The Trial of Joan of Arc (1431): Heresy, Politics and a Verdict Overturned

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

Few trials have been so thoroughly documented, and so thoroughly undone. The condemnation trial of Joan of Arc at Rouen in 1431 survives in detailed notarial records, and those same records enabled a second Church court, twenty-five years later, to declare the first trial null, invalid and fraudulent. Joan was about nineteen when she died. She was canonised in 1920.

A teenager in a war

Joan of Arc was born around 1412 at Domrémy, in north-eastern France, to Jacques d’Arc and Isabelle Romée. The exact year is not recorded. France was then deep in the Hundred Years’ War: the English and their Burgundian allies held Paris and much of the north, while Charles, the uncrowned French dauphin, held territory in the south.

According to the trial record, Joan said that from about the age of thirteen she had heard voices she identified as those of saints, urging her to support Charles and to see him crowned. Whether those voices were divine, as she believed, is a matter of faith, not something the historical record can settle. What the record does show is that she acted on that conviction with remarkable persistence. After gaining the support of Robert de Baudricourt, the captain at Vaucouleurs, she travelled to Chinon, where she met Charles in 1429, and was examined by theologians before being allowed to accompany the French forces.

Orléans and Reims

Joan entered the besieged city of Orléans on 29 April 1429, bringing supplies and troops. The city had been under English siege since October 1428, and its position on the Loire made it strategically vital. Within days, French forces took a series of English positions around the city, and on 8 May 1429 the English abandoned the siege.

The relief of Orléans transformed Joan from an unknown peasant girl into a figure of national importance. She then pressed Charles to march to Reims, the traditional city of French coronations. Towns along the route submitted, and on 17 July 1429 Charles was crowned Charles VII in Reims Cathedral, with Joan present near the altar holding her banner.

Her military career after Reims was shorter and less successful. An attack on Paris in September 1429 failed, and on 23 May 1430, during a sortie from Compiègne, she was cut off, pulled from her horse and captured by Burgundian troops. She was held for months, attempted to escape by leaping from a tower at Beaurevoir, and was then transferred to English control. Secondary accounts commonly report that the English paid 10,000 livres for her, though the precise terms are a matter for the historical sources.

The court at Rouen

The trial was an ecclesiastical one, held in Rouen, then under English occupation. It was presided over by Pierre Cauchon, Bishop of Beauvais, a supporter of the Anglo-Burgundian cause, with the inquisitor Jean le Maistre as the second judge. In practice, theologians from the University of Paris took a prominent part as assessors. The proceedings began in February 1431 and ran until the end of May.

Joan was questioned at length about her voices, her clothing, her military actions and her submission to the Church. The original list of charges ran to about seventy articles, later condensed into twelve. The central accusations were heresy and witchcraft, with particular attention paid to her claim that her voices came from God and to her wearing of men’s clothing, which the court treated as a grave offence against Church teaching. She had no legal counsel in the modern sense, and she was held in a military prison under English guard rather than in an ecclesiastical prison, a point the later rehabilitation trial would treat as a serious irregularity.

The trial record preserves Joan’s answers, often in confident and direct language, but readers should be careful about treating the published transcripts as a word-for-word record. The proceedings were taken down in Latin by notaries, with a French minute kept by the trial recorder Guillaume Manchon — a formal, translated record, not a stenographic transcript in the modern sense.

Abjuration, relapse and sentence

On 24 May 1431, under threat of execution, Joan signed or accepted a document abjuring her voices and agreeing to wear women’s clothing. She was sentenced to perpetual imprisonment. Within days, however, she had resumed men’s clothing and withdrawn the abjuration. The court treated this as relapse into heresy. A short relapse hearing was held on 28 and 29 May, and she was condemned as a relapsed heretic. She was handed over to the secular authorities, and on 30 May 1431 she was burned at the stake in the Place du Vieux-Marché, the old market square in Rouen. She was about nineteen years old. Contemporary accounts report that her ashes were scattered in the River Seine, to prevent the gathering of relics, although that detail rests on later testimony rather than on a surviving official record of the execution itself.

The rehabilitation trial

The case did not end in Rouen. In 1450, Charles VII ordered a preliminary inquiry, led by the theologian Guillaume Bouillé. After the end of the Hundred Years’ War, Joan’s mother, Isabelle Romée, petitioned the Pope for a formal review. Pope Callixtus III authorised a new proceeding, the Trial of Nullification, which opened in Paris on 7 November 1455.

The rehabilitation court heard testimony from more than a hundred witnesses, including people who had known Joan as a child and companions from her campaigns. Its commissioners included Jean Jouvenel des Ursins, Archbishop of Reims, and Jean Bréhal, the Grand Inquisitor of France, who prepared a summary of the errors of the 1431 trial, known as the Recollectio.

On 7 July 1456, the commissioners pronounced the original trial null, invalid and fraudulent, and declared Joan innocent. The verdict found the 1431 proceedings tainted by deceit, intimidation and errors of law and theology. The rehabilitation restored her good name, but not sainthood: she was beatified in 1909 and canonised by Pope Benedict XV on 16 May 1920.

What the record shows

Documented: Joan was born around 1412 at Domrémy; she entered Orléans on 29 April 1429 and the siege was lifted on 8 May; Charles VII was crowned at Reims on 17 July 1429; she was captured at Compiègne on 23 May 1430; she was tried at Rouen in February–May 1431 under Bishop Pierre Cauchon, abjured on 24 May, was condemned as a relapsed heretic on 29 May and burned at the stake on 30 May 1431; a rehabilitation trial declared the condemnation null on 7 July 1456; she was canonised on 16 May 1920.

Disputed or unverified: The exact year of Joan’s birth is approximate, and the sum paid for her transfer to the English is reported as 10,000 livres in secondary accounts. The claim that her ashes were scattered in the Seine rests on later testimony, not on a surviving execution record. The trial transcripts are Latin notarial records, not verbatim modern transcripts, and the divine origin of her voices is a matter of faith, not of historical proof.

Sources

Leave a Comment