On the morning of Monday, 8 June 1931, a beachcomber found the body of a young woman on the sand at Long Beach, on the south shore of Long Island, New York. She was Starr Faithfull, 25 years old, a New York socialite whose short life had already been a tabloid story. The autopsy said she had drowned. It also said she had been bruised before death, apparently by another person. A grand jury returned an open verdict. A final inquest, fifteen minutes long, reached no conclusion at all.
Her death remains unsolved — not for lack of suspects, but because the evidence pointed in too many directions at once.
The family
Starr Faithfull was born Marian Starr Wyman on 27 January 1906 in Evanston, Illinois, the first daughter of Frank Wyman II, an investment banker, and Helen MacGregor Pierce. The family moved to Montclair, New Jersey, and in 1925 Helen married Stanley Faithfull, a self-employed inventor whose business ventures repeatedly failed. The family lived on little money, in an apartment at 12 St. Luke’s Place in New York City.
The family’s most important connection was Helen’s cousin Martha, who had married Andrew James Peters — a career politician who had served in Congress, as an assistant secretary of the Treasury, and as mayor of Boston from 1918 to 1922. The Peters family helped support the Wymans with gifts of money and paid for the daughters’ private schooling. Starr spent summers with the Peters family, and Peters often took the young girl on trips alone with him.
In June 1926, Faithfull told her mother that Peters had been sexually abusing her since she was eleven years old. Stanley Faithfull engaged a lawyer, and in 1927 negotiated a written settlement with Peters: $20,000, supposedly to cover Starr’s medical care and rehabilitation, in return for keeping the abuse secret. Although the agreement described this as a one-time payment, the Faithfulls received several further large payments from Peters, estimated at around $80,000 in total — apparently the family’s only source of income. The evidence suggests the family may have been extorting Peters, and that unrelated gangsters had also learned of the abuse and were using it to extort money from him.
The last days
By 1931, Faithfull’s life was troubled. She had received psychiatric treatment, and she drank and used drugs; in March 1931 she was briefly committed to Bellevue Hospital after being found drunk, naked, and beaten in a New York hotel room. She attended farewell parties on ocean liners in New York harbour, and on 29 May 1931 she was forcibly removed from the Cunard liner RMS Franconia, where she had tried to remain to be near the ship’s doctor, Dr. George Jameson-Carr, with whom she was infatuated.
Her family last saw her on the morning of Friday, 5 June 1931, leaving the house in the same dress she was wearing when found. She spent that day visiting ships’ officers on ocean liners docked in Manhattan, and the evening with one of them, before getting into a taxi late that night. After that, she vanished.
The body
At about 6:30 a.m. on Monday, 8 June, a beachcomber found her body on the beach at Long Beach, near Minnesota Avenue. She was wearing only her dress, silk stockings, and a suspender girdle; the rest of her clothing was missing. Her dress was undamaged, but her body showed numerous bruises that the medical examiner said had been inflicted before death, apparently by another person.
The autopsy determined that she had died of drowning and that her body had been in the water for at least forty-eight hours, suggesting she died on the night of Friday, 5 June, or the early morning of Saturday, 6 June. Her lungs contained a large quantity of sand, later read as indicating that she had drowned in shallow water near the shore, and her liver contained a high level of a barbiturate sedative — a dose large enough to cause stupor, but not large enough to kill her.
The investigation
The investigation was led by Nassau County Police Inspector Harold King and District Attorney Elvin Edwards. Edwards was convinced it was murder; King thought it was probably suicide. After Stanley Faithfull told investigators he believed Peters had ordered her murder to prevent her from revealing the abuse, Edwards travelled to Boston and announced he expected to indict two unnamed men.
When the body was due to be cremated on 11 June, Edwards dramatically ordered the cremation stopped so he could convene a grand jury. A police search of the family’s apartment found Faithfull’s diary — her “Memory Book” — which recorded affairs with nineteen men, identified by initials; the initials “AJP” were thought to refer to Peters. When newspapers began to connect Peters to the case, he denied through his lawyer that he had ever had “improper relations” with Faithfull. He was questioned in the autumn of 1931, was never prosecuted, and died in 1938.
By October 1931 the case was reported to be “virtually closed.” A final inquest in December lasted fifteen minutes and reached no conclusion; Coroner Edward Neu was quoted as saying, “Whatever I decide, it will only be a matter of opinion.”
The theories
Three broad explanations have been offered, and none has ever been proven.
The first is suicide or accident: that Faithfull, distressed and under the influence of a sedative, jumped or fell from a ship, or walked into the water — a reading supported by farewell notes that were reportedly found, though her stepfather insisted they had been forged.
The second, from the crime historian Jonathan Goodman, who reviewed the surviving police file for his 1990 book The Passing of Starr Faithfull, is that Long Island mobster Vannie Higgins had her taken to Island Park and beaten to extract information he could use against Peters, and that her body was dumped in the ocean while she was still alive.
The third, advanced by the writer Jay Robert Nash and the New Yorker reporter Morris Markey, is that Faithfull went to the beach with a man she had met, that an encounter went wrong, and that he beat her and drowned her in the shallows.
What is certain is that the investigation was compromised by the Faithfulls’ own conduct: they had lived on Peters’s money for years, asked him for more while Starr was missing, and were suspected of not cooperating fully with police. The case was closed with no conclusion — and it has stayed that way.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Starr Faithfull (born Marian Starr Wyman, 27 January 1906, Evanston, Illinois) was found dead on the beach at Long Beach, New York, on the morning of 8 June 1931. The autopsy found she had drowned, with bruises inflicted before death, apparently by another person, and a sedative in her system at a level that would cause stupor but not death. In June 1926 she told her mother that Andrew James Peters, former mayor of Boston (1918–1922), had sexually abused her since she was eleven; in 1927 Peters paid $20,000 under a written settlement to keep it secret, with total payments estimated at around $80,000. Police found her diary, which recorded affairs with nineteen men identified by initials, including “AJP.” Peters denied any improper relations, was questioned in the autumn of 1931, and was never prosecuted. A grand jury returned an open verdict, and a final inquest in December 1931 reached no conclusion. Peters died in 1938.
Unverified or unproven: That Peters ordered Faithfull’s murder — this was her stepfather’s accusation, and Peters was never charged. That she was killed by Vannie Higgins or his associates — Jonathan Goodman’s theory, based on his reading of the police file, not a proven fact. That she was killed on the beach by an unknown man — the theory of Nash and Markey, also unproven. That she died by suicide or accident — supported by her state of mind and by farewell notes whose authenticity was disputed by her family. Whether the bruises on her body were inflicted by an attacker or in some other way was never established. The manner of her death remains officially undetermined.