The Trial of Jodi Arias: A Verdict, a Retrial, and a Life Sentence

Reading Time: 6 minutes ·

On 9 June 2008, friends of Travis Alexander went to his house in Mesa, Arizona, because he had not shown up for a planned trip to Mexico and had not answered his phone for days. They found his body in the shower of his master bathroom. He had been shot in the head, stabbed 27 times, and his throat had been cut. He was 30 years old. The investigation that followed, and the trial that came five years later, became one of the most watched murder cases in American history — a five-month trial, broadcast live on television, that drew millions of viewers and turned its defendant, Jodi Arias, into a household name.

The case was, on its face, a domestic murder. But the trial became a spectacle, and the spectacle became part of the story: a case about a killing, a lie, and the way a courtroom can become a stage.

The killing

Travis Alexander was a salesman for a legal services company and a devout Mormon. He had met Jodi Arias in September 2006 at a business conference in Las Vegas. The two began a relationship that, by all accounts, was intense and troubled. They broke up in the summer of 2007, but continued to see each other, and Alexander was, by the time of his death, seeing other women. Arias, who had moved to California, told friends she was struggling to let the relationship go.

On 4 June 2008, Arias drove from California to Mesa. She later said she had gone to see Alexander, and that the two had spent the day together. What happened next is the subject of the case. According to the prosecution, Arias attacked Alexander in his shower, shooting him, stabbing him repeatedly, and cutting his throat, before cleaning up the scene and driving back to California. She was, the prosecution said, acting out of jealousy and rage after Alexander had ended the relationship and begun dating someone else.

Arias’s account changed several times. When she was first questioned by police, she said she had not been in Mesa at all. When she was shown evidence that she had been there — a camera found in Alexander’s washing machine, with deleted photographs of the two of them together on the day of the killing, and her own bloody palm print and DNA at the scene — she changed her story. She said that two intruders had broken in and killed Alexander while she watched, and that she had fled in fear. At trial, she changed her story again: she said she had killed Alexander in self-defence, after he had attacked her.

The evidence against her was extensive. The camera, which had been put through a washing machine cycle, still held images that had been deleted but were recoverable, including photographs of Alexander in the shower shortly before his death, and a blurred image of a person standing over him. Her DNA was found mixed with Alexander’s blood at the scene. A rental car she had used had been returned with the floor mats missing, and petrol cans were found in the boot. Phone records placed her in Mesa on the day of the killing, and gas station receipts traced her route.

The trial

The trial began on 2 January 2013 in Maricopa County Superior Court in Phoenix, before Judge Sherry Stephens. It lasted five months, and it was televised live, gavel to gavel, by the cable channel HLN, which built its daytime schedule around it. Millions of people watched. Arias became, for a time, one of the most famous criminal defendants in America, and the trial became a daily fixture of daytime television.

The prosecution, led by Juan Martinez, presented the case as a premeditated murder driven by jealousy. Martinez was aggressive and theatrical, and his cross-examination of Arias — which lasted for 18 days — became one of the most talked-about parts of the trial. He pressed her on the changing stories, on the evidence, and on her credibility, and the exchanges between them were often combative.

Arias testified for 18 days in her own defence, the longest testimony by a defendant in recent memory. She described the relationship in detail, including its sexual content, and she said that Alexander had been abusive towards her, both physically and emotionally. She said that on the day of the killing, Alexander had become angry, had attacked her, and that she had grabbed a gun from a shelf and shot him, then stabbed him in a panic. She said she did not remember cutting his throat.

The defence called a psychologist who testified that Arias suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder and had experienced domestic violence. The prosecution called its own expert, who testified that Arias showed signs of borderline personality disorder and that her account was not credible. The trial became, in large part, a contest over Arias’s credibility — and over whether the jury believed that a woman who had lied repeatedly to the police could be believed when she said she had acted in self-defence.

The verdict — and the sentence that took two more years

On 8 May 2013, after 15 hours of deliberation, the jury found Arias guilty of first-degree murder. The verdict meant that the jury had rejected both the claim that she had not been present and the claim that she had acted in self-defence. It also meant that the case moved to the penalty phase, in which the same jury would decide whether she should be sentenced to death.

The penalty phase ended in a hung jury: the jurors could not agree unanimously on a death sentence, and under Arizona law a single juror’s refusal to vote for death is enough to prevent it. A second penalty phase was held, with a new jury, in late 2014 and early 2015. That jury also deadlocked. Under Arizona law, after two hung juries on the penalty, the judge was required to impose a sentence of life in prison, with or without the possibility of parole. On 13 April 2015, Judge Stephens sentenced Jodi Arias to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Arias is held at the Arizona State Prison Complex at Perryville. She has appealed her conviction, arguing that the publicity surrounding the trial and the conduct of the prosecutor made a fair trial impossible. Her appeals have been unsuccessful.

What the trial meant

The trial of Jodi Arias is remembered, above all, for the way it was watched. It was one of the first murder trials to be consumed as live, daily television by a mass audience, and it set a pattern that later trials — including those of Casey Anthony and, much later, of Johnny Depp and Amber Heard — would follow. The coverage raised questions that have not gone away: whether a defendant can receive a fair trial when the proceedings are broadcast live and dissected on social media in real time, and whether the courtroom can remain a place of law when it becomes a form of entertainment.

The case also became a reference point in the debate about domestic violence and self-defence. Arias’s claim that Alexander had abused her was central to her defence, and the prosecution’s response — that her account was fabricated and that the killing was premeditated — was central to theirs. The jury’s verdict rejected her claim, but the question of how courts should weigh a defendant’s account of abuse against physical evidence remains a live one.

For the Alexander family, the trial was an ordeal that lasted years. They attended the proceedings, gave victim impact statements, and, after the sentence, said they were relieved that the case was over. Travis Alexander’s brother said at the sentencing that the family had waited seven years for justice, and that the sentence, while not the death penalty they had sought, was at least final.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Travis Alexander was found dead in his home in Mesa, Arizona, on 9 June 2008. He had been shot in the head, stabbed 27 times, and his throat had been cut. Jodi Arias was arrested in July 2008. At her trial, which ran from January to May 2013, she testified that she had killed Alexander in self-defence; the prosecution argued the killing was premeditated. On 8 May 2013 the jury convicted her of first-degree murder. Two penalty-phase juries deadlocked on a death sentence, and on 13 April 2015 she was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

Unverified or unproven: That Alexander was physically abusive towards Arias — this was her testimony, supported by a defence expert, and disputed by the prosecution’s expert and by the jury’s verdict. That Arias planned the killing in advance — the prosecution argued premeditation based on the evidence of preparation, including the petrol cans and the missing floor mats, but Arias maintained that the killing was the result of a sudden confrontation. Any claim about what was said between Arias and Alexander in the minutes before the killing rests on Arias’s account alone, since Alexander did not survive.

Sources

Leave a Comment