On the morning of Wednesday, January 15, 1947, Betty Bersinger walked with her three-year-old daughter along South Norton Avenue in the Leimert Park district of Los Angeles. She was on her way to run errands, and the street was the ordinary kind of street in a new middle-class neighbourhood, with vacant lots still waiting for houses. In the weeds of one of those lots she saw a pale shape lying close to the sidewalk. At first she thought it was a discarded shop mannequin, the kind of thing a person might dump in an empty lot. Then she understood what she was looking at, and she ran with her daughter to the nearest house to call the police.
The body was that of a young woman, lying unclothed in the grass, cut in two at the waist. There was no blood on the ground around her and no blood on her skin. She had been washed clean. There was no purse, no identification and no clothing anywhere near her. Within hours, fingerprints taken from the body and sent by wire to the Federal Bureau of Investigation in Washington matched records on file there, and the dead woman had a name: Elizabeth Short, twenty-two years old, of Medford, Massachusetts. She had been seen alive six days earlier, on the evening of January 9, at the Biltmore Hotel in downtown Los Angeles. No one has ever established where she spent the six days in between, or who she spent them with, or where she died.
What followed was one of the largest criminal investigations in the history of the Los Angeles Police Department, and one of the most heavily reported crimes in American history. Detectives questioned more than 150 people as possible suspects. Hundreds of men and women came forward to confess to a murder they had not committed. Newspapers gave the dead woman a nickname that outlived her by decades and turned her death into a national spectacle. And after nearly eighty years, after thousands of pages of files, after books and films and a hundred theories, the case remains officially open and officially unsolved. This is the record of what happened to Elizabeth Short, what the investigation found, and what it never found.
Elizabeth Short
Elizabeth Short was born on July 29, 1924, in Hyde Park, a working-class neighbourhood of Boston, and she was the third of five daughters of Cleo Short and Phoebe Mae Sawyer. Her father, a skilled mechanic and a veteran of the First World War, had started a business building miniature golf courses, which were hugely popular at the time, and the family moved to a comfortable house in Medford, about fifteen miles north of Boston. The stock market crash of 1929 ruined the business, and Cleo Short left the family. Phoebe Short moved her five daughters into a small apartment in Medford and found work as a bookkeeper, and it was there, in a household run by a single mother through the Depression, that Elizabeth grew up.
She was troubled from childhood by asthma and bronchitis, and at sixteen she was sent to spend the winter in Miami, Florida, where the warm air was easier on her lungs. For the next three years she lived in Florida during the cold months and in Medford for the rest of the year, earning money mostly as a waitress. The pattern of her life was set early: she moved often, she lived with friends and acquaintances rather than in a home of her own, and she was always looking for something better, a warmer place, a steadier job, a way into the life she wanted.
At nineteen she travelled to Vallejo, California, to live with her father, who was working at the Mare Island Naval Shipyard on San Francisco Bay. The two moved to Los Angeles in early 1943, but an argument ended the arrangement, and she left to take a job at the post exchange at Camp Cooke, an Army base near Lompoc, California, now Vandenberg Air Force Base. She then moved to Santa Barbara, where on September 23, 1943, she was arrested for underage drinking at a restaurant. The juvenile authorities sent her back to Medford, but she did not stay there long. She returned to Florida, with only occasional visits back to Massachusetts, and went on working as a waitress.
In Florida she met Major Matthew Michael Gordon Jr., a decorated United States Army Air Forces officer with the 2nd Air Commando Group, who was training for deployment to the China Burma India theatre of operations. She told friends that Gordon had written to her from India proposing marriage while he was recovering from injuries suffered in an airplane crash, and that she had accepted. Gordon died in a second crash on August 10, 1945, near Kalaikunda in West Bengal, India, one day after the bombing of Nagasaki and only weeks before the end of the Second World War. She later embellished the story, telling people that they had been married and had lost a child. Gordon’s fellow airmen confirmed that the two had been engaged, while his family denied any connection to her after her murder. The loss devastated her. After August 1945 she never held a steady job again, and she drifted between Medford, Chicago, Florida and Los Angeles.
In July 1946 she returned to Southern California to see an old boyfriend she had met in Florida during the war, Army Air Forces Lieutenant Joseph Gordon Fickling, who was stationed at Long Beach. She spent the last six months of her life in southern California, mostly in the Los Angeles area, staying with friends and acquaintances, hoping for modelling work or small film roles that never came. She had dark hair, a striking face, and a habit of dressing in black, and the people who knew her remembered her as a young woman who wanted, above all, to be noticed. She was twenty-two years old, and she had no fixed address, no steady income, and no one in Los Angeles who was responsible for her.
The Last Week
The last confirmed sighting of Elizabeth Short begins with a drive. On January 8, 1947, Robert Manley, a twenty-five-year-old married travelling salesman from South Gate, California, picked her up in San Diego, where she had been staying. The following day, January 9, he drove her back to Los Angeles, arriving at the Biltmore Hotel downtown at about half past six in the evening. He left her in the lobby. She told him she was meeting one of her sisters, who was visiting from Boston, that afternoon. Manley walked out through the grand entrance onto Olive Street, and that is the last moment of her life that the police were ever able to confirm.
What happened in the six days between January 9 and January 15 is the central blank in the case, and it has never been filled. Several people later claimed to have seen her in the days after she left the Biltmore, in restaurants and bars and on street corners around Los Angeles, but none of those claims could be confirmed, and the police treated January 9 as the last reliable sighting. She had no money of her own that anyone could trace, no telephone, and no address where a message could reach her. If she met someone in those six days, that person has never been identified. If she was held somewhere, that place has never been found. The week simply ends, on the morning of January 15, in a vacant lot in Leimert Park.
Manley became the first prime suspect, because he was the last known person to have seen her alive. Detectives questioned him at length, and on January 19 he took a polygraph examination, which he passed. He was cleared, and he remained cleared for the rest of his life. He died on January 9, 1986, exactly thirty-nine years after the evening he dropped Elizabeth Short at the Biltmore Hotel. The fact that the last person to see her alive could be cleared so quickly, and that no one could be found who had seen her after him, set the pattern for everything that followed: the investigation had a beginning and an end, but no middle.
A Morning in Leimert Park
Leimert Park in 1947 was a new neighbourhood, still half built, with stucco houses going up beside empty lots on streets that had only recently been laid out. The lot on the west side of South Norton Avenue, midway between Coliseum Street and West 39th Street, was one of those empty places, grown over with weeds. Bersinger’s discovery was reported within minutes, and the first officers on the scene understood at once that they were dealing with something beyond an ordinary homicide. The body had been placed deliberately, in full view of the street, only a few feet from the sidewalk, and yet there was no sign of a struggle and no blood anywhere near it.
The coroner’s office sent Dr. Frederick Newbarr, the county pathologist, to examine the body, and he carried out the autopsy on January 16. He concluded that Short had been dead for roughly ten hours when she was found, and that the cause of death was a cerebral haemorrhage and shock brought on by blows to the head and face. The body had been cut cleanly at the waist, between the second and third lumbar vertebrae, and it had been washed so thoroughly that no blood remained on it or around it. The killing, and everything done to the body afterwards, had taken place somewhere else. The vacant lot was only where the body had been left.
Identification came with a speed that surprised even the detectives. Short had been fingerprinted in 1943, when she applied for the wartime job at Camp Cooke, and her prints were on file with the FBI. Officers took fresh prints from the body and sent them to Washington by Soundphoto, a wire service that transmitted photographs, and the FBI matched them within about an hour. By the afternoon of January 15, the police knew the dead woman’s name, her age, her home town, and the outline of her life. What they did not know, and what they have never learned, was who had killed her.
The police searched the lot and the surrounding streets for anything she might have carried, and found nothing. No purse, no identification, no clothing. The following day, a handbag and a black suede shoe were reported found on top of a garbage can in an alley a short distance from Norton Avenue, about two miles from the lot, and the police recovered them. Whether they belonged to Short was never established beyond doubt, and like so much else in the case, they led nowhere.
The Biggest Investigation in Los Angeles
The Los Angeles Police Department treated the murder as one of the largest investigations in its history. Contemporary reports put the number of investigators assigned to the case in its early stages at around 750, drawn from the LAPD and other law enforcement agencies. Detectives interviewed hundreds of people, searched storm drains and abandoned properties and the ground around the Los Angeles River, and followed up thousands of leads. The investigation was led by Detective Harry Hansen and his partner, Detective Finis Brown, and it produced more than 150 people who were questioned as possible suspects, along with more than 300 interviews. A reward of ten thousand dollars was offered for information leading to the killer.
The scale of the effort was the problem as much as the solution. The reward and the publicity brought in a flood of tips, most of them useless, and a flood of confessions. About sixty people confessed to the murder during the original investigation, and over the decades that followed the number grew to more than five hundred. Some of the confessors were plainly seeking attention. Some were suffering from mental illness. Some had not even been born when Elizabeth Short was killed. Each confession had to be checked, and each one took time that could have been spent on real leads. The case became, by one account, the investigation that produced the highest number of false confessions in the history of the LAPD.
The investigation also exposed the weaknesses of the department itself. In September 1949, a Los Angeles County grand jury examined failures within the LAPD homicide unit, including its inability to solve several murders of women and children, and the Short case was among those considered. The scrutiny produced criticism and reform, but it did not reveal her killer. By then the trail was more than two years old, the witnesses had scattered, and the physical evidence had been handled by too many hands. The case file, which would eventually run to thousands of pages, remained open, and it has remained open ever since. The Los Angeles Public Library holds a clipping file on the case of some four thousand articles, spanning from 1947 to the present day, a measure of how long the public has refused to let the case go.
The Press Takes the Case
If the police investigation was one of the largest in the city’s history, the newspaper coverage was larger still. Los Angeles in 1947 was a city of competing daily papers, and the two Hearst papers, the Los Angeles Examiner and the Los Angeles Herald-Express, fought over the case from the first day. The Herald-Express first called it the Werewolf Murder. The name did not catch on, and within days the papers had settled on another one: the Black Dahlia.
Where that name came from is itself disputed, and the dispute has never been settled. According to newspaper reports published shortly after the murder, Short had received the nickname in mid-1946 from the staff and patrons of a drugstore in Long Beach that she frequented, as wordplay on the film noir The Blue Dahlia, released in April 1946 and starring Veronica Lake and Alan Ladd. Other accounts, including reports by investigators for the Los Angeles County district attorney, state that the nickname was invented by newspaper reporters covering the murder, and the Herald-Express reporter Bevo Means, who interviewed Short’s acquaintances at the drugstore, has been credited with first using it. The FBI’s own account says the press gave her the first part of the name for her rumoured penchant for sheer black clothes. What is certain is that the name was not one she was known by in life in any documented way, and that it was the name, more than any other single thing, that turned her murder into a national sensation. A homicide detective on the case later observed that the words themselves did the work: black is night and mystery, the dahlia is an exotic flower, and no other name would have carried the story so far.
The Examiner’s conduct in the first days of the case became a scandal of its own. The paper located Short’s mother, Phoebe, in Massachusetts, and offered to pay her airfare and accommodation if she would travel to Los Angeles to help the police investigation. It was a ploy. The newspaper kept her away from the police and from other reporters to protect its scoop, and it used her grief as material for its coverage. The Examiner and the Herald-Express both sensationalised the case, describing Short as an adventuress who prowled Hollywood Boulevard, and publishing details of her life that had nothing to do with her death. The coverage established a template that American true crime journalism would follow for decades: the nicknamed victim, the detailed account of the crime, the speculation about the dead woman’s private life, all of it presented as news. It also damaged the investigation. Reporters questioned witnesses before the police reached them, published unverified claims as fact, and turned a murder inquiry into a contest between newspapers.
The Envelope
Six days after the body was found, the case took a turn that has fascinated writers ever since. On January 21, 1947, a man claiming to be Short’s killer telephoned the office of James Richardson, the editor of the Los Angeles Examiner, congratulated the paper on its coverage, and said he planned to turn himself in eventually, but not before allowing the police to pursue him further. He told Richardson to expect some souvenirs of Beth Short in the mail.
Three days later, on January 24, a postal worker found a suspicious manila envelope addressed to the Los Angeles Examiner and other Los Angeles papers, its words cut and pasted from newspaper clippings. A large message on the face of the envelope, made from the same pasted letters, said that here were Dahlia’s belongings and a letter would follow. Inside were Short’s birth certificate, her social security card, a Greyhound baggage check, business cards, photographs, names written on pieces of paper, and an address book with the name Mark Hansen embossed on the cover, with several pages removed. The packet also held newspaper clippings of Major Gordon’s obituary and a Western Union telegram signed with the name Red. The envelope and its contents had been carefully washed in gasoline, apparently to remove fingerprints, in the same way the body had been washed clean.
The police treated the packet as possibly genuine, because only the killer would have had Short’s personal effects, and because the gasoline cleaning matched the care taken with the body. Several partial fingerprints were lifted from the envelope and sent to the FBI, but the prints were compromised in transit and could not be properly analysed. A second communication followed, a handwritten note received on January 26, which promised that the writer would turn himself in on Wednesday, January 29, at ten in the morning, and signed itself the Black Dahlia Avenger. No one turned himself in. A later note said the writer had changed his mind, that he would not be given a fair hearing, and that the killing had been justified. Whether any of these communications came from the killer, from a person who had found the belongings, or from a hoaxer feeding on the publicity, has never been established. The handwriting on the later notes was compared with samples from suspects for decades, and the comparisons were inconclusive.
The Suspects
Over the decades, the list of people investigated or accused in the Short case has grown into a cast of dozens, and it is worth setting out who they were, because the list itself tells the story of the investigation. The first was Robert Manley, cleared by polygraph within days. The second was Mark Hansen, a nightclub owner whose address book had arrived in the mailed envelope. Hansen admitted that he knew Short well, and detectives questioned him on January 25, 1947. He denied any romantic involvement, said she had borrowed his address book without his permission, and produced an alibi. He was never charged.
Others followed. A soldier named Joseph Dumais confessed to the murder and was questioned at length before detectives concluded that his account did not fit the evidence, and he was released. A bellhop named Leslie Dillon came to police attention in 1948 because he appeared to know details of the crime that had not been published, and he was detained and questioned before being released. Nearly seventy years later, the writer Piu Eatwell argued in her 2017 book Black Dahlia, Red Rose that Dillon, together with an associate named Henry Duke Lavery, had killed Short. The argument has not been accepted by the police, and it rests on interpretation rather than on evidence that was ever tested in court.
The most famous name attached to the case is that of Dr. George Hill Hodel, a prominent Los Angeles physician who owned the distinctive Sowden House in Hollywood. Hodel came to police attention during a 1949 grand jury investigation, which named him among twenty-two major suspects, including seven doctors. In 1950, during a renewed investigation, an eighteen-man task force of district attorney’s investigators and police officers wiretapped his home and office for about forty days. The transcripts, 146 typed pages, were released in 2003. In one recorded conversation, Hodel spoke to a visitor in hypothetical terms, saying that even if he had killed the Black Dahlia, the police could no longer prove it. The remark proves nothing on its own, and it has been quoted, paraphrased and argued over ever since, but it is the reason the theory has never gone away.
Hodel’s own son, Steve Hodel, a retired LAPD homicide detective, spent years building a case against his late father, and his 2003 book Black Dahlia Avenger became a bestseller. He pointed to the wiretap remark, to handwriting comparisons between his father’s writing and the mailed notes, to photographs he believed showed Short among his father’s belongings, and to his father’s documented history of violence toward women, including a 1949 trial in which Hodel was acquitted of a charge involving his own daughter. The handwriting comparisons were examined by independent experts who could not confirm a match either way. The LAPD, for its part, had investigated Hodel in 1950 and cleared him after a month-long inquiry, concluding that it could not prove he ever met Elizabeth Short. Hodel left the United States for Asia in 1950 and died in 1999, never having been charged with the murder. The novelist James Ellroy, who had fictionalised the case in his 1987 novel The Black Dahlia, endorsed Steve Hodel’s theory in 2004. More recent scholarship has argued the other way, noting that there is no convincing evidence Hodel and Short ever met, and that the police had built a nearly comprehensive timeline of her movements in Los Angeles during the six to eight weeks when both of them were in the city, a timeline that leaves little room for a secret relationship.
The police memorandum compiled by Lieutenant Frank Jemison in 1951 listed about twenty-five persons of interest in the Short case, though later writers have noted that not all of them were considered strong suspects, and that some names were included to show the thoroughness of the investigation. Among the other names that have been attached to the case over the years are Walter Bayley, a doctor whose daughter later claimed he had confessed; Francis Sweeney, a physician investigated in 1947; Fred Sexton, a mortuary worker; and George Knowlton, a man whose widow claimed he had knowledge of the crime. None of them was ever charged. No one, in nearly eighty years, has ever been charged with the murder of Elizabeth Short.
Why It Has Never Been Solved
There are cases that go unsolved because the evidence was thin, and cases that go unsolved because the evidence was ruined, and the Short case is both. The body was found in a vacant lot, not where the murder took place, so the scene that mattered was never found. The body had been washed clean, the mailed packet had been washed in gasoline, and the fingerprints that might have identified the sender of the packet were damaged before they could be analysed. The physical evidence that survived was handled by a department that was still learning modern forensic practice, in an era before DNA testing, before reliable fibre analysis, and before the kind of record-keeping that later investigations would take for granted.
The publicity made it worse. The newspapers contaminated witnesses, published rumours as fact, and kept the victim’s mother away from the police. The reward and the fame drew hundreds of false confessors, each of whom had to be investigated, and each of whom consumed time and attention that the real leads never got back. The investigation was, in the end, a victim of its own size. Seven hundred and fifty investigators, more than 150 suspects, thousands of leads, and no way to tell which of them mattered.
Time finished what the publicity had started. Witnesses died, memories faded, and the people who might have known something in 1947 were gone by the time new techniques arrived. George Hodel died in 1999. Robert Manley died in 1986. The detectives who worked the case, Harry Hansen and Finis Brown, are long dead. Periodic reviews of the file have taken place, and searches with ground-penetrating radar have been carried out at the Sowden House, but the file, for all its thousands of pages, has yielded no breakthrough. The case is still officially open, and the LAPD has consistently declined to close it, but no one now expects a prosecution. The killer, if he lived a normal lifespan, is dead, and the evidence that might have identified him was lost in the first weeks of 1947, in a vacant lot, in a gasoline-washed envelope, and in a flood of false confessions.
What remains is the record, and the record is worth keeping straight, because the case has become something larger than a murder investigation. It has become a story that Los Angeles tells about itself: a young woman who came to the city hoping to be noticed, a crime that was too strange to be forgotten, a police department that threw everything it had at the case and still failed, and a nickname that turned a dead woman into a legend. The books and the films, from James Ellroy’s novel in 1987 to the film adaptation in 2006, have kept the name alive, and each generation finds a new suspect to argue about. But the centre of the story is not the nickname, and it is not the suspects. It is Elizabeth Short, twenty-two years old, who was last seen alive in the lobby of the Biltmore Hotel on the evening of January 9, 1947, and who was found six days later in a vacant lot in Leimert Park, and whose killer has never been named.
Evidence Ladder
Verified
- Elizabeth Short was born on July 29, 1924, in Hyde Park, Massachusetts, and raised in Medford; she was twenty-two when her body was found on the morning of January 15, 1947, in a vacant lot on South Norton Avenue in Leimert Park, Los Angeles, and her last confirmed sighting was on January 9 at the Biltmore Hotel, where Robert Manley had dropped her off.
- The autopsy by Dr. Frederick Newbarr found that the cause of death was a cerebral haemorrhage and shock from blows to the head and face, and that the body had been washed clean, with no blood at the scene, showing that she had been killed elsewhere and her body transported to the lot.
- The LAPD questioned more than 150 people as possible suspects, received about sixty confessions during the original investigation, and made no arrests; the case file remains officially open, and the murder has never been solved.
Disputed
- The origin of the Black Dahlia nickname is unresolved: newspaper reports shortly after the murder said Short received it in mid-1946 from staff and patrons at a Long Beach drugstore, as wordplay on the film The Blue Dahlia, while district attorney investigators’ reports state that it was invented by newspaper reporters covering the murder, with Herald-Express reporter Bevo Means credited with first using it.
- Whether Dr. George Hodel ever met Elizabeth Short is unresolved: his son’s 2003 book argues that he did and that he killed her, while the LAPD investigators who cleared Hodel in 1950 said they could not prove the two had ever met, and more recent scholarship has argued there is no convincing evidence of any meeting.
- The mailed envelope of January 24, 1947, containing Short’s birth certificate, photographs and Mark Hansen’s address book, was treated by investigators as possibly sent by the killer because of the gasoline cleaning and the personal items, but the partial fingerprints recovered from it were compromised in transit and never analysed, so no sender was ever confirmed.
Rumour
- Claims that the Short murder is linked to the 1946 murder and dismemberment of six-year-old Suzanne Degnan in Chicago, advanced by Steve Hodel and other writers, rest on no evidence accepted by the police.
- Claims that Short was a secret mistress of George Hodel, or that photographs found among his belongings show her, were asserted by his son and have never been established by police investigation.
- Claims that the killer was a surgeon, or that the murder was the work of a serial killer operating in Los Angeles, are speculation; the LAPD never established either, and no other murder has ever been reliably connected to the case.
Case File
- What happened: Elizabeth Short, twenty-two, was found dead in a vacant lot in Leimert Park, Los Angeles, on the morning of January 15, 1947; she had last been seen alive six days earlier at the Biltmore Hotel, and her killer has never been identified.
- When: January 9 to 15, 1947
- Status: Unsolved
If the largest investigation in the history of the Los Angeles Police Department could not name the person who killed a twenty-two-year-old woman in the middle of a great city, how many other names from that winter are still waiting in the files?
Keep exploring: The Zodiac Killer: The Letters, the Codes, and the Case That Never Closed; D.B. Cooper: The Man Who Jumped Out of a Plane With $200,000 and Vanished; Lizzie Borden: Arrested, Tried, and Acquitted — the Case That Was Never Solved; The Lindbergh Kidnapping: The Crime That Changed American Law