been read in many ways: as a warning about free speech in a democracy, as a story about a philosopher who refused every compromise that might have saved him, and as a product of a frightened city looking for someone to blame after war and oligarchy. None of these readings is the whole truth, and the sources do not allow us to settle Socrates’ guilt in a modern legal sense. There is no proof that he incited treason, and the charge of corrupting the youth rested largely on the claim that his questioning undermined respect for the city’s gods and traditions.
What is certain is the trial’s legacy. Plato’s dialogues made Socrates the founding figure of Western philosophy, and his death became the model of the philosopher who dies for the examined life.
What the record shows
Documented: Socrates was tried in Athens in 399 BC on charges of impiety (asebeia) and corrupting the youth, brought by Meletus with the support of Anytus and Lycon; the jury numbered 501 citizens chosen by lot; he was convicted by a narrow majority and, after a second vote on penalty, sentenced to death by hemlock; he refused to escape and drank the poison in prison. The principal sources are Plato’s Apology, Crito and Phaedo, and Xenophon’s Apology and Memorabilia. Socrates wrote nothing himself.
Disputed or unverified: The exact vote counts (commonly about 280 to 221) vary between reconstructions. Neither Plato’s nor Xenophon’s Apology is a verbatim transcript. The claim that Socrates’ associations motivated the prosecution is interpretation, not a fact in the indictment. Details of his final hours come from Plato’s Phaedo, whose author says he was absent through illness.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trial_of_Socrates
- https://reasonandmeaning.com/2014/10/10/the-trial-of-socrates/
- https://www.philosophyprofessor.com/philosophers/socrates/
- https://www.aureliushistory.com/history/why-was-socrates-executed/
- https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:David_-_The_Death_of_Socrates.jpg