The Amistad Trial: The Africans Who Took Back Their Freedom

Reading Time: 4 minutes ·

In the summer of 1839, a Spanish slave ship called La Amistad was sailing along the coast of Cuba when the Africans in its hold broke free. They had been kidnapped from Sierra Leone, sold in Havana, and loaded onto the ship to be taken to another part of Cuba. On the night of 2 July, led by a man named Sengbe Pieh — known to the Americans as Joseph Cinqué — they rose up, killed the captain and the cook, and took control of the ship.

What happened next turned a slave revolt into one of the most important trials in American history. The Africans did not reach Africa. They reached the United States. And there, in a courtroom, they had to prove that they were not property — that they were free people who had been stolen.

The revolt and the capture

The 53 Africans aboard La Amistad were Mende people from what is now Sierra Leone. They had been captured, marched to the coast, and sold to Spanish traders in Havana in defiance of treaties that banned the Atlantic slave trade. Spain had outlawed the trade, but it continued in secret, and the traders had forged papers claiming the Africans were Cuban-born slaves.

Cinqué and the others killed the captain, Ramón Ferrer, and the cook, Celestino. They spared two Spanish traders, José Ruiz and Pedro Montes, and ordered them to sail the ship back to Africa. Ruiz and Montes obeyed by day and steered north by night. For two months the ship drifted up the American coast.

On 26 August 1839, the United States Navy brig Washington seized La Amistad off the coast of Long Island, New York. The ship was brought to New London, Connecticut. The Africans were jailed in New Haven, and the legal fight over their fate began.

Who owned them?

The case was a tangle of competing claims. Ruiz and Montes said the Africans were their property. The Spanish government demanded their return under a treaty with the United States. The American government, under President Martin Van Buren, sided with Spain — the administration did not want a case about slavery in an election year, and the president hoped to keep the support of Southern voters.

The Africans’ lawyers argued something simpler: the 53 men, women and children had been kidnapped in Africa and sold illegally. They were not slaves under Spanish law, because they had never legally been enslaved. They were free people, and their revolt was self-defence.

The case was first heard in the federal circuit court in Hartford, Connecticut, before Judge Andrew Judson. In January 1840, Judson ruled that the Africans had been illegally kidnapped and were free. The government appealed to the Supreme Court.

John Quincy Adams

The Africans’ cause was taken up by abolitionists, including the lawyer Roger Sherman Baldwin and the wealthy merchant Lewis Tappan, who raised money for their defence. For the Supreme Court hearing, they persuaded John Quincy Adams to argue the case.

Adams was 73 years old, a former president and now a member of the House of Representatives. He had been arguing against slavery for years. He agreed to take the case, and he spent weeks preparing. On 24 February 1841, he rose in the Supreme Court and spoke for eight hours over two days. He called the case the most important of his life.

The Court’s decision came on 9 March 1841. Justice Joseph Story, writing for a seven-to-one majority, held that the Africans were free. They had been kidnapped and sold in violation of Spanish law, and they had acted in self-defence when they seized the ship. The Court ordered them released. Only one justice, Henry Baldwin, dissented in part.

The journey home

The decision was a sensation. The Africans were free, but they were also penniless and far from home. Abolitionist supporters raised money for their return, and in January 1842, 35 survivors sailed back to Sierra Leone. The others had died of disease while in American custody. Cinqué returned to find his village destroyed by war and his family gone, but he lived out his life in Sierra Leone.

The Amistad case did not end slavery in America. That would take another two decades and a civil war. But it was the first time the Supreme Court had ruled in favour of enslaved people claiming their freedom, and it showed that the courts could be used against the slave system. It also made the case a touchstone for abolitionists, and it remains one of the most famous trials in American history — retold most recently in Steven Spielberg’s film Amistad (1997).

What the record shows

  • On 2 July 1839, 53 kidnapped Mende Africans led by Sengbe Pieh (Joseph Cinqué) seized the Spanish schooner La Amistad off Cuba, killing the captain and the cook. The ship was captured by the USS Washington off Long Island on 26 August 1839 and brought to Connecticut.
  • The case was heard first in Hartford, Connecticut, where Judge Andrew Judson ruled in January 1840 that the Africans had been illegally kidnapped and were free. The United States government appealed to the Supreme Court.
  • Former president John Quincy Adams argued the case before the Supreme Court in February 1841. On 9 March 1841, the Court ruled seven to one that the Africans were free and ordered their release.
  • In January 1842, 35 survivors returned to Sierra Leone. The others had died of disease while in American custody.
  • Disputed/unverified: The exact number of Africans who died in custody varies slightly between accounts, and some details of the voyage — including how long the ship was at sea — differ between contemporary reports.
  • Unresolved: The case settled the fate of the 53 Africans, but it did not settle the wider question of slavery in the United States, which was only resolved by the Civil War and the Thirteenth Amendment in 1865.

Sources

Leave a Comment