The Jamison Family: A Trip to Look at Land in Oklahoma, and No One Came Home

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

In the autumn of 2009, a family of three from Eufaula, Oklahoma, drove into the Sans Bois Mountains of south-eastern Oklahoma to look at a 40-acre plot of land they were considering buying. Bobby Jamison was 44, his wife Sherilynn was 40, and their daughter Madyson was six. They were last seen on 8 October 2009. Days later, their pickup truck was found abandoned on a remote track, with their belongings — and a large sum of cash — still inside. The family themselves were gone. It would be four years before their remains were found, and the cause of their deaths has never been determined.

The Family and the Land

Bobby Dale Jamison, born 4 August 1965, and Sherilynn Jamison, born 5 November 1968, lived with their daughter Madyson, born 1 August 2003, in a house on Eufaula Lake. The family had been thinking about buying rural land, and in early October 2009 they began looking at a 40-acre plot near Red Oak, about 30 miles from Eufaula, in the San Bois Mountains of Latimer County.

On 7 October, the day before they vanished, they visited the property and spoke with the landowner. On 8 October they returned to the area. They were seen by the landowner and were recorded on surveillance footage at a local real estate office in Red Oak that day. That is the last confirmed sighting of the family.

The Abandoned Truck

When the family did not return home, relatives and police began searching. On 16 October 2009 — eight days after they were last seen — hunters found the family’s white pickup truck abandoned at a remote well-pad site south of Kinta, in Latimer County, a short distance from the land the family had been considering buying.

Inside the truck, investigators found the family’s wallet and purse, their mobile phones, and about $32,000 in cash. The family’s small dog was also in the truck, alive but starving. Also reported among the items in the truck was a letter written by Sherilynn to Bobby, expressing anger in their marriage. The truck had been left with its driver’s-side window down.

The contents of the truck deepened the mystery rather than resolving it. A family that had run away would not be expected to leave behind their phones, their money and their dog. A family that had been robbed would not be expected to leave $32,000 in cash behind. More than 300 volunteers and dozens of law enforcement officers searched the surrounding area in the weeks that followed. They found the truck, but not the family.

A Troubled Background

Reporting after the disappearance revealed strains in the family’s life. About six months before they vanished, Bobby Jamison had filed a petition for a protective order in McIntosh County, stating that a close relative had twice threatened to kill him and his family, in November 2008 and again in April 2009. That relative, his father Bob Dean Jamison, died in December 2009, two months after the family disappeared. Police have said they do not believe Bob Dean Jamison was involved in the family’s disappearance.

The case was profiled on the Investigation Discovery series Disappeared in late 2010, in an episode titled “Paradise Lost”, which brought the family’s story to a national audience. Still, no new leads emerged, and the case went cold.

The Remains Are Found

On 16 November 2013, more than four years after the family disappeared, two deer hunters found skeletal remains in a remote, heavily wooded area of Latimer County, less than three miles from where the pickup truck had been found. The remains were those of two adults and one child, lying close together. On 3 July 2014, the Oklahoma medical examiner confirmed that the remains belonged to Bobby, Sherilynn and Madyson Jamison.

Because of the extent of decomposition and damage to the bones after four years outdoors, the medical examiner could not determine a cause of death for any of the three, nor the manner of death. No weapon was recovered, and no injuries that could explain their deaths survived in a form that could be identified. The official record therefore ends with the starkest possible finding: cause unknown.

In 2021, the Latimer County Sheriff’s Office said publicly that it believed the family had been murdered. The sheriff said investigators were confident the deaths were a homicide, but no suspect was named and no evidence was described in public. No one has been charged in connection with the deaths.

The Theories, and Their Limits

In the absence of a cause of death, the case has attracted many theories: that the family was killed by someone they knew, that they died of exposure after becoming lost, that they were victims of a group suicide, and even that occult activity was involved. None of these theories is supported by evidence that has been made public, and none should be treated as fact.

What the evidence does support is narrower, and more sobering. The family went to a remote place they did not know well. Their truck, with everything they would need, was left behind. Their remains were found close together, a short distance away, four years later. Whether they walked into the woods themselves and died there, or were taken there by someone else, is something the available evidence cannot answer — and after so much time outdoors, it may never be able to.

What Is Documented — and What Is Not

Documented: Bobby (44), Sherilynn (40) and Madyson Jamison (6) were last seen on 8 October 2009 near Red Oak, Oklahoma; their truck was found on 16 October 2009 near Kinta with their phones, wallet, purse, about $32,000 in cash and their dog inside; skeletal remains found on 16 November 2013 less than three miles from the truck were identified as the Jamisons on 3 July 2014; the medical examiner could not determine a cause or manner of death; in 2021 the Latimer County Sheriff’s Office said it believed the deaths were a homicide, with no suspect named and no charges filed.

Not established: How the family died, whether anyone else was involved, and what happened between their last sighting and the abandonment of the truck. The letter found in the truck and the protective order Bobby filed are documented facts, but neither proves a motive or identifies a killer. Theories involving group suicide, cults or occult activity are speculation with no supporting evidence in the public record, and the 2021 homicide statement was an investigative assessment, not a charge or a finding by the medical examiner.

Sources

Leave a Comment