In the early hours of a Friday night in September 1997, six men loaded $18.9 million in cash into a rented U-Haul truck outside a warehouse on Mateo Street in downtown Los Angeles and drove away. No one was seriously hurt. No shots were fired. And for nearly two years, investigators had almost nothing to go on — except the certainty that the robbery had been planned by someone who knew the building from the inside.
The Dunbar Armored robbery was, at the time, the largest cash robbery ever carried out in the United States. It was also a case study in how an inside job works: not through force, but through knowledge — of floor plans, camera positions, guard routines and the precise hour when the vault stood open.
The man who knew the building
Allen Pace III was a regional safety inspector for Dunbar Armored, the company that moved cash for banks and businesses across Southern California. The job gave him near-total access to the company’s Los Angeles depot on Mateo Street: its layout, its security cameras and their blind spots, its guard rotations, and the rhythms of a night shift. Over months on the job, he photographed the depot’s interior and mapped its routines.
Pace recruited five childhood friends to carry out the robbery with him: Erik Damon Boyd of Buena Park, Eugene Lamar Hill Jr. of Bellflower, Freddie Lynn McCrary Jr. of Arleta, Terry Wayne Brown Sr. of Los Angeles, and Thomas Lee Johnson of Las Vegas. None of the five worked for Dunbar. Pace supplied them with detailed floor plans and camera locations, ski masks, pistols, a shotgun and radio headsets.
There was one complication. The day before the robbery, Dunbar fired Pace for tampering with company vehicles. It was an unrelated disciplinary matter, but it made him the obvious suspect the moment the robbery was discovered — and it also meant that the keys and access he still held would not work for long. The crew went ahead anyway, on the night of Friday 12 September 1997.
Thirty minutes
The six men began the evening at a house party, establishing an alibi, before leaving for the depot. Pace used his keys to let the crew into the building. They hid in the employee cafeteria and waited.
The depot’s guards came to the cafeteria one by one for their breaks, at around 12:30 a.m. The robbers ambushed each of them in turn, restraining them without firing a shot. With the guards secured, the crew moved to the vault. It was a Friday night, and the vault was open, holding cash that had been collected during the week and was bound for banks and ATMs across Los Angeles. In about thirty minutes, the men loaded $18.9 million — much of it in $20 bills — into the waiting U-Haul truck. They removed the security recordings before they left.
By the time the restrained guards freed themselves and raised the alarm, the truck was gone. Police found almost nothing at the scene: no forced entry, no broken locks, and no witness who could identify the masked men. The single piece of physical evidence was a small plastic lens from a vehicle’s tail light, left behind at the depot.
An inside job, but no proof
Investigators from the Los Angeles Police Department, the FBI and the IRS formed a joint task force. They realised immediately that the robbery was an inside job, and they looked closely at Pace — not least because he had been fired the day before. But suspicion was not proof. Pace had an alibi for the evening, the crew had left no forensic trail, and the cash itself was ordinary currency in circulation, with no serial numbers logged for a single transaction that would allow it to be traced.
The FBI laboratory in Washington matched the plastic lens found at the scene to the tail lights fitted to fourteen-foot U-Haul trucks. That narrowed the search, but the truck itself had been rented under circumstances that did not immediately lead back to the crew.
For nearly two years, the six men lived quietly. The money was laundered through front companies, real estate purchases and vehicles, with the help of an attorney, David Matsumoto, and an office manager, Joaquin Bin, who were later convicted of money laundering.
The mistake
The case broke on a detail that had nothing to do with the night of the robbery. Eugene Hill paid a real estate broker with a stack of cash still bound in its original currency straps — the paper bands used by banks and armored carriers, which linked the money to the kind of bulk cash handled by a depot. The broker became suspicious, and the payment led investigators to Hill, and from Hill to the rest of the crew.
Arrests followed. The trial began in February 2001. Some of the defendants pleaded guilty and received sentences of between seven and a half and eleven years. Pace, who maintained his innocence and pleaded not guilty, was convicted. On 23 April 2001, he was sentenced to twenty-four years in federal prison. Boyd was sentenced to seventeen years, and the other four robbers received sentences ranging from eight to ten years. Matsumoto and Bin, who had assisted with the laundering, were each sentenced to two and a half years.
The judge in the case, U.S. District Judge Lourdes Baird, noted Pace’s lack of remorse in imposing the sentence. Prosecutors said at the time that the crew would also be ordered to repay the money taken.
The missing millions
Only a fraction of the $18.9 million was ever recovered. According to the most widely cited accounting, less than a third — about $5 million — was recovered, through the seizure of homes, cars and other property bought with the stolen cash, leaving about $13.9 million unaccounted for. The U.S. Attorney at the time, Alejandro Mayorkas, said that more than $10 million remained unaccounted for. None of the convicted men has publicly revealed where the missing money went.
Pace served his sentence at the Federal Correctional Institution in Safford, Arizona, and was released on 1 October 2020, after more than two decades in prison. The Dunbar robbery held its record as the largest cash robbery in American history for more than twenty-six years, until the Easter Sunday heist of 31 March 2024, at a cash storage facility in the Sylmar area of Los Angeles, was estimated at more than $20 million.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: The date and place of the robbery; the sum of $18.9 million; Pace’s role as a regional safety inspector and his firing the day before; the identities of the five other robbers; the sequence at the depot, including the cafeteria ambush, the thirty-minute loading and the U-Haul getaway; the tail-light lens matched to a fourteen-foot U-Haul; the laundering through Matsumoto and Bin; Hill’s payment in strapped currency as the break in the case; the convictions and sentences imposed in 2001, including Pace’s twenty-four-year sentence on 23 April 2001 and his release on 1 October 2020; and the fact that the record stood until the Easter Sunday heist of 31 March 2024.
Unverified or uncertain: Sources differ on the precise amount recovered — about $5 million in the most widely cited accounting, with some accounts giving $5 million to $7 million, and the unaccounted balance variously stated as about $12 million, more than $10 million or $13.9 million. This article uses the $5 million recovered and $13.9 million unaccounted figures, which follow from the same accounting, and flags the variation here. Some accounts date the entry into the depot to just after midnight on 13 September rather than the night of 12 September; the date is given here as the night of 12 September 1997, as in the principal sources. Claims in some retellings about exactly how the crew spent the money, and about where the missing millions are now, are speculation and are not repeated as fact.
Sources
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dunbar_Armored_robbery
- https://www.worldatlas.com/crime/the-biggest-heists-and-bank-robberies-in-american-history.html
- https://gilaherald.com/the-great-dunbar-armored-depot-robbery/
- https://enigmatruecrime.com/2026/08/06/dunbar-armored-robbery-1997/
- https://medium.com/@alyssakelirose/the-dunbar-heist-7e16450c3192