Aileen Wuornos: The Woman Who Killed on Florida’s Highways

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Between November 1989 and November 1990, seven men were found dead along the highways of central Florida. All had been shot, and all had been robbed. The killer was Aileen Wuornos, a 34-year-old sex worker who said she had acted in self-defence against men who had attacked her. The jury that tried her for the first murder did not believe her. She was sentenced to death, and in 2002 she became the first woman executed in Florida in more than fifty years.

This article does not describe her crimes in detail. The record is established; the focus here is on how she was caught, tried and punished, and on the questions her case raised.

A hard life

Wuornos was born in 1956 in Rochester, Michigan, and had a childhood marked by abandonment and abuse. Her mother left when she was an infant, and she was raised by her grandparents. She left home as a teenager, lived on the streets, and by her twenties was working as a sex worker along the highways of Florida. She had a history of arrests for theft, forgery and assault, and a brief, unhappy marriage that ended in divorce.

In 1986, she met Tyria Moore, a hotel maid, at a Daytona Beach bar. The two became lovers and lived together, moving between motels in central Florida. Moore later testified that Wuornos supported them both through sex work, and that Wuornos had told her about the killings.

The killings and the arrest

The first victim was Richard Mallory, a 51-year-old electronics shop owner, whose body was found in December 1989 in a wooded area near Daytona Beach. Over the following eleven months, six more men were found dead in similar circumstances along the highways of Volusia, Marion, Citrus, Pasco and Dixie counties. All had been shot with a .22-calibre pistol, and all had been robbed.

The investigation turned on two things: a car and a pawn ticket. In July 1990, Wuornos and Moore were involved in a car accident in a vehicle belonging to one of the victims, Peter Siems, whose body was never found. Later, Wuornos pawned items belonging to the victims, leaving a thumbprint on a pawn ticket. Police identified her, and Moore — who had left Florida — agreed to cooperate. In a series of recorded telephone calls, Moore encouraged Wuornos to talk, and Wuornos admitted to the killings, saying she had acted in self-defence.

Wuornos was arrested in January 1991 at a bar in Port Orange, Florida. She confessed to the killings, maintaining that each man had attacked or tried to rape her and that she had shot them to protect herself.

The trial

Wuornos was tried first for the murder of Richard Mallory, in January 1992 in Daytona Beach. The prosecution argued that the killing was robbery, not self-defence: Mallory’s car and belongings had been taken, and Wuornos had pawned his property. The defence argued that Mallory had a history of sexual violence — he had previously been convicted of attempted rape — and that Wuornos had reason to fear him. The judge did not allow the jury to hear most of the evidence about Mallory’s past.

On 27 January 1992, the jury found Wuornos guilty of first-degree murder. She was sentenced to death. Over the following months, she pleaded guilty to five more murders and no contest to a sixth, receiving five more death sentences. She later withdrew her self-defence claim, saying she wanted to “get right with God”, and asked that her appeals be stopped.

The execution

Wuornos was executed by lethal injection at Florida State Prison on 9 October 2002, aged 46. Her last words, as recorded, were: “I’d just like to say I’m sailing with the Rock, and I’ll be back, like Independence Day, with Jesus, June 6, like the movie, big mothership and all. I’ll be back.”

Her case has been the subject of films, documentaries and debate. The 2003 film Monster, starring Charlize Theron, portrayed her sympathetically and won Theron an Academy Award. Legal scholars and advocates have argued that her background of abuse, her mental health — she was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder and antisocial personality disorder — and the limits placed on her defence at trial raise questions about whether she received a fair hearing. Others argue that the evidence of robbery, and the pattern of seven killings, made her guilt clear.

What the record shows

  • Aileen Wuornos was born in Rochester, Michigan, in 1956. She left home as a teenager and worked as a sex worker along Florida’s highways.
  • Between November 1989 and November 1990, seven men were killed in central Florida. All were shot with a .22-calibre pistol and robbed. The first victim was Richard Mallory, 51.
  • Wuornos was identified through a pawn ticket bearing her thumbprint and through a car belonging to victim Peter Siems. Her partner Tyria Moore cooperated with police in recorded telephone calls.
  • Wuornos was arrested in January 1991 and confessed, maintaining she had acted in self-defence. She was tried for Mallory’s murder in January 1992, convicted of first-degree murder on 27 January 1992, and sentenced to death.
  • She later pleaded guilty to five more murders and no contest to a sixth, receiving five further death sentences. She was executed by lethal injection on 9 October 2002, aged 46.
  • Disputed/unverified: Wuornos’s claim of self-defence was rejected by the jury, but the evidence about Mallory’s history of sexual violence was largely excluded from the trial, and the fairness of that exclusion remains debated. Her later statements withdrawing the self-defence claim were made while she was, by her own lawyers’ account, mentally unstable.
  • Unresolved: The body of Peter Siems was never found, and Wuornos was never tried for his killing.

Sources

Leave a Comment