Charles Arthur Floyd did not like his nickname. “Pretty Boy” was given to him by others, and he hated it — he preferred to be known as a serious man. But the name stuck, and it followed him through a career of bank robberies across the American Midwest, through the bloodiest law enforcement killing of the decade, and to his death in an Ohio cornfield in 1934.
Floyd was the last of the great Depression-era bank robbers to die. He was also the most ambiguous of them: a man who robbed banks and was blamed for murdering four lawmen, yet who was mourned in his home state of Oklahoma as a folk hero. The songs written about him after his death praised him for destroying mortgage papers during robberies — a claim that may be more legend than fact, but which tells us something about how he was seen.
An Oklahoma outlaw
Floyd was born on 3 February 1904 in Adairsville, Georgia, and raised in Oklahoma. His family were poor farmers, and he left school early. His first crimes were small — theft, bootlegging, a payroll robbery in St. Louis in 1925 for which he served time in prison. By the early 1930s, he was robbing banks across Oklahoma, Kansas, Missouri and Arkansas, usually with a small gang, usually in daylight, and usually without killing anyone.
The nickname came from somewhere in this period. One account says it was given to him by a victim’s wife, who described the polite young robber as “a pretty boy”. Another says it came from a wanted poster description. Floyd himself said he disliked it. The press loved it.
Floyd’s reputation in Oklahoma rested on more than robbery. He was said to be generous with the money he stole, helping neighbours and destroying mortgage documents during bank raids. The mortgage story is told in Woody Guthrie’s ballad “Pretty Boy Floyd”, written in 1939, which presents him as a Robin Hood figure. Whether he actually destroyed mortgages is not established — no bank records confirm it — but the story took hold because it fitted the mood of the Depression, when banks were foreclosing on farms across the Midwest.
The Kansas City Massacre
On 17 June 1933, Floyd’s name became attached to a massacre. That morning, at Union Station in Kansas City, Missouri, federal agents and local police were transferring a prisoner, Frank Nash, from a train to a car. Gunmen opened fire. Four lawmen were killed — FBI agent Raymond Caffrey, police chief Otto Reed, and two detectives — along with Nash himself.
The FBI blamed Floyd and his associate Adam Richetti. The evidence was thin: witnesses gave conflicting descriptions, and no one was ever tried for the shooting. Floyd denied any part in it. Later research has questioned whether Floyd was involved at all, and some historians believe the killers were other men — possibly associates of the Kansas City crime boss who wanted Nash silenced before he could talk.
Whether or not Floyd fired a shot that morning, the massacre made him the FBI’s most wanted man. J. Edgar Hoover’s Bureau, still young and eager to prove itself, put enormous resources into finding him. The case also helped to build the case for giving federal agents the right to carry guns and make arrests — powers they did not fully have at the time.
The death in the cornfield
On 22 October 1934, FBI agents led by Melvin Purvis found Floyd on a farm near East Liverpool, Ohio. The accounts of what happened next differ. The Bureau’s version is that Floyd drew a gun and was shot in a gunfight. Others who were present said Floyd was already wounded and may have been trying to surrender when he was killed. What is certain is that Floyd was shot twice and died at the scene.
His body was taken to East Liverpool, where it was put on display in a funeral parlour. Thousands of people came to see it. He was buried in Oklahoma, and his funeral drew a large crowd.
Adam Richetti, Floyd’s associate, was tried for the Kansas City Massacre and executed in 1938 — the only person ever convicted for it. The question of who actually fired the shots at Union Station has never been settled.
Floyd’s afterlife has been longer than his career. Woody Guthrie’s ballad made him a folk hero. He has been portrayed in films and books ever since, usually as a charming rogue rather than a killer. The truth is more complicated: he was a bank robber who, in all likelihood, never set out to kill anyone — but whose name became attached to one of the worst killings of the decade, and who died for it.
What the record shows
- Charles Arthur Floyd was born on 3 February 1904 in Adairsville, Georgia, and raised in Oklahoma. He became a bank robber in the early 1930s, working across the Midwest.
- On 17 June 1933, four lawmen and the prisoner Frank Nash were killed at Union Station, Kansas City, Missouri, in what became known as the Kansas City Massacre. The FBI blamed Floyd and Adam Richetti.
- Floyd was killed on 22 October 1934 near East Liverpool, Ohio, by FBI agents led by Melvin Purvis. His body was displayed publicly in East Liverpool, and he was buried in Oklahoma.
- Adam Richetti was convicted of the Kansas City Massacre and executed in 1938. Woody Guthrie’s ballad “Pretty Boy Floyd” (1939) presented Floyd as a folk hero.
- Disputed/unverified: Floyd’s involvement in the Kansas City Massacre is disputed — the evidence against him was circumstantial, and later research has questioned whether he was present. Whether Floyd was shot while resisting or while trying to surrender is also disputed. The story that he destroyed mortgage papers during bank robberies is widely told but not confirmed by bank records.
- Unresolved: No one else was ever convicted for the Kansas City Massacre, and the identity of all the gunmen has never been established.