The Trial of John Demjanjuk

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Few trials in modern history have swung so far, or ended so strangely, as the trials of John Demjanjuk. In 1988, a court in Jerusalem sentenced him to death as “Ivan the Terrible”, the most feared guard at the Treblinka death camp. Five years later, Israel’s Supreme Court set the verdict aside, accepting that the evidence pointed to a different man. Demjanjuk returned to Ohio a free man. Then, in 2011, a court in Munich convicted him again — this time as a guard at a different camp, Sobibor — and sentenced him to five years in prison. He died before his appeal could be heard, and under German law he died a man presumed innocent.

The man from Cleveland

John Demjanjuk was born Ivan Mykolaiovych Demianiuk on 3 April 1920, in the village of Dubovi Makharintsi in central Ukraine. He served in the Red Army during the Second World War and was taken prisoner by the Germans in 1942. What happened to him after that is the question that consumed three decades of litigation. Prosecutors said he was trained at the SS camp at Trawniki in occupied Poland and served as a guard at the Sobibor and Treblinka death camps. Demjanjuk said he had spent the war as a prisoner and a farm labourer, and had never been a guard anywhere.

After the war, he emigrated to the United States, settling in Cleveland, Ohio, where he worked in a Ford car factory. He became an American citizen in 1958. In 1977, the United States government began proceedings to strip him of that citizenship, on the ground that he had concealed his wartime service when he entered the country. His citizenship was revoked in 1981. The case against him rested on two things: an SS identity card, found in Soviet archives, that appeared to show his photograph and list his service at Sobibor, and the testimony of Treblinka survivors who identified him as “Ivan the Terrible”, a guard remembered for exceptional cruelty.

The trial in Jerusalem

In 1986, Demjanjuk was extradited to Israel to stand trial for crimes at Treblinka. The trial, which opened in Jerusalem in February 1987, was one of the most closely followed in Israeli history. Survivors took the stand and pointed at the elderly man in the dock, saying he was the guard they remembered. The prosecution argued that the SS identity card proved he had been trained at Trawniki and posted to Sobibor, and from there to Treblinka.

In April 1988, the court found him guilty of war crimes and crimes against humanity and sentenced him to death by hanging. Demjanjuk protested his innocence throughout, insisting he had been neither at Treblinka nor at Sobibor.

Then the case fell apart. While the appeal was pending, the Soviet Union collapsed, and files from its archives became available. They contained evidence that “Ivan the Terrible” was not Demjanjuk but another Ukrainian guard, Ivan Marchenko. In July 1993, Israel’s Supreme Court overturned the conviction and the death sentence, ruling that there was reasonable doubt about the Treblinka identification. The court added, however, that the evidence still showed Demjanjuk had served as a guard at Sobibor and Trawniki. He was freed and returned to the United States, where his citizenship was restored in 1998.

The trial in Munich

The story did not end there. In 2002, the United States revoked Demjanjuk’s citizenship a second time, on the ground that he had served as a guard at Sobibor. In May 2009, at the age of 89, he was deported to Germany to face trial in Munich as an accessory to murder at Sobibor.

The Munich trial, which ran from November 2009 to May 2011, broke new legal ground. There was no evidence that Demjanjuk had personally killed anyone, and no living witness placed him at Sobibor. The prosecution’s case rested on the SS identity card and on camp records, and on the argument that serving as a guard at a death camp was itself enough to make him an accessory to the murders committed there. Demjanjuk, who spent much of the trial lying on a stretcher in court and listening through an interpreter, said nothing in his own defence beyond denying the charge at the outset.

On 12 May 2011, the court convicted him of being an accessory to the murder of 28,060 Jews at Sobibor between March and September 1943, and sentenced him to five years in prison. Because of his age and health, he was released while his appeal was pending. He died on 17 March 2012 in a nursing home in Bad Feilnbach, Bavaria, aged 91, before the appeal could be heard. Under German law, because the conviction was not yet final, he died presumed innocent, and the conviction was annulled.

What the cases settled — and what they did not

The Demjanjuk trials matter for two reasons. The Jerusalem trial showed the limits of eyewitness identification after more than forty years: survivors were certain, and they were wrong about the identity, even though the man they remembered was real. The Munich trial changed the law: it was the first time a person had been convicted solely for serving as a camp guard, without proof of involvement in a specific killing. That precedent opened the way for the prosecution of other elderly camp guards in Germany in the years that followed.

For the victims of Sobibor, where some 170,000 Jews were murdered, the Munich verdict was the only judgment ever delivered against one of the camp’s guards. It came almost seventy years after the killings, and it did not survive its subject. Demjanjuk died a free man, in a nursing home, still insisting he had never been a guard.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: John Demjanjuk was born in Ukraine on 3 April 1920, served in the Red Army, was captured by the Germans in 1942, emigrated to the United States, and worked at a Ford plant in Cleveland. He was extradited to Israel in 1986, convicted in Jerusalem in April 1988 and sentenced to death; the Israeli Supreme Court overturned the conviction in July 1993. He was deported to Germany in May 2009, and on 12 May 2011 a Munich court convicted him as an accessory to the murder of 28,060 Jews at Sobibor and sentenced him to five years. He died on 17 March 2012 in Bad Feilnbach, aged 91, before his appeal was heard, and the conviction was annulled under German law.

Unverified or unproven: That Demjanjuk was “Ivan the Terrible” of Treblinka — the Israeli Supreme Court found reasonable doubt, and the evidence pointed to Ivan Marchenko. The authenticity of the SS identity card — Demjanjuk’s defence argued it was a Soviet forgery; the Munich court accepted it as genuine, but no original forensic consensus was ever reached. Whether Demjanjuk personally took part in any killing — no evidence of a specific act by him was ever presented; the Munich conviction rested on his role as a guard.

Sources

Leave a Comment