Adam Worth: The Napoleon of Crime

Reading Time: 6 minutes ·

For more than twenty years, the most successful criminal in the English-speaking world lived in plain sight. He kept a flat in Mayfair and was received in London’s best drawing rooms as Henry Judson Raymond, a wealthy American gentleman. The police knew his real name — Adam Worth — and knew he was running an international network of thieves, forgers and burglars. What they could not do was prove it.

Worth’s career ran from the pickpocket gangs of Civil War-era New York to the diamond trade of South Africa, and its centrepiece was the theft of Thomas Gainsborough’s portrait of Georgiana, Duchess of Devonshire, in 1876 — a painting he kept for a quarter of a century, not to sell, but because he loved it.

A poor boy who disappeared

Adam Worth was born in about 1844, into a poor Jewish family in Germany. His original surname may have been Werth. When he was five, his family emigrated to the United States and settled in Cambridge, Massachusetts, where his father worked as a tailor. In 1854, at about ten years old, Worth ran away from home, moving first to Boston and then, in 1860, to New York City.

When the American Civil War broke out in 1861, Worth was seventeen. He lied about his age and enlisted in the Union army, and was wounded at the Second Battle of Bull Run on 30 August 1862. Taken to a hospital in Georgetown, Washington, D.C., he learned that he had been listed as killed in action — and instead of correcting the record, he simply walked away. With his official death on the record, he became a bounty jumper: enlisting in regiments under assumed names, collecting the enlistment bounty, and then deserting. When the Pinkerton Detective Agency began tracking men using this method, he fled New York for Portsmouth in England.

From pickpocket to bank robber

After the war, Worth returned to New York and became a pickpocket, then founded his own gang and began to organise robberies. Caught stealing the cash box of an Adams Express wagon, he was sentenced to three years in Sing Sing prison. He escaped, and resumed his criminal career.

By the mid-1860s, Worth was working for Fredericka “Marm” Mandelbaum, New York’s most prominent fence and criminal organiser. With her backing, he expanded into bank and store robberies from about 1866. In 1869, he helped Mandelbaum break the safecracker Charley Bullard out of the White Plains Jail — through a tunnel. With Bullard, he robbed the vault of the Boylston National Bank in Boston on 20 November 1869, again through a tunnel, dug from a neighbouring shop. The bank alerted the Pinkertons, who tracked the trunks the pair had used to ship the loot to New York, and Worth decided to move to Europe with Bullard.

Liverpool, Paris and the American Bar

Bullard and Worth went first to Liverpool. Bullard took the identity of “Charles H. Wells”, a Texas oilman. Worth became the financier “Henry Judson Raymond”, a name borrowed from the late founder and editor of The New York Times. The two men competed for the favours of a barmaid named Kitty Flynn, who eventually learned their true identities. She became Bullard’s wife, but remained close to Worth; the paternity of her two daughters is uncertain.

Together, the three moved to Paris in 1871, where Worth and his associates founded an “American Bar” — a restaurant and bar on the ground floor, and an illegal gambling den on the upper floor. The Paris police raided the bar numerous times, and eventually the Bullards and Worth abandoned it after one last fraud, defrauding a diamond dealer, and moved to London.

The master criminal of London

In England, Worth and his associates bought Western Lodge at Clapham Common, and he leased an apartment in Mayfair. He formed his own criminal network, organising major robberies and burglaries through intermediaries. Those who worked in his schemes never knew his name, and he insisted that his subordinates not use violence.

Eventually, Scotland Yard learned of Worth’s network, though at first they were unable to prove anything. Inspector John Shore made Worth’s capture his personal mission. But the network began to fray: his brother John was arrested in Paris for cashing a forged cheque, four associates were arrested in Istanbul, and Bullard, drinking heavily, grew violent and left for New York, followed soon afterwards by Kitty.

The theft of the Duchess

In 1876, Worth committed the crime that made him famous. Thomas Gainsborough’s portrait of Georgiana Cavendish, Duchess of Devonshire, painted around 1787, had recently resurfaced after disappearing for some fifty years, and the dealer William Agnew had bought it at auction for 10,000 guineas. Agnew had agreed to sell it to the American financier Junius Morgan. But before Morgan could take possession, Worth stole the painting from the London gallery of Thomas Agnew & Sons, on the night of 25 May 1876, with the help of two associates, cutting the canvas from its frame.

Worth liked the painting and did not try to sell it. One of his accomplices, arrested in America, talked to the Pinkertons, who alerted Scotland Yard. Still, the police could not prove anything.

Worth kept the painting with him for twenty-five years — by one biographical account, rolled up in the false bottom of his trunk when he travelled, and stretched out flat beneath his mattress in London. Whether he kept it out of love for the painting or because it was simply too famous to sell, the Duchess stayed with him.

Diamonds, marriage and the fall

Worth travelled to South Africa, where he stole a reported $500,000 worth of uncut diamonds, and back in London founded a diamond firm that undercut its competitors. In the 1880s, he married Louise Margaret Boljahn, while still using the name Henry Raymond. They had a son, Henry, and a daughter, Beatrice; it is possible that his wife did not know his real identity.

In 1892, Worth visited Belgium, where Bullard was in jail. On 5 October, he improvised a robbery of a money delivery cart in Liège with two untried associates. The robbery went badly, and the police captured Worth on the spot. It was a clumsy, opportunistic crime — the kind of job Worth had spent his whole career avoiding — and it undid him. In jail, Worth refused to identify himself, but the Belgian police made inquiries abroad, and both the New York Police Department and Scotland Yard identified him.

Trial, prison and last years

Worth’s trial took place on 20 March 1893. He denied the crimes attributed to him, saying the Liège robbery had been a stupid act committed out of a need for money and that his wealth had come from legal gambling. He was sentenced to seven years and sent to Leuven Central Prison in Belgium.

Released early for good behaviour in 1897, Worth learned that his wife had been committed to an asylum and his children were in the care of his brother John in the United States. He returned to London and stole £4,000 from a diamond shop to raise funds. When he visited his wife in the asylum, she barely recognised him. He travelled to New York, visited his children, and told William Pinkerton the story of his life in great detail.

Through Pinkerton, Worth arranged the return of the Duchess of Devonshire painting to Agnew & Sons in return for $25,000. The portrait and the payment were exchanged in Chicago on 28 March 1901 — twenty-five years after the theft. His son later became a career Pinkerton detective — the thief’s son joining the very agency that had hunted his father.

Worth died on 8 January 1902 in London. He was buried in Highgate Cemetery in a common grave under the name of “Henry J. Raymond”.

The shadow of Moriarty

Worth’s most lasting legacy may be fictional. According to Vincent Starrett, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle used Worth as the prototype for Professor Moriarty, Sherlock Holmes’s criminal mastermind — “the Napoleon of crime”, the same title Scotland Yard had given Worth.

It is a neat story, and it may be true. But it rests on second-hand testimony: a conversation reported by one man about what Doyle supposedly told another, and Doyle never confirmed it in print. Still, the comparison fits the facts. Worth was short, clever, and organised; he planned crimes from a distance and let others carry them out; he lived a double life, respected in society and feared in the underworld.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Worth was born in about 1844 in Germany, emigrated to the United States as a child, and settled with his family in Cambridge, Massachusetts. He enlisted in the Union army, was wounded at the Second Battle of Bull Run on 30 August 1862, and left the army after being listed as killed in action. He became a bounty jumper, then a pickpocket and organiser of robberies in New York. With Charley Bullard, he robbed the Boylston National Bank in Boston on 20 November 1869. He lived in Liverpool, Paris and London as Henry Judson Raymond and organised a criminal network in London through intermediaries. On the night of 25 May 1876, he stole Gainsborough’s portrait of Georgiana, Duchess of Devonshire, from the gallery of Thomas Agnew & Sons in London. On 5 October 1892, he was captured during a robbery of a money delivery cart in Liège, Belgium, tried on 20 March 1893, sentenced to seven years for robbery, and imprisoned at Leuven Central Prison. Released early in 1897, he arranged through William Pinkerton the return of the painting to Agnew & Sons for $25,000; the exchange took place in Chicago on 28 March 1901. He died on 8 January 1902 in London and was buried in Highgate Cemetery under the name “Henry J. Raymond”.

Unverified or unproven: That Sir Arthur Conan Doyle based Professor Moriarty on Worth — the claim rests on Vincent Starrett’s account of a conversation reported second-hand, and Doyle never confirmed it in print. That Worth kept the canvas under his mattress and carried it in a false-bottomed trunk — these details come from later biographical accounts and cannot be independently verified. The paternity of Kitty Flynn’s daughters is uncertain, whether Worth’s wife Louise knew his real identity is not documented, and the reported $500,000 value of the uncut diamonds stolen in South Africa comes from accounts of his career rather than a court record.

Sources

Leave a Comment