On 21 November 1983, fifteen-year-old Lynda Mann took a shortcut home from a friend’s house in Narborough, a quiet village in Leicestershire. She never arrived. Her body was found near a footpath, and the forensic samples taken from it pointed to a killer with type A blood and an enzyme profile shared by only ten per cent of men — but the police had no suspect. Almost three years later, on 31 July 1986, fifteen-year-old Dawn Ashworth was murdered in almost identical circumstances in the neighbouring village of Enderby. The two cases were solved not by a witness or a confession, but by a science that had barely existed when Lynda Mann died: DNA fingerprinting. It first cleared an innocent man who had confessed to one of the murders, and then it caught the real killer, Colin Pitchfork, the first person in the world to be convicted of murder on the strength of DNA evidence.
Lynda Mann was 15. On the evening of 21 November 1983 she left a friend’s house in Narborough and took a shortcut along Forest Road, near the footpath known as the Black Pad. She was raped and strangled. Dawn Ashworth was also 15. On 31 July 1986 she left home to visit a friend and entered a footpath to Enderby called Ten Pound Lane, a few hundred yards from where Lynda had been killed. She too was raped and strangled. The similarities were obvious, and the police were convinced the same man had killed both girls. But the forensic evidence of the time could only narrow the killer to a blood group and an enzyme type, and that was not enough to name anyone.
The Science That Changed Everything
In 1984, at the University of Leicester, geneticist Alec Jeffreys and his team developed DNA profiling — a technique that could produce a unique genetic “fingerprint” from a biological sample. On 10 September 1984, Jeffreys produced the first DNA fingerprint. Within two years, the technique was applied to the Narborough and Enderby murders, and it did two things at once.
First, it cleared a suspect. Richard Buckland, a 17-year-old local youth, had confessed to Dawn Ashworth’s murder and had been charged on 10 August 1986. When Jeffreys compared the semen samples from both victims against Buckland’s blood, the DNA proved conclusively that the same man had killed both girls — but that the man was not Buckland. On 21 November 1986, after three months in custody, Buckland was released. He was the first suspect in the world to be cleared by DNA profiling.
Second, it gave the police a way to find the killer. In early 1987, the police asked every local man between the ages of 16 and 34 to give a blood sample voluntarily for DNA testing — the first mass DNA screening in history. More than four thousand men came forward. One of them did not: Colin Pitchfork, a local bakery worker. Instead, he persuaded a colleague, Ian Kelly, to give blood in his place. Months later, Pitchfork was overheard in a pub boasting about the deception, and a listener reported him to the police.
Arrest, Conviction and Parole
Pitchfork was arrested on 19 September 1987. A new blood sample was taken and sent for DNA analysis. The result was unambiguous: his genetic profile matched the samples recovered from both Lynda Mann and Dawn Ashworth. Confronted with the evidence, he confessed to both murders. On 22 January 1988, at Leicester Crown Court, he pleaded guilty to the two murders, as well as to the rapes and another sexual assault, and was sentenced to life imprisonment with a minimum term of thirty years. An appeal later reduced that minimum to twenty-eight years. He was the first person ever convicted of murder on the strength of DNA profiling, and the case made the technique a standard tool of criminal investigation around the world.
His minimum term expired in 2016, but a life sentence does not end when the minimum term expires — release depends on the Parole Board. In June 2021 the Board granted his release, and on 1 September 2021 he was freed on licence. Just over two months later, on 19 November 2021, he was recalled to prison for breaching his licence conditions by approaching young women in the street. In June 2023 the Parole Board approved his release a second time, but after an intervention by the Lord Chancellor the Board reviewed its decision and decided not to release him. In December 2023 parole was denied, and in 2025 the Parole Board refused release again, finding that he continued to pose a risk. He remains in a closed prison, most recently reported at HMP The Verne in Portland, Dorset.
What Is Documented — and What Is Not
Documented: Lynda Mann, 15, was murdered on 21 November 1983 near the Black Pad footpath in Narborough, Leicestershire. Dawn Ashworth, 15, was murdered on 31 July 1986 on Ten Pound Lane in Enderby. Both girls were raped and strangled. Alec Jeffreys developed DNA profiling at the University of Leicester, producing the first DNA fingerprint on 10 September 1984. Richard Buckland, 17, confessed to Ashworth’s murder and was charged on 10 August 1986; DNA evidence proved he was not the killer, and he was released on 21 November 1986, the first suspect cleared by DNA profiling. In early 1987 police carried out the first mass DNA screening, asking local men aged 16 to 34 to give blood samples. Colin Pitchfork avoided testing by persuading a colleague, Ian Kelly, to give blood for him, and was reported after boasting about it in a pub. Pitchfork was arrested on 19 September 1987, pleaded guilty on 22 January 1988 at Leicester Crown Court, and was sentenced to life imprisonment with a 30-year minimum term, later reduced to 28 years on appeal. He was released on licence on 1 September 2021 and recalled to prison on 19 November 2021 for breaching his licence conditions. A second parole grant in June 2023 was reversed on review, parole was denied in December 2023, and in 2025 the Parole Board refused release again.
Not documented / unverified: Some sources spell Richard Buckland’s surname as “Burkland”; the widely used spelling is Buckland. The number of men who gave blood samples in the 1987 screening is reported as more than four thousand, with exact figures varying between accounts. Some reports describe Pitchfork as having been “left in charge of his baby son” on the evening of Lynda Mann’s murder, a detail drawn from accounts of his confession rather than from independent evidence. The precise date of the appeal that reduced his minimum term to 28 years is given as 2009 in most accounts. The Parole Board’s most recent refusal of release was published in November 2025; the timing of his next review has not been fixed.