The Trial of the Gunpowder Plotters

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

In the early hours of 5 November 1605, a man was found in a cellar beneath the House of Lords, guarding thirty-six barrels of gunpowder. His name was Guy Fawkes, and he was waiting to blow up Parliament, the King, and every lord and member of Parliament gathered for the State Opening. He was arrested before he could strike a match. Three months later, on 27 January 1606, Fawkes and seven fellow conspirators stood trial for high treason in Westminster Hall. All eight were convicted, and all eight were executed within four days. The plot failed, but its name — and the face of Guy Fawkes — has been remembered in England ever since.

The plot

The plot was the work of English Catholics who believed that King James I, who had taken the throne in 1603, would never end the persecution of their faith. Its leader was Robert Catesby, a wealthy Warwickshire gentleman. With him were twelve others, among them Thomas Percy, a relative of the Earl of Northumberland; Thomas Wintour and his brother Robert; John Grant; Ambrose Rookwood; Robert Keyes; Everard Digby; and Guy Fawkes, a soldier from York who had fought for Spain in the Netherlands and knew how to handle explosives.

Their plan was simple and terrible. They leased a cellar beneath the House of Lords and filled it with gunpowder. When the King opened Parliament on 5 November 1605, Fawkes would light the fuse and escape by boat to the Continent, while the other conspirators seized the King’s nine-year-old daughter, Princess Elizabeth, and raised her as a Catholic queen. The explosion would have killed the King, his eldest son, the Lords, the Commons, and the bishops — the whole government of England in a single blast.

The letter

The plot was undone by a letter. On 26 October 1605, Lord Monteagle, a Catholic peer, received an anonymous note warning him not to attend the opening of Parliament, “for though there be no appearance of any stir, yet I say they shall receive a terrible blow this Parliament”. Monteagle showed the letter to Robert Cecil, the King’s chief minister, who ordered the cellars searched.

The first search, on the afternoon of 4 November, found nothing but a tall man standing watch over a pile of firewood — Fawkes, posing as a servant named John Johnson. Suspicious, the searchers returned after midnight. This time they lifted the firewood and found the barrels. Fawkes was arrested on the spot, carrying matches, touchwood and a watch. He refused at first to give his real name, but under torture — authorised by the King himself — he confessed within days and named his fellow conspirators.

Catesby and the others had already fled London. On 8 November, at Holbeche House in Staffordshire, they were cornered by the Sheriff of Worcestershire and his men. In the shootout that followed, Catesby and Thomas Percy were killed. John and Christopher Wright died with them. The rest were captured and brought back to London in chains.

The trial

The trial took place on 27 January 1606 in Westminster Hall, before the Lord Chief Justice, Sir John Popham, and a panel of commissioners. The Attorney General, Sir Edward Coke, prosecuted. Eight men stood in the dock: Fawkes, Thomas Wintour, Robert Wintour, John Grant, Ambrose Rookwood, Robert Keyes, Thomas Bates — Catesby’s servant — and Everard Digby. All pleaded not guilty, except Digby, who admitted the charge and asked only for mercy for his family. Fawkes, who had confessed under torture, now pleaded not guilty to the indictment as read.

The evidence was overwhelming. The gunpowder was in the cellar, the letters and confessions were in the Crown’s hands, and the surviving conspirators had been caught with arms in their possession. Coke’s speech was a masterpiece of prosecution, and the jury needed little time. All eight were found guilty of high treason, and all were sentenced to be hanged, drawn and quartered — the punishment reserved for traitors.

The executions

The sentences were carried out in two groups. On 30 January 1606, Digby, Robert Wintour, John Grant and Thomas Bates were executed at St Paul’s Churchyard in London. The next day, 31 January, Fawkes, Thomas Wintour, Ambrose Rookwood and Robert Keyes were taken to Old Palace Yard at Westminster, opposite the Parliament they had tried to destroy.

Fawkes was the last to mount the scaffold. Weakened by torture and illness, he climbed the ladder with help, said a few words, and then — rather than wait for the hangman — jumped from the ladder and broke his neck. He died instantly, spared the rest of the sentence. His body was quartered anyway, as the law required, and the quarters of the conspirators were displayed on the gates of London as a warning.

What the plot left behind

Parliament passed a law making 5 November a day of public thanksgiving, and for centuries afterwards English towns marked the date with bonfires and the burning of effigies of Fawkes. The celebration, Guy Fawkes Night, is still held every year, though few who light the bonfires remember the thirteen men behind the plot, or that Fawkes was not even its leader. That was Catesby, who died at Holbeche House and was never tried at all.

The trial itself set a pattern that would be followed for centuries: a treason trial as a public spectacle, with the evidence laid out before the nation and the verdict never in doubt. It also left one lasting curiosity. The cellar in which the gunpowder was found was searched every year before the State Opening of Parliament, a ceremony that continues to this day.

What is documented — and what is not

Documented: Thirteen men conspired to blow up Parliament on 5 November 1605; thirty-six barrels of gunpowder were found in a cellar under the House of Lords. Guy Fawkes was arrested in the cellar in the early hours of 5 November, confessed under torture, and named his fellow conspirators. Catesby, Thomas Percy and the Wright brothers were killed at Holbeche House on 8 November 1605. Eight men were tried for high treason at Westminster Hall on 27 January 1606 and all were convicted; four were executed on 30 January and four on 31 January 1606. Fawkes broke his neck jumping from the scaffold.

Unverified or unproven: Who wrote the letter to Lord Monteagle — it was anonymous, and historians still debate whether it came from one of the plotters, from Monteagle himself, or from the government. Whether the government knew of the plot before the letter arrived — some historians have argued that Cecil allowed the plot to run so that it could be exposed at the last moment, but there is no proof. The exact number of barrels — thirty-six is the figure given in the trial records, though some accounts say thirty-five or thirty-seven.

Sources

Leave a Comment