The Trial of Charles I

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

In January 1649, a reigning king was put on trial for his life by his own subjects. It had never happened before in England, and it has never happened since. Charles I, King of England, Scotland and Ireland, was charged with treason against his own people — with waging war on Parliament and on the kingdom he ruled. He refused to plead, denied that any court on earth had the right to try a king, and was sentenced to death. Nine days after the trial began, he was beheaded outside the Banqueting House in Whitehall, before a silent crowd.

A king at war with his kingdom

Charles was born in Dunfermline, Scotland, on 19 November 1600, and became king in 1625. He believed, as most kings of his age did, that his authority came from God and could not be questioned by his subjects. For eleven years, from 1629 to 1640, he ruled without calling a Parliament at all, raising money through measures his critics called illegal. His religious policies, shaped by Archbishop William Laud, drove many of his subjects — above all the Puritans — to fury.

When Parliament was finally recalled, the quarrel turned into a war. The English Civil War began in 1642, pitting the King’s Cavaliers against Parliament’s Roundheads. The war ended in 1646 with the King’s defeat, but Charles refused to accept the terms offered to him. He escaped from custody, allied himself with the Scots, and started a second civil war in 1648. That, for the army that had defeated him, was the last straw. The army’s leaders, above all Oliver Cromwell, concluded that there could be no peace while Charles lived, because he would never keep an agreement he had signed.

In December 1648, soldiers under Colonel Thomas Pride purged Parliament of the members willing to negotiate with the King. The remaining members — the Rump Parliament — voted to put him on trial.

The court

The House of Lords refused to take part, so the Commons acted alone. On 6 January 1649, it passed an ordinance creating a High Court of Justice to try the King. Of the 135 commissioners named to the court, about 68 took their seats. John Bradshaw, a lawyer from Cheshire, presided. The prosecution was led by John Cook, the solicitor-general.

The trial opened on 20 January 1649 in Westminster Hall, the great medieval hall of Parliament. Charles was brought in under guard, and the charge was read: that he had been “a tyrant, traitor, murderer and public enemy to the good people of this nation”, and that he had waged war against Parliament and the kingdom. When Bradshaw called on him to plead, the King refused. He would not recognise the court at all. “I would know by what power I am called hither,” he said. A king, he argued, could not be tried by any court on earth, because his authority came from God. Bradshaw replied that the court sat in the name of the people of England, and that even a king was answerable to the law.

The trial ran for four days of hearings — 20, 22, 23 and 26 January — with the King refusing to answer at every session. Witnesses were called to prove that he had ordered the wars, but Charles would not cross-examine them or present a defence. On 27 January, the court found him guilty and sentenced him to death. Fifty-nine of the commissioners signed the death warrant.

The execution

Charles was executed on 30 January 1649, on a scaffold built outside the Banqueting House in Whitehall, in front of a large crowd. He had dressed carefully for the occasion and wore two shirts, so that the cold would not make him shiver and the crowd would not mistake it for fear. On the scaffold he said a few words, forgave his executioner, and laid his head on the block. The axe fell in a single blow. The executioner, whose face was masked, held up the severed head, and a groan went through the crowd.

He was buried in silence on 9 February 1649 in St George’s Chapel at Windsor Castle. His son, the future Charles II, was in exile in the Netherlands.

Why the trial still matters

The trial of Charles I was a revolution in law as much as in politics. For the first time, a king had been tried and executed not by a rival or an assassin, but by a court claiming to act for the people. The idea behind it — that even a sovereign is subject to the law, and that power derives from the people rather than from God — would echo through the centuries that followed, in the American and French revolutions and in the trials of heads of state in our own time.

The men who signed the death warrant did not escape the consequences. When the monarchy was restored in 1660, the surviving regicides were themselves put on trial. Thirteen were executed, and others were imprisoned for life. The court that had tried the King was declared illegal, and its records were burned. But the precedent it set could not be burned with them.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Charles I became king in 1625, ruled without Parliament from 1629 to 1640, and fought two civil wars against Parliament in the 1640s. After Pride’s Purge in December 1648, the Rump Parliament created a High Court of Justice, which tried him in Westminster Hall from 20 to 27 January 1649. He refused to plead and denied the court’s jurisdiction. He was found guilty of high treason and sentenced to death; 59 commissioners signed the death warrant. He was executed on 30 January 1649 outside the Banqueting House in Whitehall and buried at Windsor on 9 February 1649.

Unverified or unproven: The identity of the executioner — his face was masked, and although Richard Brandon, the common hangman, is usually named, it has never been proven. Whether Charles wore two shirts for the reason he gave — the story comes from the King’s own words on the scaffold, as reported by those present, and is widely accepted but rests on a single account. The exact number of commissioners who attended — about 68 of the 135 named, with attendance varying by day.

Sources

Leave a Comment