The sergeant with four wives
Drew Peterson was a police sergeant in Bolingbrook, a suburb of Chicago, Illinois. He had been married four times. His third wife, Kathleen Savio, was an accountant. They divorced in October 2003, after a bitter split, and Savio kept the house. On 1 March 2004, she was found dead in her bathtub — a dry bathtub, with bruises on her body and a large gash in her scalp. The coroner ruled the death an accidental drowning. Peterson collected on her life insurance.
Three years later, on 28 October 2007, Peterson’s fourth wife, Stacy Ann Peterson, disappeared. She was 23, the mother of two of his children, and she had told friends and family that she was afraid of him. Peterson said she had left him for another man. The Illinois State Police did not believe him — and, looking again at Savio’s death, they did not believe the accident ruling either. In November 2007, Savio’s body was exhumed. A second autopsy found evidence of a struggle, and her cause of death was reclassified as homicide. In February 2008, the findings were formalised: Savio had been murdered, her death staged to look like an accident.
A new law
Peterson was arrested for Savio’s murder on 7 May 2009. But the prosecution had a problem: the most important witness against him was dead. Savio herself had told friends and family, before her death, that Peterson had threatened to kill her. Stacy Peterson — who might have testified about what she knew — had vanished, and Peterson has never been charged in connection with her disappearance. Without the two women, the case rested on what they had said to others — hearsay, which is normally inadmissible in court.
The Illinois legislature solved the problem by changing the law. In 2008, it passed a statute — 725 ILCS 5/115-10.6, soon known as “Drew’s Law” — allowing prosecutors to present a dead person’s statements at trial, if the court found that the defendant had murdered the witness, that the statements were reliable, and that admitting them served the interests of justice. It was, in effect, a law written for a single case. The defence challenged it, and in April 2012 an appellate court ruled that selected statements could be admitted.
The trial
The trial began on 31 July 2012 in Joliet, Illinois, before Judge Edward Burmila. Prosecutors argued that Savio’s injuries — the bruises, the head wound — showed a struggle, and that the dry bathtub showed the scene had been staged. They presented the statements Savio had made to her sister, her friends and her pastor, in which she said Peterson had threatened to kill her and make it look like an accident. They also presented evidence that Peterson had offered a fellow officer $25,000 to hire someone to kill Savio.
Peterson did not testify. His lawyers argued that the hearsay evidence was unreliable, that the second autopsy was inconclusive, and that the prosecution had built a case out of rumour. On 6 September 2012, the jury found him guilty of the premeditated murder of Kathleen Savio. Jurors later said the hearsay evidence admitted under Drew’s Law had been the most compelling part of the case. On 21 February 2013, Judge Burmila denied a motion for a new trial and sentenced Peterson to 38 years in prison.
A second conviction
Peterson’s legal troubles did not end with the murder conviction. In 2014, while in prison, he hatched a plot to have Will County State’s Attorney James Glasgow — the prosecutor who had pursued the Savio case — killed. He was charged on 9 February 2015 with solicitation of murder and solicitation of murder for hire. On 31 May 2016, a jury convicted him, and on 29 July 2016 he was sentenced to an additional 40 years in prison. His total sentence is 78 years, with the earliest possible release date of 7 May 2081.
In 2017, Peterson was transferred from Illinois state custody to the United States Penitentiary in Terre Haute, Indiana, and in 2019 he was moved again to a state prison outside Illinois. His location is not publicly disclosed, for security reasons. In 2021, he filed a handwritten petition for post-conviction relief, which was denied. In 2024, he filed a motion for a new trial, arguing that he had received ineffective legal representation. It has not succeeded. He remains a suspect — but has never been charged — in the disappearance of Stacy Peterson, whose body has never been found.
What the case changed
The Peterson case matters for two reasons. The first is the law. “Drew’s Law” — the statute that allowed a dead woman’s words to be heard in the courtroom — has been used in other Illinois cases since, and it remains controversial. Its supporters say it prevents a murderer from silencing his victim twice: once by killing her, and again by keeping her words out of court. Its critics say it weakens the right to confront one’s accusers, and that it was written for a single defendant.
The second is the pattern. Peterson was a police officer — a man whose job was to investigate crimes, and who knew exactly how a murder could be staged to look like an accident. Savio’s death was ruled an accident for more than three years, and it took a second wife’s disappearance to make anyone look again. The case is now cited as a warning about how domestic violence can be missed, even by the institutions that are supposed to catch it, when the abuser wears a badge.
The disappearance of Stacy Peterson
Stacy Peterson was 23 when she vanished. She had married Peterson in 2003, when she was 19, and they had two young children. In the months before her disappearance, she had told her sister, her pastor and friends that she was afraid of her husband, and that she believed he had killed Savio. She had also, according to her family, been planning to leave him. On 28 October 2007, she was last seen at home in Bolingbrook. Peterson reported her missing the next day, and told police she had left him for another man and taken $25,000 with her. Her family did not believe him. Neither did the police.
The search for Stacy Peterson was extensive — police, volunteers and cadaver dogs combed the area around Bolingbrook, and the case was covered nationally. But no trace of her was ever found: no body, no car, no belongings, no sign of where she had gone. Peterson was named a person of interest, and later a suspect, but he was never charged. The legal problem was the same one the Savio case had faced: without a body, and without a witness, there was no case to bring. Her disappearance remains one of the most discussed unsolved cases in Illinois, and it is the reason many people first heard Drew Peterson’s name.
Peterson’s earlier marriages added to the picture the prosecution painted. His first wife, Carol Brown, divorced him in 1980 after, she said, he had threatened her. His second wife, Victoria Connolly, divorced him in 1992; she later said he had abused her during the marriage. Neither woman was a witness in the Savio trial, but their accounts were part of the public record that surrounded it, and they shaped how the case was understood: not as a single crime, but as the end of a pattern.
Peterson’s appeals have all failed. The Illinois Supreme Court upheld his murder conviction in 2017, rejecting his argument that the hearsay evidence admitted under Drew’s Law had violated his rights. In 2021, he filed a handwritten petition for post-conviction relief, arguing that his trial lawyers had been ineffective; it was denied. In 2024, he filed a motion for a new trial on similar grounds. It, too, has not succeeded. He remains in custody, and his earliest possible release date — 7 May 2081 — means he will almost certainly die in prison.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Kathleen Savio was found dead in a dry bathtub on 1 March 2004; her death was initially ruled an accidental drowning, then reclassified as homicide after a second autopsy in 2007–2008. Drew Peterson was arrested for her murder on 7 May 2009. Illinois passed a hearsay statute in 2008, known as “Drew’s Law”, allowing a murder victim’s statements to be admitted at trial. On 6 September 2012, a jury convicted Peterson of premeditated murder, and on 21 February 2013 he was sentenced to 38 years in prison. On 31 May 2016, he was convicted of solicitation of murder for hire against prosecutor James Glasgow and sentenced to an additional 40 years, for a total of 78 years. His earliest possible release date is 7 May 2081.
Unverified or unproven: What happened to Stacy Peterson — she disappeared on 28 October 2007, her body has never been found, and Peterson has never been charged in connection with her disappearance, though police have named him a suspect. Whether Peterson killed Savio himself or arranged for someone else to do it has never been established in court. Claims about Peterson’s conduct in his earlier marriages rest on testimony and reporting, not on separate convictions.
Sources
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drew_Peterson
https://www.oxygen.com/crime-news/where-is-drew-peterson-now-19-years-after-his-4th-wife-vanished
https://www.crimeandinvestigation.co.uk/articles/drew-peterson-guilty-ex-wifes-murder
Drew Peterson