The Somerton Man: The Tamám Shud Case, Adelaide, 1948

Reading Time: 5 minutes ·

On the morning of 1 December 1948, a couple walking on Somerton Park beach, a suburb of Adelaide in South Australia, found a man lying against the seawall. He was well dressed — a double-breasted jacket, knitted pullover, shirt and tie, polished shoes — and appeared to be asleep. He was dead.

Police were called at about 6:30 a.m. The man carried no wallet, no hat and no identification. The labels had been cut from his clothing. A search of his pockets found only ordinary small items: an unused second-class rail ticket from Adelaide to Henley Beach, a bus ticket, cigarettes and matches, chewing gum and a comb. Nothing in his pockets said who he was, where he had come from, or why he was on that beach.

He was, in the words of the pathologist who examined him, in top physical condition: about 180 centimetres tall, aged about 40 to 45, with grey eyes and fair-to-ginger hair greying at the temples. His teeth matched no known dental records. The coronial inquest that followed ran, on and off, for years, and when it concluded in March 1958 it could determine neither his identity nor his cause of death.

A death the doctors could not explain

The autopsy, conducted by pathologist John Burton Cleland and Dr. Dwyer, estimated the time of death at around 2 a.m. on 1 December. The man’s last meal, a pasty, had been eaten three to four hours before he died. His heart was normal in size and appearance, and there was no sign of a natural cause of death that the doctors could settle on.

Tests found no foreign substance in the body, yet the pathologists were convinced the death had not been natural. Dr. Dwyer concluded that a poison — he suggested a barbiturate or a soluble hypnotic — was the likely cause, even though laboratory tests of the time could not detect one. That gap, between a firm medical opinion and an absence of proof, has never been closed. Modern reporting sometimes states flatly that the man was poisoned. The record is more careful: poisoning was suspected, not established.

The suitcase with no name

On 14 January 1949, staff at Adelaide railway station found a brown suitcase in the cloakroom. It had been checked in after 11 a.m. on 30 November 1948, the day before the body was found. Its label had been removed, like the labels on the dead man’s clothes.

Inside were clothes and personal items consistent with those of the dead man. Some items bore the name “Keane” or “T. Keane” — the same name that appeared on a tie, a laundry bag and a singlet among the dead man’s belongings. Police were never able to trace anyone of that name in connection with the case, and the spelling itself varies between accounts. The suitcase confirmed that the man had arrived in Adelaide recently and had travelled light. It did not say who he was.

Tamám Shud

The detail that made the case famous was found only when the dead man’s clothing was re-examined. Sewn into the waistband of his trousers was a small fob pocket. Inside, rolled tight, was a tiny scrap of paper printed with two words: “Tamám Shud.”

The words are Persian, meaning “it is ended” or “it is finished.” They are the closing words of Edward FitzGerald’s translation of the Rubáiyát of Omar Khayyám, a collection of verse. A police reporter recognised the phrase, and the newspapers — misprinting it as “Taman Shud” — made it the name of the case. The misspelling has followed the case ever since.

Police appealed for anyone who had a copy of the Rubáiyát with its final page torn out. In July 1949, a man came forward with a copy he said he had found in the back seat of a car parked near Glenelg. The final page had been torn out, and the torn edge matched the scrap found on the body. That physical match tied the little roll of paper to that particular book. It did not explain it.

The telephone number and the code

Inside the back cover of the recovered book, faint pencil impressions could be made out under ultraviolet light: a local telephone number and a short sequence of capital letters arranged in lines, with one line crossed out and rewritten. The letters became known as the Somerton Man code. No one has ever produced an accepted reading of them, and naval intelligence at the time could not say with confidence whether they were a cipher at all. Some letters cannot even be transcribed with certainty.

The telephone number led to a woman living in Moseley Street, a short distance from the beach. She was an ex-nurse, later publicly identified as Jessica “Jo” Thomson, known to police at the time by the pet name “Jestyn.” She told police she did not know the dead man and did not know why her number was in the book. She said she had once given a copy of the Rubáiyát to a wartime acquaintance, Alf Boxall. For a moment that looked like a breakthrough — until police found Boxall alive in Sydney, still in possession of his own copy, intact, with her inscription inside it. Whatever book the scrap came from, it was not his.

When Thomson was shown a plaster cast of the dead man’s face, witnesses said she appeared shaken. She never publicly identified him, and she died in 2007. Her daughter later told reporters that her mother had said she knew who the man was but would not say — a second-hand, unverified claim, reported here as a claim, not as evidence.

A name, claimed but not confirmed

In May 2021, South Australian authorities exhumed the body to attempt DNA recovery. In July 2022, University of Adelaide professor Derek Abbott, working with genealogist Colleen M. Fitzpatrick, announced that DNA from hair preserved in a plaster cast of the man’s face identified him as Carl “Charles” Webb, an electrical engineer and instrument maker born in Footscray, Victoria, on 16 November 1905.

That announcement was widely reported as solving the case. It did not, in the formal sense. South Australia Police and Forensic Science South Australia have not verified the result, and as of the latest reporting the coronial investigation remained open and described by police as complex and ongoing. The identification is therefore best described as disputed — claimed but not officially confirmed. If it is eventually confirmed, it will answer only the smallest of the case’s questions: a name. It will not answer how the man died, why his identity had been so thoroughly removed, what the scrap of poetry meant, or what the code says. Theories about espionage, prompted by the Cold War atmosphere of 1948, have circulated for decades; none has been supported by evidence from the record.

What the record shows

What is documented is this: a man, apparently in good health, died on Somerton Beach in the early hours of 1 December 1948; no identification was found on him and the labels had been removed from his clothes; a suitcase checked in the day before contained belongings marked with a name that led nowhere; a scrap of paper bearing the words “Tamám Shud” was found in a hidden pocket of his trousers and matched a torn page in a copy of the Rubáiyát handed to police months later; that book also carried a telephone number and a short sequence of letters that has never been read; and a coronial inquest concluded in 1958 without determining who he was or how he died. He was buried unnamed in West Terrace Cemetery in Adelaide.

A DNA-based identification as Carl Webb was announced in 2022 but has not been officially confirmed. The cause of death remains undetermined, the code remains unread, and the reason a man would travel to Adelaide and die with his name cut out of his clothes remains unknown. The Somerton Man endures not because the evidence is thin — the file is thick — but because the evidence answers almost none of the questions it raises.

Sources

Leave a Comment