The JonBenét Ramsey Case, 1996: A Child, a House, and an Investigation That Went Wrong

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

The JonBenét Ramsey Case, 1996: A Child, a House, and an Investigation That Went Wrong

JonBenét Patricia Ramsey was six years old. She was born on 6 August 1990, and she lived with her parents, John and Patsy Ramsey, and her nine-year-old brother, Burke, at 755 15th Street in Boulder, Colorado. Her father was the founding president of Access Graphics, a computer-distribution company he had sold to Lockheed Martin in 1991. On the evening of Christmas Day 1996, the family attended a Christmas party and returned home at about 10 p.m.

What happened that night has never been established in a court of law. What is documented is the morning that followed, and the investigation that followed that — an investigation that, by wide agreement, was compromised from its first hours.

The morning of 26 December 1996

Early on the morning of 26 December, Patsy Ramsey found a long handwritten ransom note on a staircase. It was addressed to John, it demanded $118,000, and it said he would be contacted between 8 a.m. and 10 a.m. Patsy telephoned the police at 5:52 a.m. Two officers arrived within three minutes. They conducted a cursory search of the house but did not find any sign of forced entry, and they did not secure the house as a crime scene.

For several hours, law enforcement believed JonBenét had been kidnapped. Friends and family moved through the house during the morning. At about 1 p.m., police began a more thorough search of the home, and shortly afterwards John Ramsey and a friend, Fleet White, were asked to search the house. John Ramsey found his daughter’s body in a small basement storage room.

The autopsy determined the cause of death as “asphyxia by strangulation associated with craniocerebral trauma” — a severe head injury and strangulation. The death was ruled a homicide. JonBenét’s skull had an 8.5-inch fracture on the right side of her head, and a ligature was tied around her neck. This article does not describe the injuries beyond what the autopsy formally recorded, and it does not repeat the graphic detail that has circulated in the press.

The ransom note and the early investigation

The ransom note became the centre of the early investigation. It was unusually long — almost two and a half pages — and it demanded $118,000, a figure that matched, almost exactly, a bonus John Ramsey had recently received. Handwriting experts eliminated more than 70 people as possible writers of the note, but could not definitely say Patsy Ramsey had not written it. The ligature used was made with the broken handle of an artist’s paintbrush belonging to Patsy Ramsey.

The Boulder Police Department initially focused on the Ramsey family. The police theorised that the note and the condition of JonBenét’s body had been staged by her parents to conceal responsibility for the killing. That theory was never proved in court, and no member of the family was ever charged with her murder.

The handling of the scene is now widely regarded as having badly damaged the investigation from the outset. The house was not treated as a crime scene in the first hours. The first uniformed officer on the scene searched the house but did not open the latched door to the room where the body was later found. A friend opened the door in a later search but did not enter the room. Evidence was, in the judgement of later reviews, contaminated by the number of people who moved through the house that morning.

Boulder was, at the time, an affluent community whose police had little experience with murder cases. The district attorney, Alex Hunter, preferred to negotiate plea bargains rather than prosecute defendants in court. The police and the district attorney’s office disagreed about the case: while Boulder detectives assembled a case against Patsy Ramsey, Hunter’s office hired its own investigators, allowed the Ramsey family’s lawyers to review police files and physical evidence, and insisted detectives treat the Ramseys as victims rather than suspects. The police also rejected offers of help from both the Federal Bureau of Investigation and the Colorado Bureau of Investigation.

The grand jury

In 1998, Boulder County convened a grand jury to decide whether there was sufficient evidence to support any indictment. After thirteen months, it was announced that no charges would be filed. It was not until 2013, when court documents were unsealed, that the public learned the grand jury had in fact voted to indict John and Patsy Ramsey on charges related to permitting a child to be in a threatening situation, and on charges of hindering the prosecution of an unidentified person. District Attorney Alex Hunter declined to sign the indictment, saying there was insufficient evidence to prove the charges at trial.

In 1999, both the police and the district attorney stated that JonBenét’s nine-year-old brother, Burke, was not a suspect. That statement has not changed in the record.

The DNA evidence

In 2002, a new district attorney, Mary Lacy, assumed control of the case and advanced the theory that an intruder had entered the home and committed the killing. In 2003, trace DNA recovered from JonBenét’s clothing was found to belong to an unidentified male, and the Ramseys were excluded as contributors.

In 2008, Lacy sent the family a letter stating that John, Patsy and Burke Ramsey were cleared by the DNA results, and that they were no longer “under any suspicion in the commission of this crime.” She cited new testing that had matched “touch DNA” on JonBenét’s long johns to DNA previously found on her underwear, and concluded that the DNA came from the killer.

In 2009, the Boulder Police Department resumed control of the investigation. It continues to treat the case as an open homicide.

What the record shows

JonBenét Ramsey, six years old, was killed in her family’s home in Boulder, Colorado, on the night of 25 December 1996. Her body was found in the basement on the morning of 26 December. The autopsy recorded death by asphyxia by strangulation associated with craniocerebral trauma. A handwritten ransom note demanding $118,000 was found in the house. A grand jury in 1999 voted to recommend charges against her parents on counts that did not allege they had killed her; the district attorney declined to sign the indictment for lack of evidence. DNA found on JonBenét’s clothing belonged to an unidentified male and did not match any member of her family. In 2008 the district attorney wrote that the family was cleared; a later district attorney said that letter was not legally binding.

No one has been convicted of killing JonBenét Ramsey. The case remains open with the Boulder Police Department, which provides periodic public updates. In recent years, Boulder police and the family have pressed for advanced DNA and genetic-genealogy testing of the kind that has resolved other decades-old homicides.

JonBenét was six. She is the centre of this case, and the record — not the theories built around it — is the only honest account of what happened to her.

Sources

Leave a Comment