Dorothy Jane Scott: The Mother Who Vanished from a Hospital Car Park

Reading Time: 5 minutes ·

Dorothy Jane Scott was 32 years old, a single mother and a secretary in Anaheim, California, when she disappeared on the night of 28 May 1980. She had spent the evening doing a kindness for a co-worker — driving him to a hospital emergency room — and she vanished in the minutes between leaving the waiting room and fetching her car. Her remains were not identified until four years later. No one has ever been arrested in her case.

It is a case defined by two things: a series of anonymous telephone calls that began months before she disappeared, and a second series of calls that continued for years after, from a man who claimed to have killed her. Investigators believe the caller was the person responsible for her death. That belief has never been tested in court, because the caller has never been identified.

Dorothy’s life

Dorothy Jane Scott was born on 23 April 1948. She lived in Stanton, California, about twenty-four miles south-east of Los Angeles, with her aunt and her four-year-old son, Shanti. She worked as a secretary for two jointly owned stores in Anaheim — a custom printing business that also sold psychedelic-era goods such as lava lamps and beads. Her parents, Jacob and Vera Scott, lived nearby and helped care for Shanti.

By all accounts, Dorothy was a devoted mother whose life centred on her son and her work. The only shadow over her life in early 1980 was the telephone.

The calls before May 1980

For several months before her disappearance, Dorothy had been receiving anonymous telephone calls at work from an unidentified man. According to her family and co-workers, the caller threatened her, telling her that when he got her alone he would harm her so badly that no one would ever find her. The exact wording of the threats comes from family accounts reported in the press; the calls themselves were not recorded.

On one occasion, Dorothy was reportedly told by a caller to look outside, where she found a dead rose left on the windshield of her car. That detail comes from later reporting of the family’s account and has not been independently verified. What is documented is that Dorothy was frightened enough to tell her family and colleagues about the calls.

The night of 28 May 1980

On the evening of 28 May 1980, Dorothy attended an employee meeting at work at about 9:00 p.m. During the meeting, her co-worker Conrad Bostron said he was feeling unwell and showed a red mark on his arm. Dorothy and another co-worker, Pam Head, offered to drive him to the emergency room at UC Irvine Medical Center in Orange. The three left the office at about 8:30 p.m. in Dorothy’s white 1973 Toyota station wagon, according to some accounts — the reported times for the meeting and the departure vary slightly between sources.

At the hospital, medical staff determined that Bostron had suffered a black widow spider bite and treated him. Head and Dorothy waited in the emergency room waiting area. At about 11:00 p.m., Bostron was ready to leave. Dorothy said she would go and fetch the car from the car park and meet them at the entrance.

Head and Bostron waited outside. Then they saw Dorothy’s station wagon speeding towards them, its headlights so bright they could not see the driver clearly. They waved their arms to attract the driver’s attention, but the car sped past them, turned sharply out of the car park and drove away. Dorothy did not return. Whether Dorothy herself was driving, or someone else was driving her car, has never been established.

When Dorothy did not come home that night to collect her son, her parents reported her missing.

The burnt-out car

In the early hours of 29 May, Dorothy’s station wagon was found burning in an alley in Santa Ana, about ten miles from the hospital, at about 4:30 a.m. according to some accounts and about 5:00 a.m. according to others. The car was in the 800 block of South Townsend, in one account; another account places an abandoned station wagon, with Dorothy’s purse and belongings still inside and its doors locked, at the intersection of La Palma Avenue and Ball Road, roughly four miles from the hospital, at about 3:30 a.m. The two accounts may describe different stages of the same night, or they may reflect the confusion of the early investigation. The record does not settle which is correct, and this article does not present either location or time as certain.

What is not in dispute is that the car was found burnt out that morning, and that Dorothy was not in it.

The caller who claimed to have killed her

On 12 June 1980, a man telephoned the front desk of the Orange County Register, the local newspaper, which had reported Dorothy’s disappearance that day. He claimed that he had killed Dorothy. Police believe the caller was the person responsible for her death — a belief based on the investigation, not a proven fact, since the caller was never identified and never charged.

Over the following years, the caller telephoned Dorothy’s parents repeatedly, taunting them with claims about what he had done. Her parents kept the details of the calls private at the request of investigators. The calls eventually stopped. No recording of the caller has ever been publicly identified, and no voice match has ever been made.

The remains found in 1984

On 6 August 1984, a construction worker preparing to dig for cables near Santa Ana Canyon Road in Anaheim Hills discovered human bones lying beside dog bones, about thirty feet from the road. A woman’s wristwatch and a turquoise ring were found with the remains. On 14 August, the bones were identified as Dorothy Jane Scott’s by dental records. An autopsy could not determine the cause of death, because of the condition of the remains.

Dorothy’s mother said the watch had stopped at 12:30 a.m. on 29 May — about an hour after Head and Bostron had last seen the station wagon. That is the family’s account of what the watch showed; it has not been independently verified as evidence of the time of death, and the cause of death remains undetermined.

What the record shows

The documented record is this: Dorothy Jane Scott, 32, a single mother from Stanton, California, disappeared on the night of 28–29 May 1980 after driving two co-workers to UC Irvine Medical Center in Orange. Her white 1973 Toyota station wagon was seen speeding out of the hospital car park without stopping for her colleagues, and was found burnt out in Santa Ana in the early hours of the morning. She had received threatening anonymous calls for months beforehand, and an unidentified man later telephoned a newspaper and her family claiming to have killed her. Her remains were found on 6 August 1984 near Santa Ana Canyon Road and identified by dental records on 14 August; the cause of death could not be determined. No arrests have been made, and the Orange County Sheriff’s Department continues to list the case as an active cold-case investigation.

The identity of the caller, and of the person who took Dorothy Scott that night, remains unknown. Anyone with information is asked to contact the Orange County Sheriff’s Department.

Sources

Leave a Comment