The Kidnapping of Elizabeth Smart, 2002: Nine Months, and a Rescue

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

The Kidnapping of Elizabeth Smart, 2002: Nine Months, and a Rescue

Elizabeth Ann Smart was 14 years old on 5 June 2002. She lived with her family in the Federal Heights neighbourhood of Salt Lake City, Utah. That night, a man entered the bedroom she shared with her younger sister, Mary Katherine, and took Elizabeth from the house at knifepoint. Her sister, who was nine, pretended to be asleep out of fear. She was the only eyewitness.

The man was Brian David Mitchell, who called himself Emmanuel and described himself as a religious preacher. He had previously done handyman work at the Smart home. With him was his wife, Wanda Barzee. For the next nine months, Smart was held by the couple, first at a camp in the foothills above Salt Lake City and later in the San Diego area of California. She was repeatedly assaulted during her captivity, restrained, and threatened with death if she tried to escape. This article records those facts in the restrained terms of the court record, without graphic detail.

The search

The disappearance launched a national manhunt. Police, the FBI and volunteers searched neighbourhoods, foothills and canyons, and the reward for information reportedly rose to $250,000 within days. Early in the investigation, attention focused heavily on Richard Ricci, a handyman who had worked in the Smart home. Ricci was jailed on unrelated matters, denied involvement, and died in custody on 30 August 2002. Later reporting indicated he was not responsible — a fact that has since been cited as a warning about investigative tunnel vision.

Months after the abduction, Mary Katherine told her parents she believed the voice she had heard that night belonged to “Emmanuel,” a man who had previously worked at their home. Frustrated with the pace of the investigation, the family went public with a sketch. Tips poured in, and “Emmanuel” was identified as Brian David Mitchell.

Smart was, during her captivity, taken out in public on several occasions, dressed head to toe in white robes with a veil, and went largely unrecognised despite contact with members of the public.

The rescue

On 12 March 2003, after nine months, several people reported seeing a man, a woman and a girl in disguise in Sandy, Utah, about 18 miles from Smart’s home. The reports came after the three had been featured on the television programme America’s Most Wanted. Police officers stopped the group on a public street. They pulled Smart aside to talk privately. She confirmed that she was Elizabeth Smart, and she was reunited with her family the same day. Mitchell and Barzee were arrested on suspicion of aggravated kidnapping.

The rescue was, in the words of the record, a matter of recognition: two witnesses had recognised Mitchell and Barzee from the television programme, and officers who stopped the group took the time to speak to the girl alone.

The trials

The legal road that followed was long, and it was shaped by disputes over Mitchell’s competence to stand trial. He was diagnosed by forensic psychologists as having antisocial and narcissistic personality disorders. His lawyers argued that he was not guilty by reason of insanity. Extensive competency proceedings lasted several years before, on 1 March 2010, U.S. District Judge Dale Kimball issued a 149-page ruling finding Mitchell competent to stand trial.

Barzee’s case was resolved first. In November 2009 she pleaded guilty to federal charges of kidnapping and unlawful transportation of a minor, agreeing to testify against Mitchell. On 19 May 2010, Judge Kimball sentenced her to 15 years in federal prison, giving her credit for seven years already served. She was granted early release on 19 September 2018 for previously uncredited time served.

Mitchell’s federal trial began in November 2010. After a four-week trial, the jury found him guilty in December 2010 of kidnapping and unlawful transportation of a minor across state lines for sexual activity. On 25 May 2011 — Missing Children’s Day — Judge Kimball sentenced him to life in federal prison without the possibility of parole.

What happened afterwards

After her rescue, Elizabeth Smart became an advocate for missing persons and for survivors of sexual assault. She has worked as a child safety activist and as a commentator for ABC News, and she founded the Elizabeth Smart Foundation. She has spoken publicly about her experience in interviews, in a memoir, and in a documentary, and she has campaigned for changes to the way missing children are searched for and the way survivors are treated.

Mitchell remains in federal prison, serving life without parole. Barzee was released in 2018. In May 2025, she was arrested for violating her parole by visiting public parks, which she was not allowed to do as a registered sex offender.

What the record shows

Elizabeth Smart, 14, was taken from her home in Salt Lake City on 5 June 2002 by Brian David Mitchell and Wanda Barzee. She was held for about nine months, in Utah and in California, before being recognised on a street in Sandy, Utah, on 12 March 2003, and reunited with her family. Mitchell was found guilty in December 2010 and sentenced in May 2011 to life in federal prison without parole. Barzee pleaded guilty in 2009 and was sentenced to 15 years; she was released in 2018.

The case is remembered, rightly, as a rescue — but it is also a case about how a child was found: not by a single breakthrough, but by a sister who remembered a voice, a family that went public with a sketch, viewers who recognised a face on television, and officers who took the time to speak to a girl alone.

Sources

Leave a Comment