In the early 1970s, Rochester, New York, was a proud industrial city on Lake Ontario, a place where children still ran errands alone and neighbours knew each other’s names. Between November 1971 and November 1973, three young girls from the city were abducted and killed, each in a way that was chillingly similar to the others. All three were aged 10 or 11. All three had been sexually assaulted and strangled. And all three shared a strange coincidence that gave the case its name: each girl’s first name and surname began with the same letter, and her body was found in a town that began with that same letter.
The case is known as the Alphabet Murders, or the Double Initial Murders. More than fifty years later, it remains unsolved. No one has ever been charged with any of the three killings, and investigators have never been able to prove, to a legal standard, that the three murders were committed by the same person.
Carmen Colón
The first victim was Carmen Colón, aged 10, a fifth-grader from a Puerto Rican family who lived on Conkey Avenue in Rochester. On the afternoon of 16 November 1971, her grandmother asked her to go to a nearby pharmacy to collect a prescription. Carmen left home at about half past three and was seen at the store, but she never came home. Two days later, on 18 November, her body was found in a gully beside a road off Route 251 near Churchville, about 12 to 15 miles from her neighbourhood. She had been sexually assaulted and strangled.
Police interviewed hundreds of people, but the investigation stalled. Without DNA technology, the biological evidence recovered at the scene could not be matched to anyone. At the time, her death was treated as a single, terrible crime, not as the beginning of a series.
Wanda Walkowicz
Almost a year and a half later, on 2 April 1973, an 11-year-old girl named Wanda Walkowicz vanished in similar circumstances. She had been sent on an errand by her mother to a delicatessen near her home in the Ridgemont neighbourhood, and was last seen at about five o’clock that evening. Witnesses reported seeing her get into a large sedan, possibly brown or tan. The next day, 3 April, her body was found beside an access road off Route 104 in Webster, a town east of Rochester. Like Carmen, she had been sexually assaulted and strangled.
It was only with Wanda’s death that the pattern began to emerge. Wanda Walkowicz — W.W. — found in Webster. Carmen Colón — C.C. — found in Churchville. Two girls, two matching sets of initials, two towns that matched. Police began to consider that the same person might be responsible for both killings, though at first they were cautious about saying so publicly.
Michelle Maenza
The third victim was Michelle Maenza, aged 11, a shy and artistic girl who was last seen on 26 November 1973, at about twenty past three in the afternoon, after leaving school. She had gone to a shopping plaza on Culver Road to retrieve a purse her mother had left at a store. She never returned home. Two days later, on 28 November, her body was found in a ditch near State Route 31 in Macedon, about 15 miles from Rochester. She, too, had been sexually assaulted and strangled.
With Michelle Maenza — M.M. — found in Macedon, the pattern was complete. The local newspaper, the Democrat and Chronicle, first mentioned the “Double Initial” theory on 28 November 1973, the day her body was found. The name stuck, and the case became known across the country as the Alphabet Murders.
The suspects who were never charged
Over the years, investigators interviewed more than 800 suspects, and several men were examined closely. The most prominent was Dennis Termini, a 25-year-old Rochester firefighter who was also a prolific serial sexual offender, known as the “Garage Rapist”, who had carried out at least 14 sexual assaults on teenage girls in the Rochester area between 1971 and 1973. Termini died by suicide in January 1974 after a police pursuit following another attempted abduction, before he could be fully questioned. In January 2007, his body was exhumed so that his DNA could be compared with the semen sample recovered from Wanda Walkowicz’s body. The DNA did not match. No physical evidence from the Colón or Maenza cases survived for comparison.
Another suspect was Kenneth Bianchi, who lived in Rochester during the murders and worked as an ice-cream vendor in areas connected with some of the cases. Bianchi later became one of the two men responsible for the Hillside Strangler murders in California in 1977 and 1978. He denied any involvement in the Rochester killings, was never charged with them, and his DNA also did not match the sample from Wanda Walkowicz’s case.
A third man, Joseph Naso, was arrested in Nevada in April 2011 for the murders of four women in California between 1977 and 1994, all of whom had first and last names beginning with the same letter — one of them was even named Carmen Colon. Naso was a New York native who had lived in Rochester in the early 1970s. Investigators examined him as a person of interest, but DNA testing confirmed that his DNA did not match the sample from Wanda Walkowicz, and he was never charged with the Rochester murders.
Why the case is still open
In 2007, a task force reviewed the cold-case files using updated forensic methods, but the DNA testing produced no match in the available databases. In 2011, the Rochester Police Department said it was continuing to pursue leads, with assistance from the FBI’s Behavioral Analysis Unit. The New York State Police have stated that the three homicides have never been officially proven to be connected, and the possibility that more than one offender was responsible has never been eliminated.
What is certain is that three girls — Carmen, Wanda and Michelle — were taken from their families in the space of two years, and that the person or people who killed them were never brought to justice. Their families have waited more than half a century. The case remains open, and the Rochester Police Department continues to ask anyone with information to come forward.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Carmen Colón, 10, disappeared on 16 November 1971 while running an errand in Rochester, and her body was found on 18 November near Churchville; she had been sexually assaulted and strangled. Wanda Walkowicz, 11, disappeared on 2 April 1973, and her body was found on 3 April near Route 104 in Webster; she had been sexually assaulted and strangled. Michelle Maenza, 11, disappeared on 26 November 1973, and her body was found on 28 November in Macedon; she had been sexually assaulted and strangled. In each case the victim’s initials matched the town where her body was found. No one has ever been charged. Dennis Termini, Kenneth Bianchi and Joseph Naso were all investigated; Termini’s DNA, obtained by exhumation in 2007, did not match the biological sample from Walkowicz’s case, and neither Bianchi’s nor Naso’s DNA matched it either. No usable DNA survives from the Colón or Maenza cases.
Disputed or unverified: It has never been proven that the three murders were committed by the same person, and New York State Police have said the connection has never been officially established; the double-initial pattern may be coincidence rather than design. The spelling of the third victim’s first name appears in sources as both “Michelle” and “Michele”; this article uses “Michelle”, the spelling used by Wikipedia and the New York State Police.