The Disappearance of Ayla Reynolds: A Maine Toddler, No Answers

Reading Time: 5 minutes ·

Ayla Bell Reynolds was born on 4 April 2010 in Waterville, Maine, to Trista Reynolds and Justin DiPietro. She was 20 months old on the night of 16 December 2011, when her father put her to bed at 8 p.m. in the house on Violette Avenue where he was staying with his mother. The next morning, at about 8:50 a.m., DiPietro called 911 to say she was gone. Her bed was empty, and the house was quiet. No one has seen Ayla since.

The case became the largest criminal investigation in Maine’s history and the third-largest search for a missing child the state had ever mounted. Police, game wardens, and FBI agents searched the neighbourhood, lowered nearby streams, and interviewed everyone who had been in the house that night. Within weeks, investigators said they no longer believed Ayla had been abducted. Within months, they said they believed she was dead. But without a body, without a charge, and without an answer, the case has stayed open for more than a decade — a small child’s disappearance that Maine has never been able to close.

A custody fight

Ayla’s parents had a brief relationship, and her early life was unsettled. Her father, Justin DiPietro, accepted paternity only after a DNA test in July 2010, and in December of that year he was ordered to pay back child support. Visits with Ayla were short and supervised at first, then longer. In October 2011, about two months before she vanished, Ayla was placed temporarily in her father’s care by the Maine Department of Health and Human Services, while her mother, Trista, was in a ten-day substance abuse treatment programme.

The arrangement was already fraying. On 15 December 2011, two days before Ayla disappeared, Trista filed paperwork in court to begin the process of obtaining full physical custody of her daughter. Ayla was staying at 29 Violette Avenue, the Waterville home owned by Justin’s mother, Phoebe DiPietro, and on the night of 16 December the house was crowded: Justin, his girlfriend, her child, and his sister were all there at various points. Ayla was put to bed at 8 p.m. By morning, she was gone.

The morning she was gone

DiPietro’s account was that an intruder had taken Ayla in the night. He told police he had found her bed empty when he checked on her in the morning, and he called 911 at about 8:50 a.m. on 17 December. Waterville police arrived quickly, and the search began the same day: officers went door to door, dogs were brought in, and the nearby Messalonskee Stream was searched.

On the second day, a cadaver dog from the Maine State Police was brought to the house. On the third day, the FBI joined the search. A command centre was set up in the Waterville City Council chambers, and the investigation grew into the largest the state had ever seen. Waterville and state police went door to door across the neighbourhood, game wardens searched the woods and the banks of the Messalonskee Stream, and divers checked the water. But the search found no trace of Ayla — no clothing, no footprints, no sign of an intruder — and the focus of the investigation began to shift from the streets outside to the house itself.

In late December, during a search of the house, investigators found blood. It was Ayla’s blood, in several places, including her first-floor bedroom and in the basement bedroom where Justin had slept that night with his girlfriend and her child. Police later said that more than a cupful of her blood had been found, including a fist-sized stain on Justin’s mattress and sheets. On 28 January 2012, police spokesman Steve McCausland said investigators doubted Ayla had been abducted and that DiPietro’s explanation did not hold up. Court documents later showed that investigators had ruled out abduction as early as 2012.

What the police believe

By May 2012, nearly six months after Ayla vanished, authorities said publicly that they believed she was dead, but that they did not believe she had been abducted. They have never named a suspect, and no one has ever been charged in connection with her disappearance. DiPietro has maintained his innocence and says he has no idea where his daughter is. Investigators and Trista Reynolds have both said publicly that they believe DiPietro has not been forthcoming about what he knows.

The case turned on the blood evidence and on the timeline of that night. Police have said the amount of blood found in the house was inconsistent with a minor injury, and that the pattern of where it was found did not fit the account of an intruder taking a sleeping child from her bed. But without a body, prosecutors have never had enough to bring a charge. A missing child, a house full of people, and a father’s account that the police do not believe — it is a combination that has kept the case in a painful middle ground for years.

In 2017, at Trista’s request, a judge declared Ayla legally dead, setting the date of death on or about 17 December 2011. The hearing lasted about half an hour. Detective Jeff Love, head of the Maine Unsolved Homicide Unit, gave evidence, and Trista testified. The declaration allowed the family to settle Ayla’s legal affairs, but it answered nothing about what happened to her.

The civil case

In December 2018, seven years after Ayla disappeared, Trista Reynolds filed a wrongful death lawsuit against Justin DiPietro, alleging that his intentional wrongful actions had caused Ayla’s death. A civil case has a lower burden of proof than a criminal one, and the lawsuit was a way of forcing DiPietro to answer questions under oath about the night his daughter vanished.

In 2022, the lawsuit was expanded to add Justin’s mother, Phoebe DiPietro, and his sister, Elisha DiPietro, as defendants. In September 2024, the case was settled under confidential terms — an insurance settlement, by the reports of it — and the lawsuit was dismissed. The settlement did not end the criminal investigation. Maine State Police have said the investigation remains active, that detectives continue to follow up on any and all leads, and that they remain open to talking to both Trista Reynolds and Justin DiPietro. A police spokesperson confirmed at the time of the settlement that the dismissal of the civil case changed nothing about the criminal file: the investigation goes on, and it will stay open until there is an answer.

For Trista, the settlement closed one chapter without closing the case. For the police, the file remains open. And for Waterville, Ayla’s name is still on the list of the missing — a child who would be a teenager now, whose disappearance is still, officially, unsolved.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Ayla Bell Reynolds, born 4 April 2010 in Waterville, Maine, was last seen when her father, Justin DiPietro, put her to bed at 8 p.m. on 16 December 2011 at 29 Violette Avenue, Waterville. DiPietro called 911 at about 8:50 a.m. on 17 December to report her missing. The search became the largest criminal investigation in Maine’s history. Investigators found Ayla’s blood in several places in the house, including her bedroom and Justin’s basement bedroom. In January 2012 police said they doubted she had been abducted; in May 2012 they said they believed she was dead. She was declared legally dead on 17 May 2017, with the date of death recorded as on or about 17 December 2011. Trista Reynolds filed a wrongful death suit in December 2018, expanded in 2022 to include Phoebe and Elisha DiPietro; it was settled under confidential terms in September 2024. No one has been charged, and the criminal investigation remains active.

Unverified or unproven: What happened to Ayla between 8 p.m. on 16 December and the 911 call the next morning is unknown. DiPietro’s account — that an intruder took her — is his claim; police have said they do not believe it, but they have not publicly presented a complete alternative account, and no one has been charged. Any claim that a specific person in the house that night caused Ayla’s death is an allegation, not a finding. The contents of the settled civil case are confidential, and no conclusion about fault can be drawn from the settlement itself.

Sources

Leave a Comment