On the night of 9 February 2009, five-year-old Haleigh Ann-Marie Cummings went to bed in her father’s home in Satsuma, a small riverfront community in Putnam County, Florida. By morning she was gone. There was no broken window and no sign of a struggle. The back door of the family’s trailer stood open, propped ajar by a cinder block. An AMBER Alert went out, hundreds of searchers combed the woods and the nearby St. Johns River, and the case drew national attention. Seventeen years later, Haleigh has never been found, no one has been charged, and her case remains one of Florida’s unsolved AMBER Alerts.
This article follows the record: what is known about Haleigh and her family, what happened on the night she vanished, how the investigation unfolded, and what remains genuinely unresolved.
Haleigh and her family
Haleigh Cummings was born on 17 August 2003 to Ronald Lemyles Cummings and Crystal Sheffield. She was five years old when she disappeared: about three feet three inches tall, weighing around 39 pounds, with blond hair and brown eyes, a four-inch round birthmark on the lower left side of her back, and two birthmarks on her face. She was a kindergarten student at Browning-Pearce Elementary School in San Mateo, Florida, and her favourite food was macaroni and cheese.
Haleigh’s parents had separated about four years earlier and had fought over custody in court. Ronald sought custody because Sheffield had admitted to using cocaine and Haleigh had missed several doctor’s appointments in her care; Sheffield alleged Ronald was violent and once sought a protective order, but that case was dismissed. In December 2005, Ronald was given full custody. Haleigh visited her mother every other weekend.
By February 2009, Haleigh lived with her father, her three-year-old brother, known as Junior, and her father’s live-in girlfriend, Misty Janette Croslin, in a double-wide trailer in the 200 block of Green Lane, in the Hermit’s Cove area of Satsuma. Misty was seventeen and had been living with the family for about five months. Ronald, then twenty-five, worked at PDM Bridge and was on the second shift that night.
The night of 9–10 February 2009
The last hours of 9 February 2009 are known only through the accounts of the people who were in the house, and those accounts have shifted over time. Haleigh went to bed at about 8:00 p.m. Misty, who was looking after the children while Ronald was at work, went to sleep in the same room at about 10:00 p.m. Haleigh’s three-year-old brother was also sleeping in that room.
Ronald finished his shift and arrived home sometime after 3:00 a.m. on 10 February. According to Misty, she had just discovered that Haleigh was missing from her bed. The rear door of the trailer was several inches ajar, and the screen door had been propped open with a cinder block. Ronald and Misty called 911 at 3:37 a.m. On the call, Misty told the dispatcher, “I just woke up and my back door is open, and I can’t find my daughter.”
Police found no sign of forced entry, although they said they were uncertain whether the back door had been locked. Ronald and Misty insisted that it had been, and Ronald has maintained that the trailer was broken into. He also said his daughter would not have left home by herself at night, because she was afraid of the dark.
Haleigh’s younger brother told investigators that a man dressed in black had come to their home that night and taken his sister. Authorities have said they are unsure how much weight to give his account, given that he was only three years old. Early reports said Haleigh had last been seen wearing a pink shirt, but police later said the shirt had been found, and investigators now say they do not know what she was wearing that night.
The search
The response was immediate. A statewide AMBER Alert was issued on 10 February, and the search quickly drew as many as 130 officers, with bloodhounds and helicopters. The Florida Department of Law Enforcement and the FBI joined the Putnam County Sheriff’s Office, along with sheriff’s offices from Volusia, Marion, and Flagler counties, and volunteers from Texas EquuSearch arrived to help. Searchers focused on a five-square-mile area, stopping vehicles leaving the area, sending tracking dogs toward the St. Johns River and the railroad tracks, and sending divers into nearby water. Investigators also interviewed forty-four registered sex offenders who lived within five miles of the home.
Within two days, officials said the case had changed in character. “There is no longer any reason to believe that the child simply wandered off outside,” Major Gary Bowling of the Putnam County Sheriff’s Office said on 11 February, adding that someone had likely abducted the five-year-old from her bedroom. No suspects were named, and no one had been ruled out. The search turned up no sign of Haleigh. Skeletal remains found in the area proved not to be connected to her, and repeated searches of the St. Johns River produced nothing publicly linked to the case.
The questions around Misty Croslin
From the early days, detectives focused on the one adult who had been in the house with the children that night. Investigators have been publicly sceptical of Misty’s account, stating that she failed four polygraph tests and one voice stress test and changed her story multiple times. They described her accounts as “consistently inconsistent.” Misty has described herself as a devoted caregiver to Haleigh and her brother and has said she was home the entire night. Police also looked into the possibility that she was not in fact at home when the child disappeared.
The inconsistencies investigators pointed to were in the small details of that night: where exactly Haleigh had been sleeping, whether she had been on a mattress on the floor or in the bed, and what she had been wearing. The shifting accounts damaged her credibility with investigators and with the public, and she has remained a central figure in the case ever since.
One month after Haleigh disappeared, in March 2009, Ronald married Misty. Because she was only seventeen, they needed permission from her parents. In October 2009, Ronald filed for divorce, citing irreconcilable differences and the stress of the disappearance and the investigation. The divorce became final within days.
The accusation against Joseph Overstreet
In the months after Haleigh vanished, Misty and her older brother, Hank Thomas “Tommy” Croslin Jr., accused Joseph “Joe” Overstreet, a cousin of Misty’s from Tennessee, of kidnapping Haleigh. Overstreet had visited the Cummings home on 9 February and left only a few hours before she vanished; the next day he returned to Tennessee.
Tommy was the first to make the accusation. He said Overstreet had planned to steal a machine gun from the Cummings home and, when he could not find it, had threatened Misty with a knife and taken Haleigh, and that the two men then drove to the St. Johns River, about five miles away, where Overstreet threw the child into the water. Misty later affirmed his statement, saying she had lied earlier because she was afraid of her cousin. She also said Overstreet had abused her when she was a child, although he is not a registered sex offender.
Overstreet has denied any involvement. He has not been charged, and he has not even been named as a suspect, although he has been interviewed. In April 2010, authorities searched the river again and brought Misty to the dock, but the search yielded nothing of interest.
Arrests that were not about Haleigh
In January 2010, Misty, Tommy, and Ronald were arrested on drug trafficking charges, along with Ronald’s cousin and a friend. The charges were unrelated to Haleigh’s disappearance. Ronald and the other defendants pleaded guilty, except for Misty, who pleaded no contest. All except Misty were sentenced to fifteen years in prison; Misty received twenty-five years. Ronald was released in October 2022, was arrested again two months later on drug and resisting charges, and pleaded no contest in November 2024. Misty remains in prison, with a projected release date of 10 June 2031.
Neither Ronald nor Misty has ever been charged in Haleigh’s disappearance.
The case today
Haleigh’s case remains unsolved, and the Charley Project classifies it as a homicide. It is one of Florida’s seven unsolved AMBER Alerts. Crime Stoppers of Northeast Florida offers a $15,000 reward for information that helps find Haleigh.
The National Center for Missing and Exploited Children has released age-progression images showing what Haleigh might look like as she grew older — at ages eight and twelve, and again in September 2024, at twenty-one. In 2020, Haleigh’s great-grandmother, Annette Sykes, who was dying of stage four cancer, told reporters that her final wish was to find out what had happened to Haleigh.
In July 2024, Misty Croslin appeared on a true-crime podcast and changed her account again, saying, “I saw what happened” on the night Haleigh disappeared. The claim has not been independently verified, and no new charges followed.
A five-year-old girl went to bed in her own home on a February night in a quiet Florida river community, and by morning she was gone. The searches, the interviews, and the river dives have not answered the question her family has asked since 3:37 a.m. on 10 February 2009: where is Haleigh Cummings?
What is documented — and what is not
Documented: Haleigh Ann-Marie Cummings, five, was last known to be sleeping in her family’s trailer in Satsuma, Florida, on the evening of 9 February 2009, and was reported missing at 3:37 a.m. on 10 February 2009. Misty Croslin, seventeen, was looking after Haleigh and her three-year-old brother while her father worked a second shift. The rear door was found ajar, propped open by a cinder block, with no sign of forced entry. A statewide AMBER Alert was issued, and a large search found no trace of her. Investigators said Misty failed four polygraph tests and one voice stress test and changed her story multiple times. Ronald married Misty in March 2009 and filed for divorce that October. In January 2010, Misty, Tommy Croslin, and Ronald were arrested on unrelated drug trafficking charges; the others received fifteen years, Misty twenty-five. Ronald was released in October 2022; Misty’s projected release date is 10 June 2031. Neither has ever been charged in Haleigh’s disappearance, and the case remains unsolved and is classified as a homicide.
Unverified or unproven: That anyone in particular took Haleigh from the house — no suspect has been named and no one has been charged. The account by Haleigh’s three-year-old brother of a man dressed in black taking his sister, which investigators cannot weigh with confidence given his age. The accusation by Misty and Tommy Croslin that Joseph Overstreet kidnapped Haleigh and threw her into the St. Johns River — Overstreet denies any involvement, has not been charged or named as a suspect, and the April 2010 river search yielded nothing. Misty’s 2024 claim that she “saw what happened” — not independently verified, with no charges following. Whether the back door was locked that night was never settled.
Sources
- https://charleyproject.org/case/haleigh-ann-marie-cummings
- https://www.caymancompass.com/2009/02/13/5-year-old-florida-girl-likely-abducted/
- https://www.police1.com/investigations/articles/fla-police-search-for-missing-5-year-old-girl-who-disappeared-from-bed-WDG2Ew95gItOI4bB/
- https://cmg-cmg-tv-10050-prod.cdn.arcpublishing.com/news/local/putnam-county/we-do-not-forget-16-years-since-haleigh-cummings-disappearance-putnam-county/6OLLVANIFRACDMEM7UHC7XFVFI/
- https://www.iheart.com/podcast/1119-crime-stories-with-nancy-27910486/episode/ex-stepmom-changes-story-i-saw-what-196640386/