The Kidnapping of Polly Klaas: Petaluma, 1993

Reading Time: 5 minutes ·

Polly Hannah Klaas was twelve years old, a seventh-grader who loved acting and had just performed on the stage of her junior high school in Petaluma, California. On the evening of 1 October 1993, she was having a slumber party at her mother’s home with two friends. Before the night was over, a stranger had entered the house, and Polly was gone. What followed was one of the largest searches in California history, a two-month wait that held a whole town, and a case that would reshape the state’s criminal law.

A slumber party in Petaluma

Polly was born on 3 January 1981 in Fairfax, California. By the autumn of 1993 she was living with her mother, Eve Nichol, in a two-bedroom bungalow in Petaluma, a small city in Sonoma County about 40 miles north of San Francisco. On the night of 1 October, Polly and her friends Gillian and Kate were having a slumber party in her bedroom. Her mother and her six-year-old half-sister, Annie, were asleep in the other room.

At about 10:30 p.m., a man entered the house through an unlocked back door and confronted the three girls with a knife. He asked which of them lived there; Polly said that she did. He tied the girls’ hands behind their backs and covered their heads with pillowcases, then asked about valuables in the house. He took nothing. Instead, he took Polly.

Her mother discovered what had happened and called the police. Within hours, the disappearance of a twelve-year-old girl from her own bedroom had become national news.

The search

Over the next two months, about 4,000 people helped search for Polly. Volunteers combed the hills and fields of Sonoma County. Her face was on posters, on television, and in newspapers across the country. The case drew help from far beyond Petaluma: on 9 October, actress Winona Ryder, who had grown up in Petaluma and had begun her own acting career on the same junior high school stage where Polly had performed, offered a $200,000 reward for Polly’s safe return.

The search produced no trace of her. Police pursued leads across the state, and the FBI joined the investigation. For Polly’s family, the waiting was its own ordeal. Her father, Marc Klaas, became a familiar figure on television, pleading for information and for his daughter’s return.

The break came from an apparently unrelated incident. Richard Allen Davis, a 39-year-old man with a long criminal record, had been stopped by police in Mendocino County. Investigators had already noted Davis as a suspect: he had been convicted of kidnapping and assault in 1976, and of kidnapping, robbery, burglary and assault in 1984, for which he had received a 16-year sentence and served eight. He had been released from prison in June 1993, only a few months before Polly was taken.

On 4 December, after investigators told Davis that his DNA had been found in Polly’s bedroom, he confessed to kidnapping and killing her. He led detectives to a shallow grave in a wooded area south of Cloverdale, about 50 miles north of Petaluma, where her body was found. She had been strangled. She had been dead since the night she was taken.

The trial

Davis was charged with kidnapping and first-degree murder, along with robbery, burglary, assault, false imprisonment and attempted lewd acts on a child. His trial, which began on 17 April 1996 in San Jose, lasted two months and was, by every account, long and difficult. His own lawyer acknowledged in court that Davis had killed Polly.

On 18 June 1996, the jury convicted Davis of first-degree murder with four special circumstances — robbery, burglary, kidnapping and attempted lewd act on a child — along with the other charges. The jury returned a sentence of death. At his formal sentencing on 27 September 1996, Davis provoked outrage in the courtroom, gesturing obscenely at a camera and making an unsubstantiated claim about Polly’s last words, a claim for which there was no evidence. Judge Thomas Hastings formally sentenced him to death, saying Davis’s conduct in court had made the decision significantly easier.

Davis’s death sentence was upheld by the California Supreme Court in 2009. He remained on death row for decades. Following Governor Gavin Newsom’s moratorium on executions in March 2019, Davis was transferred from San Quentin to a state prison facility in Stockton. In November 2026, news reports said Governor Newsom had commuted Davis’s death sentence to life without the possibility of parole.

A legacy written into law

Polly’s murder changed California. In the months after her death, her father became a leading voice for tougher sentencing of repeat offenders. On 8 March 1994, California’s “Three Strikes” law was signed into law, imposing a sentence of 25 years to life on a third felony conviction. Similar laws followed in other states. The law has been debated ever since — voters reformed it in 2012 to remove life sentences for less serious, non-violent third offences — but its origin in Polly’s case is not in dispute.

Marc Klaas also established the Polly Klaas Foundation (formerly the KlaasKids Foundation), which works to prevent crimes against children and to help families of missing children. The case changed police practice, too: the all-points bulletin issued after Polly’s abduction had gone out only on a California Highway Patrol channel that other agencies’ radios could not receive. After the case, the radio system was upgraded so such bulletins are broadcast on all police channels through a centralised 911 dispatch system.

Petaluma has kept Polly’s memory close. The 1994 film version of Little Women — a book Polly loved — was dedicated to her. A performing arts centre in the town was named for her in 1998; after years of fundraising and building work, the Polly Klaas Community Theater reopened in November 2022. Her body was cremated and her ashes scattered over the Pacific Ocean by her family and friends.

In January 2024, her younger sister Annie Nichol wrote in The New York Times about living with the case’s long shadow, criticising the way true crime media can repackage a family’s pain as entertainment and urging care for survivors. It was a reminder that behind the law, the foundation and the headlines, the case began with a twelve-year-old girl who loved the stage — and a family that has spent more than thirty years making sure she is remembered as a person, not only as a case.

What the record shows

What is documented is this: on the night of 1 October 1993, Richard Allen Davis entered Eve Nichol’s home in Petaluma through an unlocked back door and abducted twelve-year-old Polly Klaas at knifepoint while her two friends were present; about 4,000 people took part in the search that followed; Davis confessed on 4 December 1993 after being told his DNA had been found in the bedroom, and led police to her body south of Cloverdale; on 18 June 1996 a jury convicted him of first-degree murder with four special circumstances and returned a death sentence, formally imposed on 27 September 1996; and in the wake of the case California enacted its Three Strikes law on 8 March 1994.

Two points need care. First, whether Polly was sexually assaulted could not be established: a preliminary test suggested the possible presence of semen, but it was never confirmed, and decomposition made it impossible to confirm or exclude an assault. The record is inconclusive, and it should be reported as such. Second, Davis’s claim in court about Polly’s last words had no supporting evidence and should not be repeated as fact. The November 2026 commutation of his sentence is reported from news coverage of that month.

Sources

Leave a Comment