On the evening of 22 October 1989, eleven-year-old Jacob Erwin Wetterling rode his bicycle home along a country road near St. Joseph, Minnesota, with his ten-year-old brother Trevor and their friend Aaron Larson. The boys had rented a video from a convenience store and were heading home in the dark. A masked man with a gun stopped them on the road. He told Trevor and Aaron to run, and he took Jacob. It was the last time Jacob was seen alive.
For the next 27 years, Jacob’s parents, Patty and Jerry Wetterling, did not know where their son was or what had happened to him. The case became one of the most widely known missing-child investigations in American history, and it changed the law across the country. In September 2016, the man who took him finally admitted what he had done and led investigators to Jacob’s remains. Jacob was, at last, brought home.
The Night Jacob Was Taken
St. Joseph is a small town in Stearns County, in central Minnesota. On that October evening, the three boys were riding home from the Tom Thumb convenience store, where they had rented a movie. A man wearing a mask and carrying a gun stepped out of a driveway and ordered them off their bicycles. He asked their ages, told Trevor and Aaron to run home, and ordered Jacob to get into his car.
Trevor and Aaron ran. When they reached home, they told their parents what had happened, and the alarm was raised immediately. Sheriff’s deputies, state investigators and FBI agents joined the search within hours. Hundreds of volunteers combed the fields and woods around St. Joseph. Roadblocks were set up, and a description of the masked man was circulated. But the man and the car vanished into the night, and Jacob was gone.
In the months and years that followed, investigators pursued thousands of leads. Tips came in from across the country. The Wetterling family kept Jacob’s name in the public eye, appearing on television and in newspapers, and refusing to let the case fade. In 1990, Patty and Jerry Wetterling founded the Jacob Wetterling Foundation, later the Jacob Wetterling Resource Center, to help other families of missing children and to teach parents and children about safety.
A Law Named for Jacob
Jacob’s case had an effect far beyond Minnesota. In 1994, Congress passed the Jacob Wetterling Crimes Against Children and Sexually Violent Offender Registration Act, the first federal law to require states to create sex-offender registries. It was named for Jacob because his disappearance had shown how little information was available to parents and police about convicted offenders living in a community. The law became the foundation for the national registration system that exists today.
For all of that, the central question — what happened to Jacob — remained unanswered. The case file grew to tens of thousands of pages. Investigators returned to it again and again, and in 2014 the FBI’s Child Abduction Rapid Deployment team re-examined the evidence with fresh eyes.
The Break
The break came from a separate case. In January 1989, about nine months before Jacob was taken, a twelve-year-old boy named Jared Scheierl had been abducted and assaulted in Cold Spring, Minnesota, about ten miles from St. Joseph. Scheierl survived and was able to describe his attacker. The man who attacked him was never identified at the time.
In July 2015, investigators searched the home of Danny James Heinrich, a man from Paynesville, Minnesota, about thirty miles from St. Joseph, as part of a child-pornography investigation. Inside the house they found articles about Jacob’s disappearance. More importantly, DNA from Heinrich matched evidence from the Scheierl case. Heinrich, who had been a person of interest in the Wetterling investigation for years, was arrested in October 2015 on federal child-pornography charges.
The Confession
In late August 2016, Heinrich agreed to cooperate with prosecutors. Under a plea agreement, he would plead guilty to a federal child-pornography charge and receive a twenty-year sentence, and in exchange he would tell investigators what had happened to Jacob and lead them to his remains. He would not be charged with murder or kidnapping.
Heinrich led investigators to a pasture near Paynesville, about thirty miles from where Jacob had been taken. There, buried in the ground, were Jacob’s remains and his clothing. The remains were recovered in early September 2016 and identified through dental records. On 3 September 2016, the Wetterling family announced that Jacob had been found.
On 6 September 2016, Heinrich appeared in federal court in Minneapolis and admitted that on 22 October 1989 he had abducted and murdered Jacob Wetterling. He also admitted that in January 1989 he had abducted and assaulted Jared Scheierl. In November 2016, he was sentenced to twenty years in federal prison on the child-pornography charge through which his confession had been secured.
Jacob was buried at St. John’s Abbey Cemetery. The Stearns County Sheriff’s Office later announced its intention to release the full case file — some 56,000 pages — to the public.
The plea agreement that resolved the case remains controversial. Heinrich was never charged with Jacob’s murder, and he will serve twenty years in federal prison rather than a life sentence for murder. Prosecutors said the agreement was the only way to learn what had happened to Jacob and to bring him home. For the Wetterling family, the answer they had waited 27 years for finally came, at a price they had not chosen.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Jacob Wetterling, aged 11, was abducted on the evening of 22 October 1989 near St. Joseph, Minnesota, while riding home with his brother Trevor and friend Aaron Larson. Danny Heinrich confessed in federal court on 6 September 2016 that he had abducted and murdered Jacob, and that he had abducted and assaulted Jared Scheierl in January 1989. Heinrich led investigators to Jacob’s remains in a pasture near Paynesville, about thirty miles from the abduction site; the remains were identified through dental records and the identification was announced on 3 September 2016. Heinrich was sentenced in November 2016 to twenty years in federal prison on a child-pornography charge and was not charged with murder. The Jacob Wetterling Crimes Against Children and Sexually Violent Offender Registration Act was passed in 1994.
Not established: The exact day the remains were recovered is reported differently in different sources — 1 September 2016 in some accounts, 2 September 2016 in the U.S. Attorney’s announcement — so this article gives the identification date, 3 September, which is consistent across sources. Details of what Heinrich said in his confession beyond the facts summarised here come from court transcripts and have been reported differently in secondary accounts; this article states only what the court record and the U.S. Attorney’s office confirmed.