On a September morning in 1950, readers of the Sunday newspaper The People opened their paper to a front page that named four men and demanded their arrest. The headline read “ARREST THESE FOUR MEN”, and beneath it were the photographs of four brothers who, the paper said, ran an empire of vice in the heart of London. For years the Messina brothers had operated in plain sight in Soho and Mayfair, growing rich from the exploitation of women while the authorities seemed unable or unwilling to stop them. Within six months, four of the five brothers had left England. The fifth was in prison.
A Family Trade, Learned in Malta and Egypt
The Messina brothers were the sons of Giuseppe Messina, a Sicilian from Linguaglossa who had made his living in the brothel trade. In late 1890 he went to Malta, where he worked in a brothel on Strait Street — Triq Strada Stretta — the notorious entertainment street of Valletta. There he married Virginia Debono, a Maltese woman from Zejtun. Their first two sons were born in Hamrun, Malta: Salvatore, on 20 August 1898, and Alfredo, on 6 February 1901.
In 1905 the family moved to Alexandria, Egypt, then home to a large Maltese community. Giuseppe built a chain of brothels there, and his three younger sons were born in Alexandria: Eugenio in 1908, Attilio in 1910, and Carmelo in 1915. All five boys grew up inside their father’s business.
That life in Egypt ended abruptly in 1932, when the Egyptian authorities expelled Giuseppe and his sons. The family returned to Malta, where Giuseppe held citizenship. But London, with its demand and comparatively light penalties for soliciting, offered far greater opportunities. In 1934 Eugenio, the third son, moved to London with his French wife, Colette, who helped establish the trade there. The other brothers followed, and the Messinas set themselves up in Soho.
New Names, Old Business
On arrival in Britain, the brothers took English names. Eugenio became Edward Marshal, Carmelo became Charles Maitland, Alfredo became Alfred Martin, Salvatore became Arthur Evans, and Attilio became Raymond Maynard. Behind the new names, the brothers bought properties across the West End and set up businesses that gave their wealth a respectable front.
Soho was a natural base. The district had long been London’s pleasure quarter, with a French community, restaurants, clubs, and a tolerance for nightlife that the brothers knew how to exploit. Wartime demand from American servicemen stationed in England fed the trade. After the war, they imported women from Belgium, France, and Spain, and arranged sham marriages to secure British citizenship for some of them, making deportation far harder for the authorities.
By the late 1940s, the brothers were running about thirty houses of prostitution on streets including Queen Street, Bond Street, and Stafford Street in Mayfair and Soho. The women who worked for them were required to hand over 80 per cent of their earnings. By the early 1950s, police estimated that at least 200 of London’s most expensive prostitutes were Messina women. Police memos from 1947 estimated their earnings at between £15 and £25 per woman, per night — when the average weekly wage in Britain was around £10 — and put the brothers’ fortune at about £250,000, an immense sum in the late 1940s. In Parliament in 1947, one MP claimed the brothers had made about £500,000 from vice and owned a West End estate agency and shares in an important restaurant.
Why the Law Could Not Reach Them
The most troubling part of the Messina story is not the scale of the operation but how long it ran unchecked. The brothers were not secretive. They drove expensive cars around the West End, owned property openly, and were well known to the police. Yet prosecution proved extremely difficult.
Living on the earnings of prostitution was a criminal offence, but magistrates were reluctant to convict a man who could show income from other, apparently legitimate sources — and the Messinas had property, businesses, and money to point to. A police memo from 1947 put the difficulty plainly: the brothers had exploited prostitution as a business and made a fortune from it, but their income from other sources was such that no magistrate would convict any of them of living wholly or in part on the earnings of prostitution. An attempt to prosecute Eugenio, Salvatore, and Alfredo for that offence in 1936 had already failed, the cases dismissed.
The women themselves were also hard for prosecutors to rely on. Many held valid passports, which made deportation cases difficult; others were frightened, controlled, or dependent on the brothers, and unwilling to testify. Later, the brothers also began recruiting local English girls, drawing them in with gifts, attention, and promises of marriage before inducing them into prostitution. The pattern — control through money, fear, and dependence — is one that modern investigators of human trafficking would recognise immediately.
There were also persistent claims that the brothers received protection from within the police. In the late 1940s, Duncan Webb, a crime reporter on The People, began writing articles claiming that information was being leaked from Scotland Yard to Alfred Messina. Memos exchanged between inspectors and superintendents in 1947 described the brothers as “the biggest vice racketeers in the country” and listed the women under each brother’s control, with their addresses. Yet no concerted campaign followed.
“Arrest These Four Men”
The turning point came from journalism, not from the police. On 3 September 1950, The People published Webb’s front-page investigation, “Arrest These Four Men”, based on interviews with more than 100 prostitutes and setting out names, dates, photographs, and other information that would be essential to any police investigation. The exposé caused a public sensation. The publicity forced action. Scotland Yard formed a special investigative task force under Superintendent Guy Mahon and began an aggressive campaign against the brothers. The pressure worked quickly. On 19 March 1951, Eugenio, Carmelo, Salvatore, and Attilio left England. Alfredo stayed — and was arrested. He was charged with living off the immoral earnings of his girlfriend, Hermione Hinden, and with attempting to bribe Superintendent Mahon, the very officer who had arrested him. He was sentenced to two years in prison on bribery and prostitution charges.
The Brothers Scattered
Leaving England did not end the brothers’ criminal careers. Eugenio and Carmelo resurfaced in Belgium, living in a ten-bedroom flat on Avenue Louise in Brussels. On 31 August 1955 they were arrested as they were closing a deal with two Belgian girls. They were brought to court on 23 June 1956 on charges of procuring women, illegal possession of firearms, possessing fake passports, and entering Belgium illegally. Detectives from Scotland Yard gave evidence, and police forces in Italy, France, Belgium, and Britain cooperated in the investigation. Eugenio received a six-year sentence. Carmelo was acquitted for lack of evidence.
Carmelo was banned from re-entering England, but he did so anyway and was arrested on 3 October 1958, found sitting in a car in Knightsbridge. He received a six-month prison sentence for being an illegal immigrant and was then deported to Italy, where he went to live in Sanremo. He married Maria Theresa Vervaere on 12 March 1970 — and died the same day.
Attilio, too, tried to return. He was caught attempting to re-enter Britain illegally in April 1959 and was sentenced to four years’ imprisonment. After his release, he went to live in Italy. Alfredo died in Brentford in 1963. Of the five brothers, only Salvatore, the eldest, was never brought to justice. He went into hiding and was never apprehended.
The Legacy in Soho
The Messinas laid the foundations for the Maltese organised crime networks that followed them into Soho — the so-called Maltese Syndicate that filled the vacuum they left, and later groups that dominated the West End’s vice trade into the 1960s and beyond. The scandal also fed the wider debate about West End prostitution that culminated in the Street Offences Act of 1959, which sought to clear prostitutes from the streets of central London.
But the deeper legacy is a warning. The Messina brothers were not criminal masterminds operating in the shadows. They were known men, running a known business, in known streets, for nearly two decades. Their wealth bought property, cars, businesses, and apparent respectability. Their victims — women brought from the Continent, and later English girls drawn in with false promises — were the ones who paid the price, handing over four-fifths of everything they earned while the brothers grew rich. The system failed those women for years, not because the facts were hidden, but because the law was weak, the evidence was hard to assemble, and the will to act was slow in coming. It took a newspaper, a determined reporter, and a public outcry to do what the institutions had not.
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: The brothers’ family background, birth dates and places, the 1932 expulsion from Egypt, Eugenio’s move to London in 1934, their adopted English names, the scale of the operation (about thirty houses, 80 per cent of earnings taken, police estimates of at least 200 women), the failed 1936 prosecution, the 1947 police memos and parliamentary debate, Duncan Webb’s 3 September 1950 exposé in The People, Superintendent Guy Mahon’s task force, the departure of four brothers on 19 March 1951, Alfredo’s two-year sentence for bribery and prostitution offences, the 1955 Brussels arrests and the 1956 trial in which Eugenio received six years and Carmelo was acquitted, Carmelo’s 1958 arrest and deportation, Attilio’s 1959 four-year sentence for illegal re-entry, Alfredo’s death in Brentford in 1963, and Salvatore’s disappearance are all recorded in contemporary police material, parliamentary records, press reports, and the historical sources listed below.
Unverified or unproven: The exact size of the brothers’ fortune varies between sources — police memos put it at about £250,000, while a parliamentary question in 1947 suggested £500,000 — and neither figure can be treated as exact. Attilio’s reported boast that the Messinas were “more powerful than the British Government” is a press-reported remark, not a verified quotation. Claims that specific Metropolitan Police officers were bribed by the brothers were alleged by Duncan Webb but never proven in court. The suspicion that the brothers were involved in the 1948 murder of Rachel Fennick, known as “Ginger Rae”, a Soho prostitute found dead in her flat on Broadwick Street, has been raised by some writers but was never established, and no Messina brother was charged in connection with her death. The precise number of women exploited by the brothers is an estimate, not a count.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Messina_Brothers
- https://matthewvella.substack.com/p/sohobites-7-the-tide-turns-on-the
- https://hansard.parliament.uk/Commons/1947-07-03/debates/0bf0787c-a78e-4d78-b3e3-98a931adc4db/NationalFinance
- https://www.yellow.com.mt/news/all/the-maltese-who-came-to-britain-why-over-30-000-maltese-settled-in-the-uk-after-the-war/
- https://books.google.com/books/about/The_Mayfair_Mafia.html?id=tA_NwQEACAAJ
- https://gangstersinc.org/2023/11/12/gangs-of-london/
- https://www.murdermiletours.com/blog/the-mysterious-mediterranean-murder-of-sohos-ginger-rae