On 22 April 2009, 17-year-old Brittanee Drexel of Chili, New York, near Rochester, drove nearly 800 miles to Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, with two friends for spring break. She did not tell her mother. Her mother, Dawn Drexel, had refused her permission to go, because there would be no adult supervision. Brittanee went anyway.
Three days later, on the night of 25 April, she left a friend’s hotel room and walked out of the lobby. She was caught on a surveillance camera at about 8:45 p.m., leaving the Blue Water Resort. Then she vanished. For thirteen years, no one knew what had happened to her. Then, in May 2022, a man who had been on investigators’ radar for more than a decade confessed — and led them to her grave.
The last night
Brittanee was 17, a high school student who dreamed of a career in fashion design. She had arrived in Myrtle Beach on the morning of 23 April with her friends, and spent the next two days on the beach and around the resort town. On the evening of 25 April, she visited a friend at the Blue Water Resort, then left to walk back to the hotel where she was staying. The surveillance camera caught her leaving. After that, nothing — except her phone, which investigators tracked pinging south from Myrtle Beach, towards a rural area near the Santee River, about fifty miles away.
The search that followed was extensive, but there was no body, no witness and no suspect the police could charge. Her family kept the case alive. Her mother, Dawn, became a public voice for missing teenagers, and the case was featured on national television. But for years, the investigation produced only theories — that Brittanee had run away, that she had been taken by someone she met on the trip, that she had been trafficked. None of them could be proven.
The man on the registry
One name had been on the investigators’ list since early in the case: Raymond Douglass Moody, a registered sex offender living in McClellanville, South Carolina, about ten miles from where Brittanee’s phone had last pinged. Moody had served 21 years in prison for the 1983 kidnapping and rape of a nine-year-old girl. In August 2011, more than two years after Brittanee vanished, a young woman called the Myrtle Beach police to say she suspected her father — Moody — of having something to do with the disappearance, based on statements made by Moody’s girlfriend, Angel Vause.
Moody was questioned, but there was no evidence to charge him. The case went cold again. For another eleven years, Brittanee’s family waited.
The breakthrough came in May 2022. A defence attorney contacted Horry County prosecutors, saying that a client had information about the case. The client was Moody. After failing a polygraph, Moody confessed: he said he and Vause had picked Brittanee up on the Myrtle Beach strip, taken her to a remote area south of Georgetown, and that he had assaulted and strangled her after she tried to escape. He said he had buried her in a wooded area, face down, four to six feet underground, beneath a tree.
On 11 May 2022, Moody led investigators into the woods off Old Town Avenue in Georgetown County, about 33 miles from where Brittanee had disappeared. After three days of digging, they found her remains — bones, a single contact lens and a nose ring. Dental records confirmed, 48 hours later, that they were Brittanee Drexel’s. She had been dead for thirteen years.
The plea
Moody was charged with murder, kidnapping and first-degree criminal sexual conduct. On 19 October 2022, he pleaded guilty to all charges. Circuit Judge R. Ferrell Cothran Jr. sentenced him to life in prison without the possibility of parole, plus two consecutive terms of 30 years for the kidnapping and sexual assault. Vause was never charged in connection with the homicide.
The confession that closed the case was also, in a sense, its most troubling part. Moody had been a suspect since 2011. He had lived within miles of where Brittanee’s phone had pinged. He had a history of exactly this kind of crime. And yet it took his own decision to come forward — thirteen years after the fact — for the case to be solved. The investigators who worked the case have said openly that without Moody’s confession, they might never have found her.
Brittanee’s mother, Dawn, spoke in court at Moody’s sentencing. She had waited thirteen years for an answer, and the answer she got was the worst one. But it was an answer — a place to bury her daughter, and a name for the man who killed her.
Thirteen years of waiting
For thirteen years, the investigation into Brittanee Drexel’s disappearance produced theories but no answers. Her phone records showed movement south from Myrtle Beach, towards the Santee River and McClellanville, a small town about sixty miles away. The FBI joined the investigation. Her mother, Dawn, became a public voice for missing teenagers, keeping her daughter’s name in the press and on television year after year.
The tip that pointed to Moody came in August 2011, more than two years after Brittanee vanished. A young woman called the Myrtle Beach police to say she suspected her father — Moody — of having something to do with the disappearance, based on things his girlfriend, Angel Vause, had said. Moody was living about ten miles from where Brittanee’s phone had last pinged. He was a registered sex offender with a history of exactly this kind of crime. He was questioned. And still, there was no evidence to charge him.
That is what makes the case so difficult to read. The man who killed Brittanee Drexel was known to investigators within two years of her disappearance. He was on a registry. He lived in the area. He had been questioned. And yet it took his own decision to come forward — thirteen years after the fact, through a lawyer, after failing a polygraph — for the case to be solved. The investigators who worked the case have said openly that without Moody’s confession, they might never have found her.
Moody’s history made the confession all the more damning. In 1983, he had kidnapped and raped a nine-year-old girl, and served 21 years in prison for it. He was released, registered as a sex offender, and living in McClellanville when Brittanee Drexel walked out of a Myrtle Beach hotel lobby in April 2009. The system that was supposed to keep track of him knew where he was. It did not know what he had done.
What the case shows
The Drexel case is, in many ways, a story about time. Thirteen years passed between the night Brittanee vanished and the day her remains were found. In that time, the science of investigation changed — phone records, DNA, genealogy — but none of it solved her case. What solved it was a man deciding, after thirteen years, to talk.
It is also a story about the limits of the sex offender registry. Moody was on it. He was living in the area. He had been questioned. And still, for more than a decade, the case stayed open, because being on a list is not the same as being watched, and suspicion is not evidence.
For Dawn Drexel, the case ended with a grave in Georgetown County and a sentence of life without parole. For the investigators, it ended with a lesson: that some cases are not solved by science or by searching, but by waiting for the person who knows the truth to decide, at last, to tell it.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Brittanee Drexel, 17, of Chili, New York, was last seen on 25 April 2009, at about 8:45 p.m., leaving the Blue Water Resort in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina. Her phone was tracked pinging south towards the Georgetown area. In May 2022, Raymond Douglass Moody, a registered sex offender, confessed to picking her up, assaulting and strangling her, and burying her in a wooded area off Old Town Avenue, Georgetown County. Her remains were found on 11 May 2022 and identified by dental records. On 19 October 2022, Moody pleaded guilty to murder, kidnapping and first-degree criminal sexual conduct, and was sentenced to life in prison without parole plus two consecutive 30-year terms. His girlfriend Angel Vause was never charged in connection with the homicide. Moody had served 21 years in prison for a 1983 kidnapping and rape.
Unverified or unproven: The details of what happened between Brittanee’s abduction and her death rest on Moody’s confession, which was not independently corroborated in every detail. Whether Vause was present at the killing, and what she knew — Moody’s account has varied, and she was not charged. Theories advanced during the thirteen-year investigation, including that Brittanee had been trafficked, were never substantiated.
Sources
- https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disappearance_of_Brittanee_Drexel
- https://www.oxygen.com/final-moments/crime-news/brittanee-drexel-found-killer-raymond-moody-friends?amp
- https://thecinemaholic.com/brittanee-drexel-murder-how-did-she-die-who-killed-her/
- https://kvnutalk.com/a-mothers-13-year-journey-for-justice-and-an-exclusive-look-at-the-fbi-investigation-that-solved-her-daughters-murder/