The Yogurt Shop Murders: Four Girls, Two Wrongful Convictions, and a DNA Answer 34 Years Later

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

On the night of 6 December 1991, firefighters responding to a blaze at an I Can’t Believe It’s Yogurt! shop in north Austin, Texas, found four teenage girls dead inside. The crime became one of the most notorious in the city’s history — and one of the most troubling, because the men first convicted of it did not commit it. It took 34 years, new DNA testing, and a court finding of actual innocence before the record was set straight.

The Four Girls

The victims were Eliza Thomas, 17, and Jennifer Harbison, 17, who were working at the shop that evening; Jennifer’s younger sister Sarah Harbison, 15; and their friend Amy Ayers, 13, who had visited the shop that night. All four were teenagers. They were killed inside the shop, which was then set on fire. The fire destroyed much of the scene and complicated the investigation from the start.

Austin was shaken. The shop stood in a busy commercial area, and the idea that four girls could be killed there, on an ordinary December evening, was difficult for the city to absorb. The case drew intense press coverage, and the pressure on the Austin Police Department to find those responsible was enormous.

A Long Investigation Without Physical Evidence

For years, the investigation produced no arrest. Police have acknowledged that more than 50 people confessed to the murders over time, including a man on the day of his execution for another crime. A confession in 1992 by two Mexican nationals held by Mexican authorities was soon disputed and ultimately ruled false. None of these confessions led to a charge supported by physical evidence.

Crucially, investigators had collected DNA from an unknown male at the scene. That DNA did not match any suspect the police pursued at the time, and for many years it could not be identified. It would eventually prove decisive — but not before four young men had lost years of their lives.

The 1999 Arrests and the Convictions

In September 1999, nearly eight years after the murders, Austin police arrested four men who had been teenagers at the time of the crime: Robert Springsteen, Michael Scott, Maurice Pierce, and Forrest Welborn. Police said the four had taken part in the murders. Three of them gave confessions, which they later said had been coerced. There was no physical evidence linking any of them to the crime scene.

Welborn’s charges were dropped in 2000 after two separate grand juries declined to indict him. Pierce was held in Travis County jail until 2003, when his charges were also dropped. Springsteen and Scott were tried. In June 2001, Springsteen was convicted of capital murder and sentenced to death; in September 2002, Scott was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment. In 2005, Springsteen’s death sentence was commuted to life imprisonment by Governor Rick Perry after the United States Supreme Court ruled in Roper v. Simmons that defendants who were under 18 at the time of their crime could not be sentenced to death.

The convictions rested largely on the confessions. Seven jurors from the trials later said they would not have convicted Springsteen and Scott had the DNA evidence been available to them at the time.

The Convictions Fall Apart

The convictions did not survive appeal. In 2006, the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals overturned Springsteen’s conviction on the ground that he had received an unfair trial. In 2008, the court overturned both convictions, ruling that prosecutors had violated the Confrontation Clause of the United States Constitution by using portions of the co-defendants’ alleged confessions at trial when the men could not be cross-examined by defence lawyers.

Springsteen and Scott were released on bond in June 2009, and in October 2009 the charges against them were dismissed. But dismissal is not the same as exoneration, and the four men lived for years under the shadow of the accusations. Pierce died in 2010 after a confrontation with police following a traffic stop, never having been cleared in court.

One of the lead detectives in the case had previously been accused of coercing false confessions in another wrongful-conviction case — that of Christopher Ochoa and Richard Danziger, who were later exonerated after serving more than a decade in prison for a murder they did not commit.

The DNA Answer

In 2008, new DNA testing excluded all four of the original suspects. The unknown male DNA recovered at the scene remained unidentified for another 17 years.

On 26 September 2025, the Austin Police Department announced that the DNA had been matched to Robert Eugene Brashers, a serial killer and serial rapist who had been identified through investigative genetic genealogy in 2018. The match came from Y-STR DNA — DNA from the Y chromosome — found under Amy Ayers’ fingernails, indicating that she had likely fought back against her attacker. Brashers could not be prosecuted: he had died by suicide in 1999 during a police standoff in connection with a different crime.

In December 2025, Travis County District Attorney José Garza filed paperwork to formally exonerate the four men. On 19 February 2026, Judge Dayna Blazey formally exonerated Michael Scott, Robert Springsteen, Maurice Pierce, and Forrest Welborn. The four were declared factually innocent — in Texas law, a specific finding of actual innocence, not merely a dismissal of charges — and their charges were dismissed with prejudice. The district attorney’s office told the court that the state had, more than 25 years earlier, prosecuted “four innocent men” for one of Austin’s worst crimes. In May 2026, the city of Austin agreed to pay $35 million in compensation to the men — three surviving and one deceased — a settlement reported as still requiring approval by the Austin City Council.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: Four girls — Amy Ayers, 13, Eliza Thomas, 17, Jennifer Harbison, 17, and Sarah Harbison, 15 — were killed at the I Can’t Believe It’s Yogurt! shop in north Austin on 6 December 1991, and the shop was set on fire. Four men were arrested in 1999; Springsteen was convicted in 2001 and Scott in 2002, on the basis of confessions, with no physical evidence linking them to the scene. Both convictions were overturned on appeal, and the men were freed in 2009. DNA testing excluded all four. In September 2025, Austin police said the crime-scene DNA matched Robert Eugene Brashers, who died in 1999. On 19 February 2026, a Travis County judge formally declared all four men actually innocent.

Not documented: Whether Brashers acted alone, and the full sequence of events inside the shop that night. The DNA match identifies Brashers as the source of the DNA recovered at the scene; it does not, on its own, establish every detail of what happened. Because Brashers died in 1999, he can never be tried, and some questions about the night of 6 December 1991 may never be answered in court.

The Yogurt Shop Murders are now two tragedies, not one: the killing of four girls, and the wrongful prosecution of four young men who lost their youth to a case built on confessions that the evidence did not support.

Sources

Leave a Comment