On the afternoon of 15 April 1920, a paymaster and a security guard were shot dead in South Braintree, Massachusetts, during the robbery of a shoe factory payroll. Two men with a car escaped with about $15,766. A year later, two Italian immigrant workers — Nicola Sacco, a shoemaker, and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, a fish peddler — were convicted of the murders. They were executed on 23 August 1927. The case became one of the most contested trials in American history, and the argument over their guilt has never ended.
The crime and the arrests
The victims were Frederick Parmenter, the paymaster of the Slater and Morrill Shoe Company, and Alessandro Berardelli, his guard. Both were shot on Pearl Street as they carried the payroll. Witnesses described two gunmen and a getaway car, but their descriptions were inconsistent, and no one could identify the killers with confidence.
Sacco and Vanzetti were arrested on 5 May 1920 — not, at first, for the Braintree robbery, but in connection with another crime, an attempted payroll robbery in Bridgewater on Christmas Eve 1919. Both men were known anarchists, followers of the Italian anarchist Luigi Galleani, at a time when the United States was in the grip of the first Red Scare. The Palmer Raids had rounded up thousands of foreign-born radicals that winter, and the trial that followed took place in that atmosphere.
The trial at Dedham
The trial opened in Dedham, Massachusetts, in May 1921, before Judge Webster Thayer. The prosecution’s case rested on eyewitness identifications, on a cap said to have been found at the scene and claimed to be Sacco’s, and on ballistics evidence linking a bullet from Berardelli’s body to Sacco’s pistol. The defence argued that the identifications were unreliable, that the cap evidence was weak, and that both men had alibis — Sacco said he had been in Boston applying for a passport, Vanzetti said he had been selling eels in Plymouth.
On 14 July 1921, the jury found both men guilty of first-degree murder. The verdict was greeted with protests around the world, and the case became a cause célèbre, drawing support from writers, artists and labour movements in Europe and the Americas.
Six years of appeals
For six years, the defence fought to overturn the verdict. The most famous development came in 1925, when Celestino Madeiros, a convicted murderer awaiting execution, confessed that he had taken part in the Braintree robbery with the Morelli gang, a professional criminal outfit — and that Sacco and Vanzetti had not been involved. Judge Thayer refused a new trial, and the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court upheld his rulings.
In April 1927, the court denied the final appeals. The governor of Massachusetts, Alvan T. Fuller, appointed a committee — including the president of Harvard, A. Lawrence Lowell — to review the case. The committee concluded that the trial had been fair. Sacco and Vanzetti were executed in the electric chair at Charlestown State Prison in the early hours of 23 August 1927. Vanzetti’s last words, as recorded, were a declaration of innocence and forgiveness; Sacco, according to witnesses, cried out in Italian for his family and for justice.
The doubt that remained
The case never closed in the public mind. In 1961, and again in 1983, ballistics tests on Sacco’s pistol produced results that different experts interpreted in opposite ways — some said the tests supported the prosecution, others said they were inconclusive. In 1977, on the fiftieth anniversary of the executions, Governor Michael Dukakis issued a proclamation stating that Sacco and Vanzetti had not received a fair trial, and that “any disgrace should be forever removed from their names.” The proclamation did not declare them innocent, and it did not overturn the verdicts.
Historians remain divided. Some argue that the evidence, particularly the ballistics, points to Sacco’s involvement in the robbery, even if Vanzetti’s role is less clear. Others argue that the trial was so tainted by prejudice against the men’s politics and nationality that no verdict from it can be trusted. What is not disputed is that the judge’s conduct — Thayer was reported to have called the defendants “anarchist bastards” outside the courtroom — and the atmosphere of the Red Scare made a fair hearing very difficult to achieve.
What the record shows
- On 15 April 1920, paymaster Frederick Parmenter and guard Alessandro Berardelli were shot dead during a payroll robbery in South Braintree, Massachusetts. About $15,766 was taken.
- Nicola Sacco, 29, a shoemaker, and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, 33, a fish peddler, both Italian immigrants and anarchists, were arrested on 5 May 1920 and tried at Dedham, Massachusetts, in 1921 before Judge Webster Thayer.
- On 14 July 1921, both were convicted of first-degree murder. The prosecution relied on eyewitness identification, a cap allegedly belonging to Sacco, and ballistics evidence linking a bullet to Sacco’s pistol.
- In 1925, convicted murderer Celestino Madeiros confessed to taking part in the robbery with the Morelli gang and said Sacco and Vanzetti were not involved. Judge Thayer refused a new trial.
- Governor Fuller’s review committee upheld the verdict. Sacco and Vanzetti were executed on 23 August 1927 at Charlestown State Prison.
- In 1977, Governor Michael Dukakis proclaimed that the two men had not received a fair trial. The verdicts were never overturned.
- Disputed/unverified: Whether Sacco and Vanzetti were guilty. Ballistics tests in 1961 and 1983 were interpreted differently by different experts. Madeiros’s confession was never verified. The extent to which prejudice against the men’s anarchist politics and Italian origin affected the verdict is a matter of historical argument, not settled fact.
- Unresolved: The identity of the Braintree robbers has never been established beyond the contested verdict.