For six seasons, Bob Crane was Colonel Robert Hogan, the cheerful, unflappable hero of the CBS sitcom Hogan’s Heroes — a show that finished in the top ten in its first year and earned Crane two Emmy nominations. Off screen, he had been the king of Los Angeles morning radio. By the summer of 1978, the fame had faded, and Crane was touring in dinner theatre. On 29 June 1978, his co-star walked into his apartment in Scottsdale, Arizona, and found him bludgeoned to death.
The case pointed, from the start, at one man: John Henry Carpenter, Crane’s closest friend. Sixteen years later, Carpenter stood trial for the murder. He was acquitted. The murder of Bob Crane remains officially unsolved.
The star
Robert Edward Crane was born in Waterbury, Connecticut, on 13 July 1928, and grew up in Stamford. A drummer from the age of eleven, he began in radio in 1950 in Hornell, New York, and by 1956 was hosting the number-one morning show on KNX in Los Angeles. Acting followed: guest spots on The Twilight Zone and The Dick Van Dyke Show, a regular role on The Donna Reed Show, and then, in 1965, the starring role in Hogan’s Heroes, a sitcom set in a Second World War prisoner-of-war camp. The series ran for six seasons.
After the show ended in 1971, the work thinned out. Crane appeared in two Disney films and returned to dinner theatre, and in 1975 a short-lived NBC series, The Bob Crane Show, was cancelled after thirteen weeks. In June 1978 he was in Scottsdale, performing in a production of Beginner’s Luck at the Windmill Dinner Theatre, and living in the Winfield Place Apartments.
The murder
On the afternoon of 29 June 1978, Crane failed to appear for a lunch meeting, and his co-star Victoria Ann Berry went to his apartment. She found his body in the bedroom. He had been bludgeoned to death with a weapon that was never identified, though investigators believed it to be a camera tripod. An electrical cord had been tied around his neck, but he showed no signs of strangulation.
Scottsdale’s police department had no homicide division in 1978, and the investigation struggled from the start. The crime scene yielded few clues: no evidence of forced entry, and nothing of value missing. Detectives turned to Crane’s extensive collection of home videos, which led them to Carpenter — a regional sales manager for Sony Electronics who had helped Crane with his video equipment, and who had become his constant companion on tour. Carpenter had flown to Phoenix on 25 June to spend a few days with Crane.
Carpenter’s rental car was impounded and searched. Several blood smears were found that matched Crane’s blood type — type B, found in only about nine percent of the population. DNA testing was not yet available, and the Maricopa County district attorney declined to file charges.
The trial, sixteen years later
The case sat cold for twelve years. In 1990, a newly elected county attorney reopened it, and investigators re-examined the evidence with modern techniques. DNA testing on the blood in Carpenter’s rental car came back inconclusive, but an evidence photograph of the car’s interior appeared to show a piece of brain tissue. The actual tissue samples recovered from the car had been lost, but an Arizona judge ruled the photograph admissible as evidence.
Carpenter was arrested on 1 June 1992 and charged with first-degree murder. At the trial, which began in the autumn of 1994, his son Robert David testified that Crane had repeatedly said he wanted to end the friendship, calling Carpenter a “hanger-on” and “a nuisance.” The defence attacked the case as circumstantial: the murder weapon had never been found, the tripod theory was speculation, the photograph did not conclusively show brain tissue, and evidence had been mishandled — including the loss of the tissue sample itself. Witnesses said the two men had dined together amicably the evening before the murder.
In November 1994, the jury acquitted Carpenter. He continued to maintain his innocence until his death in 1998. No other suspect has ever been charged.
The questions that remain
The acquittal did not settle the case. Maricopa County District Attorney Rick Romley later said plainly, “I am convinced John Carpenter murdered Bob Crane.” In 2016, journalist John Hook retested the surviving blood evidence with modern DNA methods, but the tests consumed all the remaining DNA from the rental car, and the results were inconclusive — two sequences were identified, one from an unknown male, and the other too degraded to reach a conclusion. Further testing is now impossible.
Crane’s son Robert David later speculated publicly that his father’s wife, Patricia Olson — who inherited Crane’s entire estate under his will — might have had a role in instigating the crime. The district attorney’s office responded: “We never characterized Patty as a suspect.” That speculation has never been supported by evidence, and Olson died in 2007.
Crane was buried in Los Angeles, and his life and death became the subject of the 2002 film Auto Focus, starring Greg Kinnear. His son disputed much of the film’s portrayal, but the central fact it dramatised is not in dispute: a beloved television star was killed in a small apartment in Scottsdale, and nearly fifty years later, no one has been convicted of killing him.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Bob Crane (13 July 1928 – 29 June 1978), star of Hogan’s Heroes (1965–1971), was found bludgeoned to death in his apartment at the Winfield Place Apartments, Scottsdale, Arizona, on 29 June 1978, by his co-star Victoria Ann Berry. The weapon was never identified; an electrical cord was tied around his neck, with no signs of strangulation. Blood smears matching Crane’s blood type were found in John Henry Carpenter’s rental car. Carpenter was charged in 1992 and tried in 1994; the jury acquitted him in November 1994. Carpenter maintained his innocence until his death in 1998. The case remains officially unsolved.
Unverified or unproven: That John Henry Carpenter killed Bob Crane — he was acquitted, and later DNA testing of the surviving evidence was inconclusive. That the murder weapon was a camera tripod — this was the prosecution’s theory, never proven, and the weapon was never found. That the photograph from Carpenter’s car showed brain tissue — the defence disputed this, and the tissue samples themselves were lost. That Patricia Olson had any role in the crime — this is speculation by Crane’s son, not supported by evidence, and the district attorney’s office never characterised her as a suspect.